Saw it last night and enjoyed it, although i did feel that the outstanding visuals were let down somewhat by the fairly by the numbers storyline. If it weren't for the cinematography and direction i'd probably be far less impressed with it. The acting was great though from everyone involved, particularly Matthew Goode who portrays a quietly menacing character in a brilliant way.
While it felt long for a 90-ish minute film, it sure as help was one of the most engaging trips to the cinema I've had in a while. Beautifully shot, brilliantly scored by Clint Mansell, and the three central performances are superb. Kidman does what she does best; cold, detached, vulnerable. But Mia Wasikovska was astonishingly good from start to finish. The denoument was telegraphed a little, but it didn't stop this being a superb experience, Park Chan Wook has managed to transition into English language film while keeping the unsettling air which made Old Boy lso good (and which Hollywood will no doubt kill completely in the remake.
ok , Park Chan Wook is a brilliant director , he's like Kubrick , every shot is lovingly crafted , hypnotic , I'll watch anything he makes , but this is slow , I think I'll prefer watching it again on tv .
the plot is basically one of those psychological dramas where you're not sure if the main character is imagining all or some of it , each scene is filled with symbolism , I'm sure in the future there will be long essays written about the meanings of each scene (it's full of childhood symbolism : drawings , forgotten traumas, eggs etc.) , but on a first viewing its hard to get involved you're not sure what its supposed to mean .
Stoker is really great film and looking foward to collecting it once it's out on dvd.
They want to make Stoker into a trilogy.
Matthew Goode and did really well in their roles.
Carey Mulligan, Kristen Stewart, Rooney Mara, Emily Browning, Emma Roberts, Bella Heathcote and Ashley Greene were considered to play India Stoker.
Carey Mulligan and Jodie Foster were originally cast but both dropped out and were replaced by Mia Wasikowska and Nicole Kidman.
Colin Firth, James Franco, Joel Edgerton, and Michael Fassbender were considered for the role of Uncle Charlie. Firth was actually cast, but he dropped out and was replaced by Matthew Goode.
Oh christ, Fassbender would have been superb, got nothing against Matthew Goode's performance but if there was a weak link in the film it was probably him, he was a bit too...... gurney.
Oh christ, Fassbender would have been superb, got nothing against Matthew Goode's performance but if there was a weak link in the film it was probably him, he was a bit too...... gurney.
I dunno , Fassbinder's great , but the part required some aspects of reverting to childhood which Goode did really well .
I really enjoyed this movie in a weird sort of way...
I kinda didnt want it to end... I kinda felt that Indias and Charlies relationship coulda been developed a bit more :sleep:
Please could someone explain the scenes in which Jacki Weaver was in?
From her first appearance at the front door to when she made a call in her motel room regarding her missing mobile? I'm sure she had a scene at the dinner table in the house? I am asking because l was a bit tired so l may have closed my eyes for a couple of minutes during the time she was in the film!
Comments
When the TV spot said "From the Director of Oldboy" I thought they meant the US remake (which I havent seen)
18 year old girls Dad dies and her long-lost Uncle appears with an unhealthy interest in her........but so much more than that ;-)
May try and check Stoker out (Oldboy is a great film)
Funnily enough when I was watching it I thought to myself how cool and understated she is in it.
I think she could be Hollywood royalty now.
the plot is basically one of those psychological dramas where you're not sure if the main character is imagining all or some of it , each scene is filled with symbolism , I'm sure in the future there will be long essays written about the meanings of each scene (it's full of childhood symbolism : drawings , forgotten traumas, eggs etc.) , but on a first viewing its hard to get involved you're not sure what its supposed to mean .
They want to make Stoker into a trilogy.
Matthew Goode and did really well in their roles.
Carey Mulligan, Kristen Stewart, Rooney Mara, Emily Browning, Emma Roberts, Bella Heathcote and Ashley Greene were considered to play India Stoker.
Carey Mulligan and Jodie Foster were originally cast but both dropped out and were replaced by Mia Wasikowska and Nicole Kidman.
Colin Firth, James Franco, Joel Edgerton, and Michael Fassbender were considered for the role of Uncle Charlie. Firth was actually cast, but he dropped out and was replaced by Matthew Goode.
I dunno , Fassbinder's great , but the part required some aspects of reverting to childhood which Goode did really well .
couldn't disagree there, I'm not saying he wasn't good, it's just the one role which left soem room for improvement imho.
Goode was perfect at being slightly smarmy but beguiling.
I kinda didnt want it to end... I kinda felt that Indias and Charlies relationship coulda been developed a bit more :sleep: