Options
The 'darkest' things that have happened in Doctor Who
[Deleted User]
Posts: 1,152
Forum Member
✭✭✭
Thought this might be an interesting thread, especially to think about the things that aren't exactly at the foreground of the story or aren't addressed.
Rewatching 'Utopia', I realised how incredibly bleak it was, despite the somewhat optimistic tone throughout most of it. Every surviving human in it will go to Utopia, the last reminiscence of hope, only to find nothing. Then they regress into a hive mind and are turned into heads in spheres, and kill their ancestors for fun.
Also, the Earth the Doctor leaves behind at the end of 'Parting of the Ways' is left decimated, it is implied. not to mention the fact that the Doctor "made" that version of Earth in the first place.
Those are just of the top of my head, but I'm sure there are pleanty!
Rewatching 'Utopia', I realised how incredibly bleak it was, despite the somewhat optimistic tone throughout most of it. Every surviving human in it will go to Utopia, the last reminiscence of hope, only to find nothing. Then they regress into a hive mind and are turned into heads in spheres, and kill their ancestors for fun.
Also, the Earth the Doctor leaves behind at the end of 'Parting of the Ways' is left decimated, it is implied. not to mention the fact that the Doctor "made" that version of Earth in the first place.
Those are just of the top of my head, but I'm sure there are pleanty!
0
Comments
Has to be the appointment of this poster who takes broken record to either robotic or autistic levels.
I hope for your sake you are a spambot who posts the same thing automatically because your contributions add nothing except for discussions about how wrong you are.
Next.
Though if you look at their posts in other threads they are quite sensible....maybe DariaM is a trekkie resentful that Who is on air and ST isn't.
And now I'm sad
Although I wouldn't call it a misstep; it's certainly very bleak, but I do think it's one of the most powerful moments emotionally in the show.
Then you have Blink- pure terror.
And what of the finale?! And by finale I mean it as a three parter with Utopia included. The very end of humanity, the return of the Master, the horrific revelation about the origin of the Toclafane, the torture of Jack, the damage to Marthas family. And alot more. Even the stupid Goblin Doctor couldn't spoil it.
I loved where RTD took the show in that season. It stays with me like no other.
I assumed that this episode was a foreshadowing of a very dark Christmas where the Doctor would be more Jekell than Hyde, more Angelus than Angel, etc, and the arc they were building up to would be someone who knew him previous would see what he'd become and put a stop to it by killing him.
Then you'd have an 11th Doctor being very remorseful and trying to atone what he'd done.
I guess that's why I should never predict who plotlines, I wasn't even close
Also: Midnight. Just a group of people in a room.
Chilling.
I love that moment. It is more jarring on rewatching as tonally that finale is all over the place. After the cheese ball, cheering/laughing out loud moments with the Tardis towing the earth home you then have the frankly bizarre resolution of Roses story which fits uneasily and then the all out tragedy of Donna and the mindwipe. He clearly had no choice though did he? She would be dead otherwise. It was a kindness albeit a cruel one.
YANA! That's pretty much what ai thought. My jaw remained dropped right up until the first five minutes or so of the End of Time when with the silly central locking of the Tardis and garlands they basically reversed over everything that had gone before. There were some dark and intense moments in that episode but it didn't go where I had hoped. I wish RTD had been a bit braver. How dramatic to have had Rose or Wilf having to 'kill' Ten to stop him from destroying everything! But I accept this is a family show and sometimes it shouldn't be too dark. Part of me still thinks theres an unwritten finale for Ten which takes it in that direction and it wouldve been classic television. Really classic and era defining. Shame it didn't happen.
Potentially meeting Satan was always going to make for a dark story, but this was made better by the Doctor's beliefs being challenged and the degree of uncertainty at the end- did the Doctor actually just meet Satan, the embodiment of evil?
Some of the quotes are pretty dark:
"Some may call him Abaddon. Some may call him Krop Tor. Some may call him Satan. Or Lucifer. Or the King of Despair. The Deathless Prince. The Bringer of Night. And these are the words that shall set him free."
[To members of the crew]
"The captain, so scared of command.
The soldier, haunted by the eyes of his wife.
The scientist, still running from Daddy.
The little boy who lied.
The virgin.
And the lost girl, so far away from home. The valiant child, who will die in battle so very soon..."
"You get representations of the horned Beast right across the universe in myths and legends of a million worlds. Earth, Draconia, Vel Consadine, Daemos... The Kaled god of war, the same image, over and over again. Maybe, that idea came from somewhere. Bleeding through, a thought of every sentient mind...
Originating from here?
Could be.
But if this is the original, does that make it real? Does that make it the actual Devil?
Well, if that's what you want to believe. Maybe that's what the Devil is, in the end. An idea."
I love these two episodes. By far the best in Series 2.
It starts off all fun, and comedic and "All hail the big talking bird!", but then it gets really dark, and disturbing.
Moffat once said it was his favorite Sixth Doctor story, and I can see some parallels between it and "The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances". But it's sort of the opposite in terms of how it ends.
I'm with you on that one, two of my all-time favourite episodes.
He didn't hang about did he? Whoosh! I'm taking those memories! Poor Donna.
Agreed. It is very brutal and I only realized on watching it again quite how much. It makes it all the more disappointing for me that Clara hasn't really gotten any better throughout the rest of S7 as her performance in those final scenes is amazing.
I thought series 4 quite pointedly suggested to Donna being desperately unhappy living a facade of a life she thought she should with the Doctor. That she had been totally demoralized by her mother and therefore started to try and live another life, one which wasn't her fantasy but the desire of the person who treated her well... Wilf (as followed through in The End of Time where we see how much he is suffering from no longer having Donna to live his life through).
For me the darkest moments of season 4 weren't when she lost her memory but those moments of despair when Sylvia's disdain cut Donna. Such a contrast from previous seasons where the mothers love was such a dominant feature. The ending for me while certainly sad was also sweet, she'd lost the Doctor but found her mothers unconditional love and support.
That's what I thought the point was?!
Took me a while to realise that while Rose didn't techincally die, she is listed as a casualty after this battle so he wasn't even lying.
But in the End, the Doctor got one over on Satan, so that's not that bad going
Another vote for The Impossible Planet and The Satan Pit. I thought the image of Scooti's dead body floating in space, getting closer to the black hole with everyone just watching was one of the most disturbing scenes in Doctor Who ever.
Memories only fade a little, always there, like the stars. The Doctor makes the stars come back, like crying and laughing at the same time.:D