Digital Spy Forums

Digital Spy Forums (http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/index.php)
-   TV Shows: UK (http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   BBC4 - Albums - Great Album Showdown (http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showthread.php?t=1795287)

alcockell 05-02-2013 21:18

BBC4 - Albums - Great Album Showdown
 
Hi folks,

New series striped through till Friday culminating in When Albums Ruled the World - anyone else watching?

pinkyponk34 05-02-2013 21:39

This must have been the pay-off that Baker got when the Beeb ditched his Radio Show , he's allowed to front a TV series about his abiding passion, tedious prog-rock albums of the early 1970's.

He's quite a engaging fellow but get him on the subject of Emerson Lake and Palmer and one would be forgiven for lashing him to Ritchie Blackmore's 4x 12 Marshall stack and pushing it in the Thames.

Oh no, and there's that awful Top Gear git as well.

NathanBarley 05-02-2013 21:54

It's pretty good.

vauxhall1964 05-02-2013 21:58

70s rock... not my favourite subject and their conservative, predictable choices haven't convinced me otherwise. Tomorrow's pop programme can only be a breath of fresh air compared to that.

alcockell 05-02-2013 22:01

And of course, this is where my We7 subs come into their own - playing out the stuff after they mention it.

LostFool 05-02-2013 22:03

Really enjoyed the programme. Danny Baker is one of my favourite broadcasters (though he's better on the radio) and Jezza is always good value - even though, embarrassingly, I would have picked 2 of the 3 albums that he did.

Time to dig out some neglected music from the dark reaches of my MP3 collection...

SgtRock 05-02-2013 22:09

I enjoyed the show, but one thing has never changed over the years. Danny Baker always sounds entirely at home on radio, yet put him on TV and he always sounds as though he's trying a little too hard...

alcockell 05-02-2013 22:10

And of course - while a lot of the acts hadn't played TOTP or ITV's stuff... out came the old OGWT clips :)

Rodney McKay 05-02-2013 22:12

Well I'm glad to see the back of vinyl albums, I hated the bloody things, the scratches, the jumping, the having to get up and turn it over.

Enjoyed the show though. The bird was rather fit as well :)

tinman 05-02-2013 23:17

I could listen to DB all day.

drykid 05-02-2013 23:29

The concept of the show sounds actually quite appealing to me, but Clarkson... no thanks. It's a shame they decided to start the series that way. I guess I'll try catching a later one instead.

mr muggles 05-02-2013 23:40

All too predictable - except the snatches of Joni Mitchell & Frank Zappa.

Straker 06-02-2013 00:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr muggles (Post 64090509)
All too predictable - except the snatches of Joni Mitchell & Frank Zappa.

Most music programming on the Beeb ends up re-hashing the same old same old. The world doesn’t need any more programmes about or featuring The Beatles or The Rolling Stones or Led Zeppelin or David Bowie or Pink bloody Floyd. It’ll be the same tomorrow with all the most obvious choices on display and in a set of programmes like this where it’s largely down to the personal choice of four different people every time that’s just rather pitiful.

Enjoyed the section on album artwork and can only echo Baker’s “could do a whole programme on this”, and yet....they’re not. :rolleyes:

tennisman 06-02-2013 01:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by tinman (Post 64090058)
I could listen to DB all day.

Agreed. He's a marvellous breath of fresh air.

Also agree about him being better on radio but he's still pretty good on TV - I'll live with his slight discomfort with the medium.

I love discussions like this where people talk for a better understanding of a subject as opposed to being pitched against each other on polarised extremes.

Even Clarkson was bearable.

Add this to the Stuart Maconie's documentary about 1962 and an interesting picture is being built about the changes in recording techniques, production capabilities and differences between then and now.

Yes, some of it can be a bit pretentious but no more than numerous other aspects of our pop culture, sport or social behaviours. Is football, as Shankley said not a question of life or death but far more important than that or 22 blokes chasing a pig's bladder around? On reflection, probably both :D

Sent Baker a tweet via his 5Live show page but it will probably get merged with, I assume, many others in the BBC machine.

