[Jaggedcat]

Picked cause they can sing any one of them would have made a good wild card but together they are not practised long enough and they are shaky on the self belief as a group. Off key and nervous last week but pretty as a button on the eye.

[MrsSpoon]

There isn't much to say about them yet. I didn't think much of their performance last week although they proved at the auditions that are all good singers.
Here's hoping that they get a better song choice and a decent wardrobe this week.

[lovecat86]

Originally Posted by Woowho

I get a little confused about this "boring" label people randomly throw around on this forum. What exactly should they do to make themselves interesting, as opposed to any other girl group with chart success? What do you consider interesting? Define?

Well, they're not just boring. I happen to think they are PANTS!!! My respect for Hayley Williams went up 10 fold after their abysmal attempt at the chorus to Airplanes. But, how many girl groups does one chart need? Seriously? That and they were formed at bootcamp. I'm a 24 year old female, girl power died with the Spice Girls

(I do quite like some Girls Aloud songs but other than that,,,)

[AliBaba2010]

It said in the Irish Daily Star yesterday that they're doing a Kinks song this week and that Rebecca is doing lead vocals...

[mintchocchip]

Originally Posted by AliBaba2010

It said in the Irish Daily Star yesterday that they're doing a Kinks song this week and that Rebecca is doing lead vocals...

Which one is Rebecca?

I thought they were better than One Direction last week.

[AliBaba2010]

Originally Posted by mintchocchip

Which one is Rebecca?

I thought they were better than One Direction last week.

The short haired one... It was reported in the Irish Daily Star cos she's Irish i suppose.

[xTonix]

The blonde one is hot I liek them, they are better then that crappy boring boyband.

[Syntax Error]

Originally Posted by Hermanazo

You would think they would be all over the media and discussion forums, but there's hardly any news or thread about them. Even John Incognito is getting more attention. And to top up things, Simon's attention seems to be focusing on 1 Direction.

Do they need to up their game, develop their personalities, do something outrageous?

They're a girl group; nobody likes girl groups on X-Factor.

I'm surprised they managed to survive last week's double vote off.

[Katcha]

Originally Posted by Syntax Error

They're a girl group; nobody likes girl groups on X-Factor.

That's a very sweeping statement.

Traditionally girl bands have not fared very well on XFactor - neither have females over 25. It doesn't mean nobody likes them.


Belle Amie are all fine solo singers. It's the singing together that is so testing in these early stages.

Anyways - glad we're talking about them - as that what the thread is all about

[Unifix]

I like Bell Amie.

They are really interesting and the best girl group I have seen on this show probably.

I think they are sexy and contemporary. Their version of B.o.B and Hayley Williams really worked for me and their not bad for a group that have just been thrown together.

[SpiderMan 83]

Originally Posted by Syntax Error

They're a girl group; nobody likes girl groups on X-Factor.

I'm surprised they managed to survive last week's double vote off.

i like girl groups and so do others. Its time a girlband one the show tbh and this could be the year.

you have to remember JLS started off slow but im sure the girls will be fine the longer they are in the show.

[Syntax Error]

Originally Posted by Katcha

That's a very sweeping statement.

Traditionally girl bands have not fared very well on XFactor - neither have females over 25. It doesn't mean nobody likes them.


Belle Amie are all fine solo singers. It's the singing together that is so testing in these early stages.

Anyways - glad we're talking about them - as that what the thread is all about

You're quite right, it was a bit too much of a sweeping statement, but like you've said, it's just that girl groups don't do well on XF.

Saying that, Belle Amie have already bucked the trend by surviving a double vote off last week, so that is good news for them.

[Thank you]

Because they were one of the worst contestants in X Factor history!

[Soppyfan]

I wasn't expecting this old thread to get bumped up and I wasn't even around here at the time.

[shaunnashines]

Originally Posted by Syntax Error

They're a girl group; nobody likes girl groups on X-Factor.

This comment is so ironic now...

But in regards to Belle Amie they are down to 2 members now...

[RodRuby93]

Originally Posted by Thank you

Because they were one of the worst contestants in X Factor history!

More deplorable than acts like Cher Lloyd, Frankie Cocozza, Eoghan Quigg, Nu Vibe, Wagner and Lloyd Daniels?

I do agree however that they were simultaneously bland and rubbish.

[monrose]

Originally Posted by shaunnashines

This comment is so ironic now...

But in regards to Belle Amie they are down to 2 members now...

I read that the two remaining girls have since disbanded

[Hassaan13]

Originally Posted by monrose

I read that the two remaining girls have since disbanded

Where did you read that?

[monrose]

Originally Posted by Hassaan13

Where did you read that?

I read it on Wikipedia

[abrightyz]

Originally Posted by monrose

I read that the two remaining girls have since disbanded

but both vowed to continue their career as solo artists, one is now called "belle", the other goes by the name "amie"...

[Hassaan13]

Originally Posted by monrose

I read it on Wikipedia

It says 'undetermined future', doesn't mention anywhere that Belle Amie 'were' a British girl group.