[zm90]

Originally Posted by InMyArms

OK, well obviously as hardcore Jedward fans you're a bit biased, and my opinion has nothing to do with The Sun as I don't read that shit rag.

How could they judge anyway when the crowd boos their mere appearance? (Before you say they don't I was at the auditions in Manchester and when the warm up introduced them they got booed). I notice you've had to make your points with music videos rather than live performances, wonder why that is? They wouldn't work, as their act makes it impossible for them to ever say anything negative about anyone. Their popularity in the UK (Not Ireland where I believe they are popular) isn't great, their first album barely made top 20, their second top 40. They couldn't even take 12 points in the UK on Eurovision over someone who was previously unknown.

They seem like nice people, but as an X Factor judge they would be awful.

They shouldn't be getting booed by anyone. It says more about the audience than it does jedward themselves. They were there as presenters of the Xtra Factor not as judges and the people working on the show have made it clear that they thought jedward did an amazing job. I really wish people would treat them fairly. They haven't got a bad bone in their body and really don't deserve all the hate.

[River_Tam]

Originally Posted by InMyArms

OK, well obviously as hardcore Jedward fans you're a bit biased, and my opinion has nothing to do with The Sun as I don't read that shit rag.

How could they judge anyway when the crowd boos their mere appearance? (Before you say they don't I was at the auditions in Manchester and when the warm up introduced them they got booed). I notice you've had to make your points with music videos rather than live performances, wonder why that is? They wouldn't work, as their act makes it impossible for them to ever say anything negative about anyone. Their popularity in the UK (Not Ireland where I believe they are popular) isn't great, their first album barely made top 20, their second top 40. They couldn't even take 12 points in the UK on Eurovision over someone who was previously unknown.

They seem like nice people, but as an X Factor judge they would be awful.

The X factor judges get booed all the time. It's all panto. The twins are good at panto.
I could have used any number of live performance videos since the twins are always doing concerts, was at one less than two weeks ago and I will be at one again by the end of the month.

That Swedish song ran away with all the Eurovision points and to be honest I knew it probably would the first time I heard it. Euphooooooria!!!!! (sorry Jedfans I am always gonna love that song from now until the end of time, the important thing to remember is I brought it but I didn't vote for it OK!)

They don't need to say negative things, they believe in constructive critisism!

Out of interest what was Dannii Minogue's highest UK chart position? Or Simon Cowells as an artist? X factor is a TV show, twins know TV.
Anyway Xtra factor peeps think they did a stunning job so maybe one day .......

[quasimoron]

Originally Posted by InMyArms

Laura White was brought up in parliament

They would be rubbish judges because they haven't got anything constructive to say, they're a novelty act. Also they have little to offer in the way of mentoring, because they dont have long term success in the music industry as performers or managers and cannot sing themselves.

It did not stop cheryl Cole. The girl is talent-less, has little constructive to say and cant sing.

Jedward sing simple pop songs well and can sing live, Cheryl cant.They are more than a novelty act. They do lack experience and success that is true. Their main problem as judges would be their hyper personalities.I dont see them as judges myself for that reason

They are better on a fun show like the Xtrafactor. Those booing them need to cop on, move on and bully someone else.Most are ignorant chavs or benefit dossers who would not know hard work if it bit them.

[sadoldbat]

Originally Posted by quasimoron

It did not stop cheryl Cole. The girl is talent-less, has little constructive to say and cant sing.

Jedward sing simple pop songs well and can sing live, Cheryl cant.They are more than a novelty act. They do lack experience and success that is true. Their main problem as judges would be their hyper personalities.I dont see them as judges myself for that reason

They are better on a fun show like the Xtrafactor. Those booing them need to cop on, move on and bully someone else.Most are ignorant chavs or benefit dossers who would not know hard work if it bit them.

Probably the same flock of sheep who booed someone just for being German on Britain's Got Talent. How embarrassing!

[jedward rule]

Originally Posted by quasimoron

It did not stop cheryl Cole. The girl is talent-less, has little constructive to say and cant sing.

Jedward sing simple pop songs well and can sing live, Cheryl cant.They are more than a novelty act. They do lack experience and success that is true. Their main problem as judges would be their hyper personalities.I dont see them as judges myself for that reason

They are better on a fun show like the Xtrafactor. Those booing them need to cop on, move on and bully someone else.Most are ignorant chavs or benefit dossers who would not know hard work if it bit them.

I agree with this statement Cheryl cole can't sing live and was
only a judge for her looks and now we know from the book
simon fancied her and danni had an affair with him and she
hasn't had a hit in years and due to the work she has have
done she can't show emotions. If you want to watch a bad
live performance on a live talent show watch Cheryl on
popstars the rivals it makes John and Edwards audition sound
like Mariah carey. I agree the jeds are not ready for being
judges but xtra factor producers were saying how brilliant they
were co presenting the xtra factor. Noone knows the ups and
downs iof the x factor journey than the jeds remember 2009 the jeds created all the headlines for the show. So the jeds
are ment to be a noverity act international famous you know
what their Are to many things tio list what the jeds are doing
And they finish sixth in 2009 and are one if the most
successful acts ever to come from the x factor to still boo
them after three years shows stupid some people are and you
should watch a. Video of with their fans and how they treat
them and they have fans all over the world they don't have to
win anything it's because they make an impact and are
remembered and yes they didn't win euro vision but they won loads more fans and getting their music played all around the
world and have screaming girls and their fans who are of all
ages from very young to old it's just a shame the uk is still
stuck in 2009 in reguard to their music but they will get load tv
work in the uk and they are always mentioned across various
areas of media don't mean those nasty comidens they were
just reference on a soap the other week and have been
mentioned in all uk major soaps and are in social
conciousness. So people can boo all they want the jeds Are here to stay