Jeez, are we still arguing over who is the most famous pre IAC and post IAC, who is the nastiest, who is the most successful, who is the most rich, who is suffering the most, who is the best looking, who uses the kids more, who is wooden on telly.
Compare his success to a singer - he fails
Compare her success to a model - she failed (most recently)
As Artless said they are both the same.
You just need to admit you prefer one to the other. Personally she is what she says on the Tin. He however fails to convince me he is who he says he is and therefore he is up for more criticism.