Adele vs Amy Winehouse

[Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,270
Forum Member
✭✭✭
thought this would be intresting

Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good"
Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

so close!!

Amy - 5
Adele 4
«1

Comments

  • Zack06Zack06 Posts: 28,304
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good"
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    Amy - 8
    Adele - 1
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 11,275
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    Adele 4 Amy 5
  • Hav_mor91Hav_mor91 Posts: 17,183
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Hometown Glory
    Take The Box
    In My Bed/You Sent Me Flying
    **** Me Pumps/Help Yourself
    Rolling In The Deep
    You Know I'm No Good
    Back To Black
    Tears Dry On Their Own
    Turning Tables

    Amy Winehouse 6 Adele 3. Huge fan of Both so shocked i was expecting a more balanced outcome but Amy the clear winner.
  • mialiciousmialicious Posts: 4,686
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Amy.W
  • mialiciousmialicious Posts: 4,686
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    oooopsy
  • gpkgpk Posts: 10,206
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    wow, this has to be the hardest so far for me.:eek:

    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me (both great débuts)
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab (both their signature songs)
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black (by far my favourite songs from both artists)
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    a total cop out this time for me, but its 6 a piece.:o its so tough for me though, because i really do feel adele had the better songs initially. while they both delivered amazing songs on the second albums and then all my favourites were vs each other.:o the best album by far though is amy`s `back to black`.:)
  • LMLM Posts: 63,325
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good"
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    Amy's second album alone for me is so much better than anything most British females have ever done. I love Adele but Back to black is more worthy of 25/30 million sales than 21 is.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,280
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good"
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own (just)
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    Adele - 4 vs Amy - 5
  • robo2robo2 Posts: 1,470
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    9-0 for adele in my eyes, amy winehouse is only rated because she is dead and i have never liked her music despite her and adele having similar sounds, i like rehab but its not better than rolling in the deep, so 9-0 adele
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 2,904
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Well Adele wins in the still being alive stakes.........
  • my name is joemy name is joe Posts: 4,450
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    robo2 wrote: »
    9-0 for adele in my eyes, amy winehouse is only rated because she is dead and i have never liked her music despite her and adele having similar sounds, i like rehab but its not better than rolling in the deep, so 9-0 adele

    tbf she was rated whlle she was living just not as highly, early death has a tendency to put you in the 'genius' camp. Rehab is one of her most annoying imo and not in the same stratosphere as RITD, but Love is a losing game is quality.

    i'll go with about 7-2 to Adele
  • konebyvaxkonebyvax Posts: 9,120
    Forum Member
    tbf she was rated whlle she was living just not as highly, early death has a tendency to put you in the 'genius' camp. Rehab is one of her most annoying imo and not in the same stratosphere as RITD, but Love is a losing game is quality.

    i'll go with about 7-2 to Adele


    Pretty much agree with all this.
  • Littlegreen42Littlegreen42 Posts: 19,963
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good"
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    Adele - 2
    Amy - 7

    Besides Emeli Sandé, Adele is the most overrated singer/songwriter of our generation.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,115
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Amy Winehouse for all.
  • Colin HuntColin Hunt Posts: 141
    Forum Member
    tbf she was rated whlle she was living just not as highly, early death has a tendency to put you in the 'genius' camp

    Agreed. Amy was an outstanding singer imo, and we'll never know how good / big she could have become.

    Adele is also very very good.
  • mimicolemimicole Posts: 50,916
    Forum Member
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    6 - Amy
    3 - Adele
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 183
    Forum Member
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger Than Me was a close one!
    Chasing Pavements vs Take The Box
    Cold Shoulder vs In My Bed/ You Sent Me Flying Cold Shoulder is one my favourite Adele songs but In My Bed is one of my favourite songs ever.
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** Me Pumps/Help Yourself
    Rolling In The Deep vs Rehab
    Someone Like You vs You Know I'm No Good
    Set Fire To The Rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour Has It vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning Tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    Adele - 2
    Amy - 7
  • GoodLuckCharmGoodLuckCharm Posts: 200
    Forum Member
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game
  • robo2robo2 Posts: 1,470
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Hometown Glory vs Stronger than me
    Chasing Pavements vs Take the box
    Cold Shoulder vs In my bed/ You sent me flying
    Make You Feel My Love vs F*** me pumps/Help yourself
    Rolling in the deep vs Rehab
    Someone like you vs You Know I'm No Good"
    Set fire to the rain vs Back to Black
    Rumour has it vs Tears Dry on Their Own
    Turning tables vs Love Is a Losing Game

    Adele - 2
    Amy - 7

    Besides Emeli Sandé, Adele is the most overrated singer/songwriter of our generation.

    i feel that way about amy winehouse, never got the whole she revolutionised music in the noughties nonsense, she just copied the 60's soul sound (like adele has also done, before anyone starts moaning)
  • Louise-annLouise-ann Posts: 1,110
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Ah no contest in this one all Amy's tracks. I've never liked an Adele song.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 0
    Forum Member
    The only song of Adele's that I really like is Skyfall.
    Amy wins by a landslide for me.
  • RobertfitzRobertfitz Posts: 2,732
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I think to pit these two against each other you have to take whole albums into consideration
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,573
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Robertfitz wrote: »
    I think to pit these two against each other you have to take whole albums into consideration

    Adele is talented but she will never make an album as good as Back To Black. I'm sure of that.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 0
    Forum Member
    Adele is talented but she will never make an album as good as Back To Black. I'm sure of that.

    This! Adele is young & I do think she's talented but Amy's music & lyricism wins hands down.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,270
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Adele is talented but she will never make an album as good as Back To Black. I'm sure of that.

    ^^ very true
Sign In or Register to comment.