Options
Tulisa or Sharon.. your preferred judge?
InMyArms
Posts: 50,794
Forum Member
✭
We've seen both judges in action, so we're perhaps (compared to previous judging changes) in a unique position that we know their styles and how they are on the show. So.. was the right decision made?
Tulisa or Sharon.. who would have preferred out of the two? 186 votes
Tulisa
36%
68 votes
Sharon
63%
118 votes
0
Comments
Actually wish we had Kelly and America had Sharon, I think that would have been better balance to both panels
Nicole is like a toned down version of Kelly so suits the UK show perfectly. I don't think the two of them on the same panel would work.
From this poll, Sharon. She should inject a bit of life into the panel and gel it together. Ironically Sharon was the weak link last time and they took her out to be replaced by Cheryl who brought the panel together after a divide. I imagine the same will happen again here.
I don't mind Tulisa, but she'd probably be more suited to The Voice than X Factor.
To be honest, I think you can only do The X Factor for a couple of years. There's only so much feedback you can give.
The panel perhaps should change every couple of years, bar Louis of course, who's a fixture.
Next year I think it will be Simon instead of Gary. When, I imagine, X Factor USA will be history.
There have always been arguments on the show, with or without Sharon. Louis is usually involved in most of them, and usually starts them too.
to be fair, most of the judges think too highly of themselves, but i just didnt "get" tulisa
or
an old hip bitter lady who only cares about her needs.
Neither
Watch the Aus. version then.
Honestly you were wittering on about Dannii Minogue coming back. Now you have her you're still going on. You should be pleased.
At last!! Someone talking sense.
You've already accused Sharon of being an alcoholic in another thread, now you mention her age - you have every right to dislike, and no one is expecting you to be over the moon, but to get personal is uncalled for.
Sharon is good box office but you would have to query how relevant she is and she didn't emerge well from stories about her rivalry/bullying of Danni Minogue.
There was never any bullying.