I would rather have Nicole and Mel B on the same panel. They'd be like chalk and cheese it would be funny
I don't like the idea of Mel B and Sharon being on the same panel. You need a gentle judge e.g. Nicole. I think the panel would be too harsh having both Mel and Sharon.
I love the both of them. I actually think they would work together better than Nicole & Sharon. I am just against Sharon returning! Nicole and Mel would be perfect because Nicole can be the sugar-coating funny and bubbly one while Mel can be the B*tc*
Nicole by a longgggggg shot. People found Mel B "entertaining and honest' - I found her rude and ignorant plus she has such little talent (if any) therefore she has no right to be a Grade A b*tch.
Nicole is talented, beautiful, funny, a great mentor and totally stole the show last year. Team Nicole!
I'd like them both to be on it I like Sharon she's a good judge but a bad mentor plus she's been on it before and I want to see someone new. But if I had to pick between Nicole and Mel I would pick Nicole.
Was in the audience and saw both of them last year (Mel in Manchester, Nicole in Newcastle on her first day) and Nicole is a far superior judge. Mel is just nasty to the contestants for no reason in particular, and then gets annoyed when the audience boos her.
I'd rather Mel B instead of Sharon. But since Sharon is confirmed Nicole is best alongside her.
I can just imagine the rows between Mel B and Sharon already if they were on the same panel.
Comments
Out of those 2, Nicole.
Now if you made a poll between Nicole and Louis or Mel B and Louis. Mel B and Nicole would both win by a landfall.
I don't like the idea of Mel B and Sharon being on the same panel. You need a gentle judge e.g. Nicole. I think the panel would be too harsh having both Mel and Sharon.
Nicole is talented, beautiful, funny, a great mentor and totally stole the show last year. Team Nicole!
Mel B is a much better judge.
a Sharon / Mel B would be a too much as much as i love both
I can just imagine the rows between Mel B and Sharon already if they were on the same panel.