Girls Aloud vs The Saturdays

Luner13Luner13 Posts: 2,968
Forum Member
✭✭✭
Compare their 17 singles in the order they were released.


Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
No Good Advice or Up
Life Got Cold or Issues
Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
The Show or Work
Love Machine or Forever Is Over
I'll Stand By You or Ego
Wake Me Up or Missing You
Long Hot Summer or Higher
Biology or Notorious
See The Day or All Fired Up
Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
Walk This Way or Gentleman
Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
Call The Shots or Not Giving Up
«13

Comments

  • Luner13Luner13 Posts: 2,968
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    GA - 8
    The Saturdays - 9
  • Hollie_LouiseHollie_Louise Posts: 39,751
    Forum Member
    GA - Sound Of The Underground
    GA - No Good Advice
    GA - Life Got Cold
    GA - Jump
    TS - Work
    GA - Love Machine
    TS - Ego
    GA - Wake Me Up
    TS - Higher
    GA - Biology
    TS - All Fired Up
    GA - Whole Lotta History
    GA - Something Kinda Ooh
    TS - What About Us
    TS - Gentleman
    GA - Sexy! No, No, No
    GA - Call The Shots

    GA - 11
    TS - 6
  • Ally_BowieAlly_Bowie Posts: 618
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    This was harder than I thought it would be. But no matter how much I love Not giving up Call The Shots is just perfect pop everything about that record is magic, girls aloud never topped that one for me, Untouchable came close though...in the same way as much as I love the Saturdays, All Fired Up is by far the best record they have achieved in my opinion, even the campaign for that was spot on, artwork, bsides, video, promo, and performances, they never have topped that one for me.

    Sound of the Underground
    Up
    Life Got Cold
    Just Can't Get Enough
    Work
    Forever Is Over
    Ego
    Missing You
    Higher
    Biology
    All Fired Up
    My Heart Takes Over
    30 Days
    What About Us
    Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No...
    Call The Shots

    Girls Aloud 5
    Sats 12
  • Mark-AnthonyMark-Anthony Posts: 572
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Sound of the Underground
    Up
    Issues
    Jump
    The Show
    Love Machine
    I'll Stand By You
    Missing You
    Higher
    Biology
    See The Day
    My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh
    What About Us
    Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No...
    Call The Shots

    Definitely think ill be the only person who prefers see the day to all fired up but ive always thought all fired up was very overrated and see the day underrated
  • LandslideBradLandslideBrad Posts: 5,085
    Forum Member
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up (I had to google NGA though but I don't like Up because of the lack of Rochelle)
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious (This one is so close, I love both songs)
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    I'm a fan of The Saturdays...not so much of Girls Aloud but GA won :o
    9-8
  • ScottishWoodyScottishWoody Posts: 23,215
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    GA- Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    GA- No Good Advice or Up
    TS- Life Got Cold or Issues
    TS- Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    GA- The Show or Work
    GA- Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    TS- I'll Stand By You or Ego
    GA- Wake Me Up or Missing You
    TS- Long Hot Summer or Higher
    GA- Biology or Notorious
    TS- See The Day or All Fired Up
    GA- Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    GA- Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    TS- I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    TS- Walk This Way or Gentleman
    GA- Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    GA- Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    GA - 10
    TS - 7
  • kryskryskryskrys Posts: 3,322
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    Girls Aloud - 12
    The Saturdays - 5
  • sward669sward669 Posts: 621
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,086
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground
    Up
    Issues
    Jump
    Work
    Forever Is Over
    Ego
    Wake Me Up
    Higher
    Biology
    All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History
    Something Kinda Oooh
    What About Us
    Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No...
    Call The Shots

    Sats - 9
    GA - 8
  • ritchie2ykritchie2yk Posts: 5,550
    Forum Member
    Sound of the Underground
    No Good Advice
    Life Got Cold
    Jump
    The Show
    Love Machine
    I'll Stand By You
    Wake Me Up
    Long Hot Summer
    Biology
    All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History
    Something Kinda Oooh
    I Think We're Alone Now
    Walk This Way
    Sexy! No No No
    Call The Shots