Also love Baker's side kick Danny Kelly on Talksport - broadcasting with brains which creates laughter and new insight while definately getting the gray matter going.

tennisman 06-02-2013 01:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by Straker (Post 64091337)
Most music programming on the Beeb ends up re-hashing the same old same old. The world doesn’t need any more programmes about or featuring The Beatles or The Rolling Stones or Led Zeppelin or David Bowie or Pink bloody Floyd. It’ll be the same tomorrow with all the most obvious choices on display and in a set of programmes like this where it’s largely down to the personal choice of four different people every time that’s just rather pitiful.

Enjoyed the section on album artwork and can only echo Baker’s “could do a whole programme on this”, and yet....they’re not. :rolleyes:

What would you prefer, Straker?

DANCE OF DEATH 06-02-2013 01:53

I have done back to vinyl. The sound is much more better from vinyl than a CD. Yes vinyl can be sratched, but if care is taken over them they can last for years without been scratched. CDs' just sound so tinny and for my liking there is no depth a recording on CD.

I enjoyed the show well considering it was about Rock and Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple, Black Sabbath , The Who were the pionners to rock. So they should be shown.

I also agreed with the guests choices as there was some iconic albums amonst them.

QwertyGirl1771 06-02-2013 02:02

I thought it was a great programme and will have to listen to some of the artists which were mentioned such as Lou Reed, King Crimson and Frank Zappa to name a few.

Dirtyhippy 06-02-2013 09:07

I really enjoyed the show, programmes about vinyl are always going to attract a rather conservative crowd as vinyl is a very conservative medium. Like it or not 70's rock (in all is guises) IS the face of vinyl and so deserves its attention and publicity.

If you want watch eclectic or edgy programmes about music don't tune into a nostalgic show about vinyl.

Tracy 06-02-2013 11:41

Can anyone put up the list of the 13 albums in the rock wall of sound I want to give them all a listen to and can only remember about 5 of them.

Paul_Andrews1 06-02-2013 12:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tracy (Post 64094744)
Can anyone put up the list of the 13 albums in the rock wall of sound I want to give them all a listen to and can only remember about 5 of them.

King Crimson (In the court of the crimson king)
joni mitchell(Summer of hissing lawns)
frank zappa (we're only in it for the money and hot rats)
jon hiseman's colisseum (for those about to die, salute you)
rumours (fleetwood mac)
ziggy stardusr (bowie)
sheer heart attack (queen)
dark side of the moon (pink floyd)
london calling (the clash
transformer (lou reed)
crime of the century (supertramp)
physical graffitti (led zeppelin)http://images.digitalspy.co.uk/forum/smilies/smile.gif

Virgil Tracy 06-02-2013 12:36

it was pretty good , pleased to see Clarkson have the guts to nomm Supertramp (who are largely ignored now ) .

a bit patronising to young people tho , I would bet that more 20-somethings have bought a vinyl album in the last year than 50-somethings have .

I read somewhere recently that vinyl sales have gone up massively in the last couple of years .

Marroo 06-02-2013 12:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rodney McKay (Post 64088683)

Enjoyed the show though. The bird was rather fit as well :)

I thought that too ! :):)

Andy2 06-02-2013 12:53

I'm just catching this show on BBC i-player and the question 'what first album did you buy with your own money/' set me thinking. I can't decide whether mine was The Bonzo's 'Gorilla' or the Moody Blues' 'Days of Future Passed'.
Must go and watch the reat, looks like a great nostalgia-fest!

abivan 06-02-2013 15:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andy2 (Post 64095960)
I'm just catching this show on BBC i-player and the question 'what first album did you buy with your own money/' set me thinking. I can't decide whether mine was The Bonzo's 'Gorilla' or the Moody Blues' 'Days of Future Passed'.
Must go and watch the reat, looks like a great nostalgia-fest!

Have just watched on catch up and it really was a nostalgia-fest. Especially the fact that you would sit there with your headphones on and listen to everyone second of every track before turning the record over. These days I'm as guilty as anyone for listening to spotify and skipping songs (sometimes midway through!) What a wonderful programme and I'd never have known it was on if it wasn't for this thread..roll on the next show.

P.S. There really should be an hour long show devoted to the artwork.

StaxVolt 06-02-2013 16:32

Storm Thorgerson,best known for Hipgnosis' artwork for Floyd,Zeppelin,Black Sabbath etc. albums,could take up an hour on his own.

Sky Arts recently did an hour on album cover artwork I think.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:48.