Non Gaga fans

Rams_Lord · 23/02/14 - 12:43

Non Gaga fans, do you prefer GUY or Venus. There is a fan base war at the moment on which one would do better as a single. Which song do you like the most if your not a Gaga fan

dearmrman · 23/02/14 - 12:50

As I am not a Gaga fan, I can honestly say I haven't heard either track, and I am not likely to what with not being a fan.

WhyHelloWorld · 23/02/14 - 12:52

Neither will do well. GUY screams 'fan appeal' but not 'wide appeal'. Venus is far too over-produced to do anything. She should have gone with MANiCURE or Gypsy. Or gone totally out there and gone with Dope. It's not a great album, so whatever song she releases won't do well. If I HAD to say out of GUY and Venus which would do better, it would be Venus. It's instantly more catchy.

Aura101 · 23/02/14 - 13:42

Why on earth would 'non-gaga fans' vote on a poll about gagas music ?

You have lost me.

Are you insinuating there are a group of people out there who don't like Gaga but still obsess over her ?

ali1234 · 23/02/14 - 14:54

I don't get why non gaga fans would even know Venus or guy

Master Ozzy · 23/02/14 - 16:39

I'm indifferent to Gaga...I don't love her or hate her. I just gave both tracks a listen out of interest. I think that out of the two, G.U.Y is more commercial. However, I don't think it's anything special. It's just camp, bubblegum pop and I'd even go as far as to say it sounds slightly dated. I think the problem with Gaga is that when she first started she was something new and different...she dressed in outrageous costumes and did strange things and she had an album full of good, crazy pop songs. I think now though maybe the novelty has worn off. I just gave her whole album (the latest one) a listen and it just sounds like an album of cheap, bubblegum pop. Her first album was pop, but it sounded fresh, current and it had an edge.

boddism · 23/02/14 - 17:02

Rams_Lord wrote: »

Non Gaga fans, do you prefer GUY or Venus. There is a fan base war at the moment on which one would do better as a single. Which song do you like the most if your not a Gaga fan

Im decidedly not a fan! To me this is like having to choose between cancer or a heart attack!! I dislike both tracks. I think of the 2 GUY is the least objectionable. Venus is a hot mess-only the chorus is really strong. Neither of these tracks will be massive IMO.
Its blinding obvious that Gypsy (or Manicure) are the clear singles from ARTPOP. If she can't see this she's a bigger fool than I think she is.