Not sure how I feel about the judges knowing who cooked the menu before the end of tasting. Seems a touch unfair considering the cliquey nature of these programmes.
Not sure how I feel about the judges knowing who cooked the menu before the end of tasting. Seems a touch unfair considering the cliquey nature of these programmes.
yes i like it as a blind judging...corrigan showed how favouritism works on this
There leaning too heavily on this idea of 'Comedy', Id be really surprised if someone can cook a dish which makes them laugh without resorting to stupid props.
Not sure how I feel about the judges knowing who cooked the menu before the end of tasting. Seems a touch unfair considering the cliquey nature of these programmes.
yes i like it as a blind judging...corrigan showed how favouritism works on this
I agree but I think previously even though they weren't supposed to know the camera man gave it away as he went from a shot of the dish they'd just eaten to the photo of the chef on the wall
I think they had to bring in the celeb judge because they wanted more chefs during the week but only two on the Friday.
they have reduced the amount of actual cooking shown so drastically and most of the programmes during the week were extended ads for restaurants that they could change the format to an hour long show with the 3 chefs being judged in a blind tasting by the judging panel.....there appears to be a lot of marking by the chef judges for mates or people with reputations whether they make errors or ignore the brief totally....unless that was just this week, hopefully it improves
Comments
http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-radio/tvandradioblog/2012/jun/08/great-british-menu-rude-chefs?intcmp=239
yes i like it as a blind judging...corrigan showed how favouritism works on this
Completely agree, would have been more of a contest between Matt and Tom.
agree with all of the above
Completely ignored it from what I can see
they have reduced the amount of actual cooking shown so drastically and most of the programmes during the week were extended ads for restaurants that they could change the format to an hour long show with the 3 chefs being judged in a blind tasting by the judging panel.....there appears to be a lot of marking by the chef judges for mates or people with reputations whether they make errors or ignore the brief totally....unless that was just this week, hopefully it improves