"Character Driven" isn't always an excuse for poorly written...
Game of Thrones is mainly character driven..poorly written? no.
And they are adapting Under the Dome from a novel and they are taking some liberties but they're not going to stay THAT far away from the source and create an ecosystem when there isn't one in the book.... The main change of the series is apparently the ending of the novel.
BIB - you should probably put things like that in spoiler tags because a lot of people who havent read the book don't like being told what is or isnt in it. Being told what isnt going to happen could also be called a spoiler
BIB - you should probably put things like that in spoiler tags because a lot of people who havent read the book don't like being told what is or isnt in it. Being told what isnt going to happen could also be called a spoiler
They don't have to create an eco system. They are already in one.
They don't have to create an eco system. They are already in one.
That's not really relevent to what was meant by my post. My post was saying that if people who have read the book insist on posting what does and doesnt happen in the book, then they should consider putting it in spoiler tags so that people who have not read the book won't have certain plots spoiled
That's not really relevent to what was meant by my post. My post was saying that if people who have read the book insist on posting what does and doesnt happen in the book, then they should consider putting it in spoiler tags so that people who have not read the book won't have certain plots spoiled
I haven't read the book though.. ?! I'm not even sure where that came from when I was writing it..but I created this thread and the first thing I wrote was NO Book Spoilers.
I haven't read the book though.. ?! I'm not even sure where that came from when I was writing it..but I created this thread and the first thing I wrote was NO Book Spoilers.
Sorry but when you said that there isnt an ecosystem within the dome in the book and therefore wouldnt be one in the show, i interpreted that as meaning that you had read the book and were saying that there definetly isnt an ecosystem in the book. In my defence it was an easy mistake to make:p
Sorry but when you said that there isnt an ecosystem within the dome in the book, i interpreted that as meaning that you had read the book and were saying that there definetly isnt an ecosystem in the book
I think I was more trying to say that they will be relatively stick to the plot of the book, and if their is no new ecosystem in the book they won't do it in the show...
I think I was more trying to say that they will be relatively stick to the plot of the book, and if their is no new ecosystem in the book they won't do it in the show...
hopes its better than Haven was I was disapointed by that.,
I sounds like aven was something you tried, didn't like, so gave up - if so how many eps did you give it ? With me, first time around I really didn't like the first ep, not warming to the lead character at all. It was only later when I watched the finale (:eek:) because Kathleen Munroe was guest starring that I got a huge "I wanna find out how they got to this...." feeling so marathon all the previous eps. From then on I became a fan.:D
(haven't read the book though, so maybe that could be a factor)
I sounds like aven was something you tried, didn't like, so gave up - if so how many eps did you give it ? With me, first time around I really didn't like the first ep, not warming to the lead character at all. It was only later when I watched the finale (:eek:) because Kathleen Munroe was guest starring that I got a huge "I wanna find out how they got to this...." feeling so marathon all the previous eps. From then on I became a fan.:D
(haven't read the book though, so maybe that could be a factor)
I've watched up to season 3 of Haven and I still hate it! haha
Only watch it when there's nothing else...block watched most of season 3 one day, can't connect with a single character, and some of the storylines are laugh out loud funny (when they are ment to be serious)
I have started watching Under The Dome and it reminds me of an episode of Eureka and Haven when both of these shows had the town inside a dome for an episode. I have high hopes for the show lets just hope that the big cheeses at the top don't decide that the ratings aren't enough and drop it half way through the first season. It is so annoying when they do that.:mad:
I have started watching Under The Dome and it reminds me of an episode of Eureka and Haven when both of these shows had the town inside a dome for an episode. I have high hopes for the show lets just hope that the big cheeses at the top don't decide that the ratings aren't enough and drop it half way through the first season. It is so annoying when they do that.:mad:
Dont worry, for now its not going anywhere! Highest rated drama premiere in the summer since 1993.. The pilot received 20 million viewers form first airing, live+3 and Sunday repeat.
Episode 2 saw a less then average drop off of 15% (usually 20-30%).
Decent enough episode. Not really liking the young guy with the long hair though. For some reason he annoys me more than the Jnr storyline (I'm liking that a bit better cos at least we have some development for Jnr/James). I think he just annoys me because of his attitude - he's happy to sponge of his friends situation and trying to make himself popular by letting people use the farmboy's generator and house. Doubt he'd be too keen if it was his stuff.
Big Jim might just be an even bigger lunatic than his son. Hopefully Julia only finds out her husband was involved with bad people but not that barbie killed him but i suppose its inveitable she will.
the guy who accidently shot the other one at the end of last weeks episode was shot by the new sheriff Linda.
Big Jim is already working on hiring new cannon fodder/deputies:)
Haha yeah, just finished watching the episode .
Beyond Barbie, it's hard to see who is capable enough to work as a deputy. Most of the town folk just seem quite feckless .
Comments
BIB - you should probably put things like that in spoiler tags because a lot of people who havent read the book don't like being told what is or isnt in it. Being told what isnt going to happen could also be called a spoiler
They don't have to create an eco system. They are already in one.
That's not really relevent to what was meant by my post. My post was saying that if people who have read the book insist on posting what does and doesnt happen in the book, then they should consider putting it in spoiler tags so that people who have not read the book won't have certain plots spoiled
Sorry but when you said that there isnt an ecosystem within the dome in the book and therefore wouldnt be one in the show, i interpreted that as meaning that you had read the book and were saying that there definetly isnt an ecosystem in the book. In my defence it was an easy mistake to make:p
Fair enough i got my wires crossed:o
Do you see me posting spoilers?
"I found this show so awful I went and spoiled it for myself, and i'm glad I did"
If you've found out the ending or whatever all i'm saying is keep it to yourself,
Simple as that
love Stephen King, hopes its better than Haven was I was disapointed by that.,
I'm in the uk too...but I watch it online
(haven't read the book though, so maybe that could be a factor)
Only watch it when there's nothing else...block watched most of season 3 one day, can't connect with a single character, and some of the storylines are laugh out loud funny (when they are ment to be serious)
The Barn thing? stupid
As I knew it would...its moving along nice and slowly
Awful. Awful. Awful.
I'll save those who enjoy it the bother: "Why are you still watching then?!!!" and/or "You don't have to watch!!!"
Dont worry, for now its not going anywhere! Highest rated drama premiere in the summer since 1993.. The pilot received 20 million viewers form first airing, live+3 and Sunday repeat.
Episode 2 saw a less then average drop off of 15% (usually 20-30%).
Scripts are fine, Music is fine, pace is fine, acting is a mixed bag..some good some bad
Big Jim might just be an even bigger lunatic than his son. Hopefully Julia only finds out her husband was involved with bad people but not that barbie killed him but i suppose its inveitable she will.
Big Jim is already working on hiring new cannon fodder/deputies:)
Haha yeah, just finished watching the episode
Beyond Barbie, it's hard to see who is capable enough to work as a deputy. Most of the town folk just seem quite feckless
Also, Junior with a shotgun