I was initially very pleased with this news and I think Frank Skinner is a great choice of host, but the format change disappoints me. As other people have said it's a bit too panel show, which is the last thing TV needs right now.
I wouldn't say the old format got tired but the guests towards the end of the run mostly weren't very good and Paul perhaps was getting sick of the show.
The only other show I can think of off the top of my head that had a similar format was TV Heaven Telly Hell. I enjoyed that too.
I've been thinking for a while that Charlie Brooker and David Mitchell would be perfect guests on this show, I hope they get them on now it's been revived.