[jackel1234]

With the rumours going around that The X Factor may soon be axed for a new kind of music show I was wondering what you guys would want to see in a possible new show?
Would you want a battle of the bands type of thing or a Must Be The music show etc.
Just curious

[mashitup]

'Must Be The Music' but it won't happen! Shows like that are not dumb enough!!!!!

[Kuda_Kunaka]

keep the x factor.. would be better.., they just need to reevaluate and focus more on the right priorities

[Lovely_noise123]

Voting for acts right at the very beginning not half-way through...there is always something really dodgy about all that. I mean being able to vote for acts after their first audition...and everything should be live too.

[LunarLegend]

A music show without gimicks like X Factor and The Voice have, with X Factor it's all about having the X Factor allegedly and The Voice is about having "The Voice" can't we just have a show were contestants can sing what and be the artist they want to be without having to play to the gimick of the shows and NO mentors or coaches it's better to just have judges that way there is no excuses for silly antics like saying yes to someone in the audition rounds then suddenly pretending they never liked this specific act when the live shows come around just to create staged drama between the judge and mentor.

Have a voting cap multi voting proves nothing.
Act with the lowest votes is eliminated each week of the live shows.


The running order is decided by picking names out of a hat with one rule if the same person's name is pulled out of the hat to get the death slot/pimp slot two weeks in a row put their name back in the hat and pull another name out it will make great TV.

All live show acts get given equal air time and not having special treatment last year in the second half of the live shows the final two got over pimped Marcus had Rebbecca Ferguson in his VT and Little Mix got Jessie J in their VT if the producers want to do this with contestants do it with everyone.

[jackel1234]

Originally Posted by LunarLegend

A music show without gimicks like X Factor and The Voice have, with X Factor it's all about having the X Factor allegedly and The Voice is about having "The Voice" can't we just have a show were contestants can sing what and be the artist they want to be without having to play to the gimick of the shows and NO mentors or coaches it's better to just have judges that way there is no excuses for silly antics like saying yes to someone in the audition rounds then suddenly pretending they never liked this specific act when the live shows come around just to create staged drama between the judge and mentor.

Have a voting cap multi voting proves nothing.

So sort of like the american idol style show where the artist chooses their own path. That would be a really good show for the uk, I mean people like Frankie got ruined on the x factor whilst if you did it where he chose the song for himself I reckon he could've been great

[LandslideBrad]

The X Factor but without the crowd at the auditions, like they used to.

[jackbell]

If you're gonna bring out a music talent voting show you may as well stick with the X Factor, which is the best of it's kind. Or bring back Idol.

[Lovely_noise123]

Stop trying to create controversy and find a good singer instead.

[jackbell]

I personally think the X Factor needs to be rested - not cancelled, because its become a television icon and the benchmark of TV talent shows in this country - and replaced by big variety show. A cross between the Royal Variety and a big charity giveaway thing.

Then bring XF back - revamped - after a few years off the air.

[Lovely_noise123]

In this day and age having pre recorded talent shows is just wrong....... make it all live, then we know you are not autotuning the voices, which is why you have lost all your viewers .

[Tyjet]

Originally Posted by Lovely_noise123

In this day and age having pre recorded talent shows is just wrong....... make it all live, then we know you are not autotuning the voices, which is why you have lost all your viewers .

LOL! They don't use autotune in the pre-recorded episodes. If they did, there would be an uproar, don't you remember the aftermath of the first episode of series 7?