Some very poor editing resulted in a lot of inconsistencies but overall I really enjoyed it. Scott didn't manage to recapture the tension of Alien or populate the cast with likeable characters I cared about but all was not lost. I enjoyed the exploration scenes, the alien scenes and the characters of David and Vickers. I'd love to see an ultimate edition with the deleted scenes restored. It feels like half a movie. I'm eager to see the next chapter in the tale if there's a sequel however.
Yeah i agree with you on this.