Spice girls to replace Posh?
Pele-thefiregoddess
Posts: 6,170
Forum Member
✭
To be honest it sounds very unlikely and a hideous decision .....
http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/news/a468007/victoria-beckham-quits-spice-girls-tv-show-to-find-replacement.html
But if they did decide to replace Posh .... Who would make a good replacement?
http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/news/a468007/victoria-beckham-quits-spice-girls-tv-show-to-find-replacement.html
But if they did decide to replace Posh .... Who would make a good replacement?
Who should replace Posh Spice? 43 votes
Cheryl Cole
13%
6 votes
Fergie
0%
0 votes
Dannii Minogue
2%
1 vote
Natasha (Atomic Kitten)
0%
0 votes
Louise (ex Eternal)
2%
1 vote
Leona Lewis
2%
1 vote
Unknown
2%
1 vote
Stay As 4
67%
29 votes
Audition from Reality Show
2%
1 vote
Other
6%
3 votes
0
Comments
They should carry on as a fourpiece as they have not really lost much in the vocals department.
But if they were to appoint a replacement I'd love to see them get Nadine Coyle in just to annoy Cheryl; Kimberley & Nicola for permanently splitting GA up.
Another member will never work and sure as won't work if it's another well know person from another well know girl group.
I think Ive made my point....:D
That is why I have selected the option 'stay as 4' and given my reasons to justify my choice. Jeez you can't really start a poll and then tell the people who contribute to it to lighten up
If it did happen Jenny Frost would suit it vocally
to be honest all the girls are doing well. Mel C can carry on with West End Shows and her music. Mel B seems to be doing well as one of SImon Cowell's panelist. Emma Bunton has Heart Breakfast, a gig most female DJ's would kill for, so she should count herself lucky and Geri is erm......going on the tube, so I think the Spice Girls should be left where they are and if another event like OLympics comes up I am sure VB could be talked round
I think they should just get an unknown to replace Victoria. Replacements have been done before in Destiny's Child and The Sugababes, and the other four girls obviously want to milk the Spice brand for all it's worth so I don't think it would be that bad an idea....
What did Victoria actually contribute to the group anyway, she never seemed like a main member until after she married David. Maybe a replacement could work as she is obviously happy with her own life and appears to want to put the girls behind her.
I vote for stay as a 4. Victoria barely sung anyway so her presence in the group has never been a memorable one.
It's all five or nothing for me.
Geri stood out in the band and was loud, plus she at least sang.
Posh was always in the background, and hardly did anything.
The lost it's spark when Geri left, however if Posh left there is not much difference in my opinion. The remaining 4 can carry the group.
Plus when Geri left, the band was more a band of 3 (Mel B, Emma, and Mel c )...as again posh was in the background doing that dumb hand movement thing. With Geri now, it will still feel like a band, and as spicier then ever
FORFSAKE - Posh did not even sing at the concert, instead she did a dumb catwalk thing. No point in having her, and the others don't need her attitude.
She can go back to what she calls fashion.
I personally hope the remaining four do something:):D:p:o
<
Posh Spice