Options
Melanie is sweet but...
Abigail88
Posts: 4,742
Forum Member
✭✭✭
(and if you look at my previous posts I have supported her) but all this raving about her is doing her no good. Her song was sung well but it was not stand out-ish and it did nothing for me. Neither did her audition.
I feel like I'm going crazy because everyone seems to love her, but honestly if you listen to her, her voice is not anything special!
I feel like I'm going crazy because everyone seems to love her, but honestly if you listen to her, her voice is not anything special!
0
Comments
I think what would be cruel is all this hyping up and then sending her home at Judges Houses.
the fact she nearly broke down but managed to pull herself back is brilliant.. without doubt deserves her top place...
And the crying at the end was just to put her through gets too much really!!
Janet was slaughtered because she was rubbish though Patsy, and she was from Northern Ireland, so was British.
It's got nothing to with Melanie being Irish and is ridiculous to suggest otherwise. Tesco Mary is Irish and was hugely popular, she even topped the votes on some weeks,
Isn't her family friends with Louis ? Maybe that's why she went through ?
I agree. People are saying about her song choice - I had to really think to remember what she even sang......
Nope....she said the first time she had a conversation with him was at the show in 2011.
It was a rather dull and tuneless ballad by Katy Perry.
Melanie's audition was fantastic - so much passion and emotion, easily one of the top 2 along with Hannah. Tamera demonstrated once again that she isn't ready for this. Very shouty and desperate. I can't even imagine how she would have handled being in Melanie's position as the last singer. I think she would have been a wreck. Abi was interesting at first but I was bored by the end of her song.
Tamera has more potential than Melanie though, and that is what they are looking for.
Melanie is a good singer, she does not deserve the slating she is getting at all. But it is mostly from fans of her competition so should be disregarded. I say best of luck to all the girls.
What I did not like tonight was her crying etc, just sing already and don't be desperate. Its not the end of the world is it, if she goes home. I believe daffyd's with the spoiler going by the editing tonight, she is not really Nicole's cup of tea. But I think Melanie has a lot more in her locker than we seen tonight, the editing of her singing was scrappy and awful.
Who was the Irish girl who Louis said was a friend of the family ?
He said he knew her family from her previous auditions.
I agree, this girl is brilliant.
I have no vested interest nor have a favourite from the girls yet. However I think Melanie is very run of the mill.
Not really we looking for right now... if it is potential surely they should be sent home and told to reapply?