Options

'You and I' is Lady Gaga's greatest

Peter Venkman

Peter Venkman Posts: 1,769

Forum Member

✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 07:12 in Music #1

She should do more country rock. Fantastic isnt it?

0

Comments

Options
Micknsiv Posts: 187
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 07:44 #2

Peter Venkman wrote: »

She should do more country rock. Fantastic isnt it?

Nope.

0
Options
chrisqc Posts: 1,291
Forum Member
✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 08:13 #3

Its ok but far from her best

0
Options
dee123 Posts: 46,271
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 12:25 #4

Um. No. That would be The Edge Of Glory.

0
Options
Anika Hanson Posts: 15,629
Forum Member
✭✭

25/11/13 - 13:58 #5

So happy I could die

0
Options
jadebutterfly96 Posts: 1,534
Forum Member
✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 14:15 #6

My vote goes to the Edge of Glory, just slightly edging over Bad Romance.

0
Options
AdzPower Posts: 4,861
Forum Member
✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 14:48 #7

It's awful, Edge of Glory is by far her best single.

0
Options
LandslideBrad Posts: 5,085
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 15:21 #8

No thanks, Judas and LoveGame are her best singles Imo.

0
Options
Hogs Head Posts: 21,361
Forum Member
✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 15:52 #9

I can't even remember it

0
Options
pothuthic Posts: 47,103
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 15:59 #10

Miranda Lamberts cover was better tbh

0
Options
[Deleted User] Posts: 7,003
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 16:03 #11

I like it a lot, but it's not her best. Bad Romance and The Edge of Glory are, I think.

0
Options
ali1234 Posts: 1,292
Forum Member
✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 16:32 #12

it is one of her greatest vocals for sure. along with speechless, bad romance (the way she sings "want your bad romance" towards the end of the song... woah), aura, do what you want (the way she sings the second "what you want with my body") and dare i say it, dope. really powerful and emotional.

0
Options
Diceroll_81 Posts: 904
Forum Member
✭✭

25/11/13 - 17:28 #13

pothuthic wrote: »

Miranda Lamberts cover was better tbh

Haley Reinhart did a really good version on American Idol a few years back as well.

0
Options
cnbcwatcher Posts: 56,681
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 18:05 #14

I think it's awful. It should have never been released as a single.

0
Options
tim18 Posts: 737
Forum Member
✭✭

25/11/13 - 18:07 #15

It is good but it shouldnt have been a single. It should of been schesse or hair

0
Options
Peter Venkman Posts: 1,769
Forum Member
✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 18:33 #16

Micknsiv wrote: »

Nope.

There's opinions from only 3 people I'm gonna respect my whole life. That's my daddy and Nebraska and JESUS CHRIST.

:mad:

0
Options
Makson Posts: 30,489
Forum Member
✭✭✭

25/11/13 - 18:39 #17

That would be Dance In The Dark.

0
Options
[Deleted User] Posts: 846
Forum Member
✭✭

25/11/13 - 19:11 #18

Single - Paparazzi
Album Track -So Happy I Could Die or Dance In The Dark

0
Options
[Deleted User] Posts: 203
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 19:16 #19

Nah, You & I is good but should never have been a single.

Her best would be Scheisse or Edge of Glory. Possibly Gypsy.

0
Options
Sex Posts: 44,161
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 19:41 #20

One of her best.

0
Options
shelleyj89 Posts: 16,292
Forum Member
✭✭

25/11/13 - 20:53 #21

I'm not really a Lady Gaga fan, and I think You & I is her best song.

0
Options
Eric_Blob Posts: 7,756
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 21:37 #22

I hate Lady Gaga, but I think You and I is her most unique song, and definitely the riskiest thing she's ever done.

0
Options
Micknsiv Posts: 187
Forum Member
✭

25/11/13 - 22:05 #23

Peter Venkman wrote: »

There's opinions from only 3 people I'm gonna respect my whole life. That's my daddy and Nebraska and JESUS CHRIST.

:mad:

Good for you man. Good for you. :cool:

0

or Register to comment.