    So close to a clean sweep but all fired up is a Sats
    Classic and luckily it came up against see the day which was crap
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 42
    Forum Member
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    The Saturdays - 13
    Girls Aloud - 4
  • AdzPowerAdzPower Posts: 4,861
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,736
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up
  • cnbcwatchercnbcwatcher Posts: 56,681
    Forum Member
    I love both GA and the Sats so this'll be hard, but anyway:

    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    So GA 8 Saturdays 9
  • KieranDSKieranDS Posts: 16,545
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Sound of the Underground
    No Good Advice
    Life Got Cold
    Jump
    The Show
    Love Machine
    I'll Stand By You
    Missing You
    Long Hot Summer
    Biology
    All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History
    Something Kinda Oooh
    What About Us
    Walk This Way
    Sexy! No No No
    Call The Shots
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 6,204
    Forum Member
    If This is Love
    Up
    Issues
    Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show
    Forever Is Over
    Ego
    Wake Me Up
    Higher
    Biology
    See The Day
    Whole Lotta History
    Something Kinda Oooh
    I Think We're Alone Now
    Walk This Way
    Disco Love
    Call The Shots
  • Littlegreen42Littlegreen42 Posts: 19,963
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    GA - 13
    SATS - 4

    Like comparing a vintage wine to Ribena.:D
  • robjames69robjames69 Posts: 2,394
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    Girls Aloud - 5
    The Saturdays - 12

    :o
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 553
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Luner13 wrote: »
    Compare their 17 singles in the order they were released.


    Sound of the Underground(/B) or If This is Love
    (B)No Good Advice(/B) or Up
    (B)Life Got Cold(/B) or Issues
    (B)Jump(/B) or Just Can't Get Enough
    (B)The Show(/B) or Work
    (B)Love Machine(/B) or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or (B)Ego(/B)
    (B)Wake Me Up(/B) or Missing You
    (B)Long Hot Summer(/B) or Higher
    (B)Biology(/B) or Notorious
    See The Day or (B)All Fired Up(/B)
    (B)Whole Lotta History(/B) or My Heart Takes Over
    (B)Something Kinda Oooh(/B) or 30 Days
    (B)I Think We're Alone Now(/B) or What About Us
    (B)Walk This Way(/B) or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or (B)Disco Love(/B)
    (B)Call The Shots(/B) or Not Giving Up

    GA = 14
    TS = 3
  • SparklySwedeSparklySwede Posts: 1,112
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    Girls Aloud by a long shot, I am so not a fan of The Saturdays since Notorious. Having said that, my first thought on seeing this thread was about Gentleman being rubbish, but then saw which GA track it was up against. :p

    To be fair I am fond of The Saturdays but I just don't like their more recent releases. Except 30 Days. Some of the earlier ones were more difficult to choose between and I might think differently about GA's first releases on another day..
  • ChrisJamesSatsChrisJamesSats Posts: 458
    Forum Member
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up
  • LMLM Posts: 63,250
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    The saturdays were better in their early days, while for me Girls aloud were better in their later days.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,280
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    GA - 8 vs SATS - 9

    Closer than I thought.
  • BluestoneBluestone Posts: 2,253
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    GA 5
    The Sats 12
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 25,501
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sound of the Underground or If This is Love
    No Good Advice or Up
    Life Got Cold or Issues
    Jump or Just Can't Get Enough
    The Show or Work
    Love Machine or Forever Is Over
    I'll Stand By You or Ego
    Wake Me Up or Missing You
    Long Hot Summer or Higher
    Biology or Notorious
    See The Day or All Fired Up
    Whole Lotta History or My Heart Takes Over
    Something Kinda Oooh or 30 Days
    I Think We're Alone Now or What About Us
    Walk This Way or Gentleman
    Sexy! No No No... or Disco Love
    Call The Shots or Not Giving Up

    Girls Aloud 7 - 10 The Saturdays
Sign In or Register to comment.