Options
Was Perrie Edwards the best vocalist of 2011?
MrJames
Posts: 8,127
Forum Member
✭
I still find it surreal that she wasn't given a shot as a solo artist, although I am more than pleased that she was put in Little Mix, of course.
Her vocals on Silent Night, Cannonball and I'm Like A Bird in particular are really quite stunning. And for me, she has the most powerful voice on the charity single, Wishing On A Star.
What is your opinion?
Her vocals on Silent Night, Cannonball and I'm Like A Bird in particular are really quite stunning. And for me, she has the most powerful voice on the charity single, Wishing On A Star.
What is your opinion?
0
Comments
Amelia Lily was a real talent but I think she lacked confidence and tried too hard with her voice to cover that.
Perrie in the other hand gained confidence as being surrounded by friends and a good mentor. I dont think she was a good project by herself but blended so good with the group, having great performances, but still not standing out from their bandmates.
People are divided about her voice after the tonsillitis, I think it changed a bit, but not in a way that isnt strong as it was before, I just think they had so much work that Perrie has not dedicated enough time to have a complete recovery.
Me too, Amelia's The Show Must Go on was one of the most impressive vocal performances of that series.
I dont think Perrie would cut it as a soloist.
Just a shame it didn't get the standing ovation from all the judges that it deserved.