It's too obvious to be Derek now I feel. It's got to be Jack but Derek takes the blame and blackmails him. Sharon agrees to marry Jack but the truth comes out on her wedding day and she falls into Phils arms.
I think it's Jack. Max has too much other stuff and if Derek is going to die then it just leaves Jack free for the story- loving the idea Derek takes the blame for it thinking he can have one up on Jack too.
It's too obvious to be Derek now I feel. It's got to be Jack but Derek takes the blame and blackmails him. Sharon agrees to marry Jack but the truth comes out on her wedding day and she falls into Phils arms.
God I hope not - that would theoretically mean the Shagger storyline would go on even longer :yawn::eek:
Hope Kat and Derek dont pretend its them only for it to be Jack later, just want this whole storyline done and buried as deep as Derek will be.
Yeah I just don't know how that would work....it would be bizarre even by EE's standards. Kat trying to make up reasons to Alfie why she fell for/was shagging Derek when all the time it was Jack I think it's meant to end at Christmas and all the storylines strands will come together ending with Derek's demise.
There is photos of Alfie holding onto Jack and Roxy hugging him on the 1st Jan so doesn't look like its him and I dont think it's Max. Ill be very surprised if it's not Derek.
There is photos of Alfie holding onto Jack and Roxy hugging him on the 1st Jan so doesn't look like its him and I dont think it's Max. Ill be very surprised if it's not Derek.
Sure but Alfie's a nice guy - he's not likely to kick off at James's graveside. And I sense a tearful apology from Jack in that scene. And of course Roxy's going to be nice to him, if he has been doing Kat. He's left the field clear for her...
In my opinion, it has to be Derek. Jack was actively chasing Sharon (a lot). He seems infatuated with her, and not int he way of "oh, it'll make Kat jealous!" and even if it was, Jack isn't that kind of guy.
It surely can't be Max - too predictable. Another affair story line? yawn...
It's too obvious to be Derek now I feel. It's got to be Jack but Derek takes the blame and blackmails him. Sharon agrees to marry Jack but the truth comes out on her wedding day and she falls into Phils arms.
I also think that Derek is far too obvious. It won't be much of a 'surprise' if the lover is Derek, as TPTB clearly want us to believe it is him due to the enormous amount of hints recently. Also the newspaper reporters who saw previews were tweeting along the lines of 'OMG - didn't see that one coming' and I don't think there would be that element of surprise if it turned out to be Derek.
I also think Jack. He's the sort of man for whom one woman in his life at a time isn't enough, and all the 'he loves Sharon' guff does not convince me at all. He's vain enough to believe himself irresistable to women and would shag Kat just to feed his vanity.
Most people on here thought that Ben would turn out to be Heather's killer (before we knew who it would be), but then we all said no, that would be too predictable. And it was Ben.
It's seemed obvious for some time that Derek is the man, and he's the one with the best motive, so I fully expect it to be him. If it is him, it just makes a mockery of the whole 'secret shagger' storyline, which I feel has been a total mockery from the outset anyway.
Most people on here thought that Ben would turn out to be Heather's killer (before we knew who it would be), but then we all said no, that would be too predictable. And it was Ben.
It's seemed obvious for some time that Derek is the man, and he's the one with the best motive, so I fully expect it to be him. If it is him, it just makes a mockery of the whole 'secret shagger' storyline, which I feel has been a total mockery from the outset anyway.
Wasn't the actual killing shown on screen? It was never meant to be a secret.
I compare the current storyline to "Whos the daddy" of Heathers baby. Lots of red herrings there, but IIRC Darren was not a suspect
Wasn't the actual killing shown on screen? It was never meant to be a secret.
I compare the current storyline to "Whos the daddy" of Heathers baby. Lots of red herrings there, but IIRC Darren was not a suspect
I was talking about the speculation before the scene took place. Most of us knew that Heather was going to be killed off several months before the scene aired, and we were all discussing who would do it. The vast majority of people said it would be Ben.
Comments
God I hope not - that would theoretically mean the Shagger storyline would go on even longer :yawn::eek:
Yeah I just don't know how that would work....it would be bizarre even by EE's standards. Kat trying to make up reasons to Alfie why she fell for/was shagging Derek when all the time it was Jack I think it's meant to end at Christmas and all the storylines strands will come together ending with Derek's demise.
Snap. Or is this just what I'm hoping for?
Sure but Alfie's a nice guy - he's not likely to kick off at James's graveside. And I sense a tearful apology from Jack in that scene. And of course Roxy's going to be nice to him, if he has been doing Kat. He's left the field clear for her...
It surely can't be Max - too predictable. Another affair story line? yawn...
:sleep:
I also think that Derek is far too obvious. It won't be much of a 'surprise' if the lover is Derek, as TPTB clearly want us to believe it is him due to the enormous amount of hints recently. Also the newspaper reporters who saw previews were tweeting along the lines of 'OMG - didn't see that one coming' and I don't think there would be that element of surprise if it turned out to be Derek.
I also think Jack. He's the sort of man for whom one woman in his life at a time isn't enough, and all the 'he loves Sharon' guff does not convince me at all. He's vain enough to believe himself irresistable to women and would shag Kat just to feed his vanity.
It's seemed obvious for some time that Derek is the man, and he's the one with the best motive, so I fully expect it to be him. If it is him, it just makes a mockery of the whole 'secret shagger' storyline, which I feel has been a total mockery from the outset anyway.
Wasn't the actual killing shown on screen? It was never meant to be a secret.
I compare the current storyline to "Whos the daddy" of Heathers baby. Lots of red herrings there, but IIRC Darren was not a suspect
I was talking about the speculation before the scene took place. Most of us knew that Heather was going to be killed off several months before the scene aired, and we were all discussing who would do it. The vast majority of people said it would be Ben.
He was surprised himself as to who it is
Yes, and the BBC confirmed its either Derek, Jack or Max.