I watched Jagged Edge a few days ago. Jeff Bridges was very hot indeed in that, a man with a great physique.
As for my vote I really don't think I can separate Paul Newman and Elvis. Both beyond stunning men. I've also read comments and heard interviews about Elvis being the most handsome man in the flesh, even more so than in pics.
I was lucky enough to actually see Elvis in the flesh. He was so beautiful with the most lovely smile (those cheekbones!) and lovely blue eyes. I have sometimes seen photos of him where his eyes appear to be brown but I saw them in real life and they were blue.
He was signing autographs and I could hardly take my eyes off him he was THE most handsome man you could ever imagine.