[pothuthic]

Just confirmed she will do all 3 days on XF's FB page!

Opinions?

[d56]

She could be ok, just as long as its not all about her.

Recently she was called for her diva behaviour on a photoshoot and I hope she doesn't act all high and mighty at X Factor, the show isn't about her, its about the contestants and people auditioning.

I bet Geri is gutted Mel is doing 3 dates though, she only got the one

[JanetDevlinUK]

Think she will be good for the show I like the way she gives people critique on XF australia.

[ultron29]

She does Australlia so she'll be well experienced. Cannot wait.

[InMyArms]

I wonder why she's been given all three days? I think this means they've stopped auditioning potentiials, and have found their permanent judge in Geri, Leona, Rita or Nicole.

[d56]

Originally Posted by InMyArms

I wonder why she's been given all three days? I think this means they've stopped auditioning potentiials, and have found their permanent judge in Geri, Leona, Rita or Nicole.

I don't think it will be Leona. Her album comes out in Novemeber and she promotes it internationally, so she won't be able to do the lives if she is in other countries.

I think Rita is too inexperienced.

I don't think Geri went down too well, my money is on the fourth judge being Nicole.

[Super Frog]

I wanted her to get the job over Cheryl Cole after Sharon left. I hope they bring her in full time.

[Remote33]

Originally Posted by Super Frog

I wanted her to get the job over Cheryl Cole after Sharon left. I hope they bring her in full time.

They won't. She's already filming Boot Camp for the Australian version.

[jackbell]

I think it will be Nicole too. She likes the UK, her boyfriend is English, she had a pleasent experience last time she did it here.

[newportjoe25]

I still think it's Dannii, regardless if she has denied it or not. They would have sorted out a permanent judge long ago otherwise. I reckon she'll be back for judges houses, maybe even bootcamp.

[GeorgeMarsh]

I really want her to be the permentant judge I think she would be able to juggle both if she was asked.

It needs to be her or Geri!

[d56]

Originally Posted by newportjoe25

I still think it's Dannii, regardless if she has denied it or not. They would have sorted out a permanent judge long ago otherwise. I reckon she'll be back for judges houses, maybe even bootcamp.

As much as I hope this is true, I doubt it now

Nothing suprises me anymore though!

[unclekevo]

Mel B is good with critique sometimes on XF Australia but the other times I just wish she would shut up, she's also a horrible mentor.

[mmeister2]

It'll be interesting to see how she's recieved in the UK compared to Australia.

[THEXFACTORKING]

Maybe Mel b should take the UK GIG, while Dannii takes the Australian gig.

It's kinda known a little that Mel B is not a fan of the Australian panel, and she thinks she is better than all of em.

[gpk]

well that puts the geri rumours into prospective. if they were hiring her, then why bring mel b in for three days? its says a lot about the nicole rumours too, i doubt her and geri have a lot on at the moment. however, i don't think mel will get the job either to be honest. she recently signed a deal with emi australia, so surely she would want to keep her profile up over there.

[samusek2]

Mel B has too much going for her this autumn. Like it has been stated, she's also one of the four mentors on XFACTOR Australia which runs concurrently with the UK version I believe. Also, there have been rumours that she will want to return to the States to take part in Dancing With the Stars All Stars. It's probably unlikely as well, but she has been tweeting her former DWTS pro partner seeing if he would be up to it.

BTW, Has she finished hosting the Australian version of DWTS yet?

[gpk]

Originally Posted by samusek2

Mel B has too much going for her this autumn. Like it has been stated, she's also one of the four mentors on XFACTOR Australia which runs concurrently with the UK version I believe. Also, there have been rumours that she will want to return to the States to take part in Dancing With the Stars All Stars. It's probably unlikely as well, but she has been tweeting her former DWTS pro partner seeing if he would be up to it.

BTW, Has she finished hosting the Australian version of DWTS yet?

i think there are 2 episodes left.

[pothuthic]

Originally Posted by unclekevo

Mel B is good with critique sometimes on XF Australia but the other times I just wish she would shut up, she's also a horrible mentor.

She will fit in with tulisa then?