Options
Am I only one who thinks Melanie is not that great ?
Maxine_Roch
Posts: 5,193
Forum Member
✭
I'm not doubting that she can sing and is talented but when she sings I just don't feel it I don't feel like she has that star quality for me .
0
Comments
Nothing special about her at all IMO
My thoughts exactly.
It is called the X Factor not the "best trier and non giver upperer".
If she had the X factor she would not be on try number 4
I think her look improved loads but he voice is still the same from her first audition. She needs to improve it in order to be a contender
i was never a fan of Jade... but i hope they do not break her heart again... this is like her 6th attempt isnt it?
I don't remember her from previous years either (this is the first time I've watched the audition shows, I usually only watch the lives) so I'm basing my opinion purely on what I saw last night.
You know full well there are many people slating her.
I however think she's incredible.
To be fair she is probably the best looking girl in the comp at the moment so if she doesn't have the look the others must be truly f**ked.