[rombod]

No, and anyone who says "yes" is wrong and trying too hard.

[pork.pie]

What a ridiculous question this thread asks... of course not... *shakes head and leaves*

[pork.pie]

Originally Posted by Heavenly

She destroyed Hanson, I will never forgive her for that.

It was bloody awful.

Hanson destroyed Hanson... long before Miss Devlin came along!

[imagine___]

She's the worst one out of the final five but in no way is she the worst ever. She was amazing coming into the lives but everyone else has surpassed her.

[RodRuby93]

Not the worst, but certainly one of the most over hyped and overestimated. I also found her voice one of the most irritating I've ever heard along with a very flimsy vocal range, likewise it's very difficult for her to sing correctly on pitch, therefore I have to admit with assertiveness that she butchered "Every Breath You Take" due to her horrifically "flat singing." It's also very conspicuous that her rendition of MMMBop was also a complete mess vocally and lyrically, oh and the reminiscence between her and Diana Vickers is pretty conclusive really.

The following list below are by far the worst contestants according to my precisional judgement.

Cher Lloyd
Frankie Cocozza
Lloyd Daniels
Eoghan Quigg
Nu Vibe
Wagner
Jedward
Ray Quinn
Same Difference
Diva Fever
2 to Go
Phillip McGee
Andy Williams
The Unconventionals
Addictive Ladies

[Kuda_Kunaka]

Gosh dammit frankie cocoza and Katie waissel

[Patti-Ann]

Originally Posted by RodRuby93

oh and the reminiscence between her and Diana Vickers is pretty conclusive really.

The following list below are by far the worst contestants according to my precisional judgement.

Cher Lloyd
Frankie Cocozza
Lloyd Daniels
Eoghan Quigg
Nu Vibe
Wagner
Jedward
Ray Quinn
Same Difference
Diva Fever
2 to Go
Phillip McGee
Andy Williams
The Unconventionals
Addictive Ladies

Janet and Diana did have similar 'yodelly' voices

I agree with your list except Ray who I voted for

I also quite liked Andy Williams, but it was Leon that caught the publics support (I liked Rhydian)

[Nastyman69]

Yes agree with OP, along with Diana Knickers

[RodRuby93]

Originally Posted by BinCat

Worst act in XFactor history?

One word. Ray

Several other words to compliment too. Flat, insipid, bland, uninspiring and overconfident.

[Nastyman69]

Originally Posted by Nastyman69

Yes agree with OP, along with Diana Knickers

Oh yes, I forgot Cher Lloyd and Hankie Pankie Stankie W**kie Frankie Cockozza (UGH!)

[unclekevo]

Janet is far from the worst, she has quite an individual style but she is really talented.

[nooneoo]

Not the worst, but the most overrated.

[LunarLegend]

Far from the worst she only had two off performances in the live shows I want you back and Mmmbop I don't think these were good choices for her I know Kelly wasn't the right mentor for her but I think she should have took her advice and not sang I want you back and Mmmbop other than that I think she should have been in the final in place of Marcus.

If we are talking about worst contestants ever here are the candidates

Frankie Cocozza
Marcus Collins
Eoghan Quigg
Phillip McGee
Nu Vibe
Lloyd Daniels
Riki Loney
Conway Sisters
Kimberly
Kandy Rain
Diva Fever
Storm Lee
FYD
Girlband
Addictive Ladies

Edit I don't think we should take this thread to seriously the OP (hehe) was a well known troll on the DS forums last year.

[BinCat]

Originally Posted by RodRuby93

Not the worst, but certainly one of the most over hyped and overestimated. I also found her voice one of the most irritating I've ever heard along with a very flimsy vocal range, likewise it's very difficult for her to sing correctly on pitch, therefore I have to admit with assertiveness that she butchered "Every Breath You Take" due to her horrifically "flat singing." It's also very conspicuous that her rendition of MMMBop was also a complete mess vocally and lyrically, oh and the reminiscence between her and Diana Vickers is pretty conclusive really.

The following list below are by far the worst contestants according to my precisional judgement.

Cher Lloyd
Frankie Cocozza
Lloyd Daniels
Eoghan Quigg
Nu Vibe
Wagner
Jedward
Ray Quinn
Same Difference
Diva Fever
2 to Go
Phillip McGee
Andy Williams
The Unconventionals
Addictive Ladies

Agree with this list apart from the omission of Olly Murs who was truly horrible, but I'll admit to finding Wagner and Jedward quite entertaining

[LunarLegend]

Originally Posted by BinCat

Agree with this list apart from the omission of Olly Murs who was truly horrible, but I'll admit to finding Wagner and Jedward quite entertaining

Forgot to add Olly to my list he was awful in the live shows still shocks me to this day he made it to the final, he has made some good music since the show though.

[Kyle123]

Aww, I forgot all about hehe's unprecidented hatred for Janet.

[LunarLegend]

Originally Posted by Kyle123

Aww, I forgot all about hehe's unprecidented hatred for Janet.

People like him are the reason my first name on here was JanetDevlinUK I wanted to defend Janet from unnecessary abuse she was getting at the time some posters got to personal, Most of my posts and threads were very rage filled one in particular thread I made was very embarrassing here's hoping no one bring's it back up.

Why did I change accounts? Becouse if I make a critical thread on a contestant this year I would have got replies like "Coming from someone who has Janet Devlin in their name hahaha MMMBOP".

[RodRuby93]

Originally Posted by LunarLegend

Far from the worst she only had two off performances in the live shows I want you back and Mmmbop I don't think these were good choices for her I know Kelly wasn't the right mentor for her but I think she should have took her advice and not sang I want you back and Mmmbop other than that I think she should have been in the final in place of Marcus.

If we are talking about worst contestants ever here are the candidates

Frankie Cocozza
Marcus Collins
Eoghan Quigg
Phillip McGee
Nu Vibe
Lloyd Daniels
Riki Loney
Conway Sisters
Kimberly
Kandy Rain
Diva Fever
Storm Lee
FYD
Girlband
Addictive Ladies

Edit I don't think we should take this thread to seriously the OP (hehe) was a well known troll on the DS forums last year.

I recall the acts in bold were also pretty terrible as well. Storm Lee was just tedious and Marcus Collins was persistently average prior to the stages of the semi finals whilst he butchered "Can You Feel It."

[bigbro24]

She was bad but I'd say Frankie Cock-no-sir, Lloyd Daniels, Jedward, Scott Bruton were worse. Cheryl Cole and Cher Lloyd came back as professionals and gave appalling bad performances too!.

[Thank you]

Ray Quinn was dire how he made the final is still a mystery.

[Andybear]

Originally Posted by Thank you

Ray Quinn was dire how he made the final is still a mystery.

He had a lead role in a 'Brookside' storyline about bullying when he was a kid - perhaps some of his voters were people who were impressed with his acting in that. OK I know the X Factor is supposed to be a singing competition but people vote for all sorts or reasons.