Best type of dog to get for a would be first time owner with children?

2

Comments

  • Weigh-ManWeigh-Man Posts: 2,132
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    make sure you get a "kind, friendly" breed though.

    eg, even for a small dog, i would not get say a corgi, as i think they can be snappy. get something placid.

    a springer spaniel might be good if you want something slightly bigger. I am pretty sure they are good natured.

    Springers are brilliant with kids, mine plays with my 6 year old niece all the time and is very gentle and patient with her. That said springers are also very active dogs and they need lots of attention and exercise, with such a young kid it might prove to be a bit too much of a handful.

    If you can handle it though they are well worth it, they are very loving and mine makes me laugh on a daily basis with his antics.
  • io1901io1901 Posts: 232
    Forum Member
    We have a Basset Fauve de Bretagne. They are very good with children.
  • technology_lovetechnology_love Posts: 3,175
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    We have a 3 year old yellow lab and my son will be 3 in August. She was hard work from day one but has improved dramatically.

    She is very patient with my son who enjoys sticking his fingers in her eyes and giving her mighty hard pats on the back. We also re-enact scenes of the never ending story where she plays falcor the luck dragon and he plays atreyu riding on her back. Our rescue cat Buster plays the part of Gmork - the evil wolf thing in the swamp. But I digress.

    Whatever dog you choose - it will need walking and looking after. many people think you can just lock a dog up from 9-5 when you are work :mad:
  • lil_miss_blondelil_miss_blonde Posts: 9,090
    Forum Member
    JulieD wrote: »
    I have a Golden Retriever and I would disagree with this. They have an ideal temperament to be a family dog but they are huge and boisterous and mature very slowly. They can knock children over without trying to when they are playing and they need a lot of exercise when young. My children were 10 and 13 when we got ours and they found him a handful at times. He is lovely now but he's 7 and has had a substantial amount of training. I'd go for something smaller if I was in the OPs shoes.

    I'd just like to fly the flag for Golden retrievers and have highlighted the words I have for a reason. Male Golden retrievers are everything you have said, large, bositerous, slow to mature ect.. However female Golden retrievers are (in my experience) a different kettle of fish. My bitch isn't large at at all, more collie size. She is the laziest, calmest dog in the world, always had a mature head on her. If I remember rightly by the time she was a year she was doing pretty much every trick under the sun and taking part in showing/obiedence classes. My mum is a childminder and she is fantastic with the kids, I can't even begin to count the amount of children my mum has had that started out with a terrible fear of dogs, my dog totally cured them and most now have family dogs of there own. I can let children as young as 4 or 5 walk her on a lead, they plag with her and shes so careful. She will play all rough and tumble with me but soon as you hand say her tug toy to a child, she pulls it with the slightest force giving the child the upper hand to tug it back. I've been known to walk outside and half the kids are watching as one asks her to roll over or beg ect and the daft mutt is rolling repeatidly over and over trying to please the child who is asking her to do it.

    Its not just her I know/have known atleast 5 or 6 other golden retriever bitches that are exactly the same. Obviously all dogs are different but i've never come across a bad behaved female golden retriever. Wheras I know 3 males (of my friends.. different friends) plus meeting some out on walks, who are all everything JulieD mentioned above.
    shirlt9 wrote: »
    We too had a golden retriever when my older boys were just 3 and 5 and Icouldnt cope..if you read my first post on this thread you will see I sad exactly as you..they are puppies for so long yet big and boisterous..lovely,lovely nature but I found myself seperating dog and children constantly which defeated the object of a family dog..lots of exercise needed and with 2 children of an age you really need to watch on the road it was all just a nightmare!..

    Im intringued as to what sex your golden retriever was? :)
  • Joel's dadJoel's dad Posts: 4,886
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I have a staffy mix and two children under four my dog is great with the kids she was a rescue dog

    I took my kids to the rEscue centre to meet the dogs
  • Hit Em Up StyleHit Em Up Style Posts: 12,141
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    A Yorkshire Terrier would be ideal. They love children and are very faithful. I doubt you would have any trouble with a Yorkie.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 4,864
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I honestly wouldn't get a dog at all while your child is so young. Pulling of ears and poking of eyes can cause upset for the dog, and danger for the baby. And for goodness sake, whatever you do, don't get a 'working' dog such as a springer, collie etc unless you have oodles of room and all day to spend with them. Dogs of a working breed can become very distructive and naughty if they're not given the time, mental and physical exercise required. If you are set on getting a dog though, the only breed I can think of that may suit and that has the patience and build to withstand little people is a Staffy.
  • yorkiegalyorkiegal Posts: 18,929
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    I agree with the above poster that i would put off getting a dog until your child is a little older, perhaps when they are 5 and start school. They will be old enough then to be a lot more involved in taking care of the new family pet and won't be kicking or biting it, as my friend's two year old often does with my boxer. Fortunately he's a gentle giant and puts up with it all. In fact I would really reccommend a boxer dog, providing you have time to exercise him and stop him from getting bored. Boxers adore children. Mine sits on his bum everytime I try to walk him past a child in the street because he expects them to come up and fuss him. I grew up amongst boxer dogs and they really are great family dogs.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 4,864
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    yorkiegal wrote: »
    I agree with the above poster that i would put off getting a dog until your child is a little older, perhaps when they are 5 and start school. They will be old enough then to be a lot more involved in taking care of the new family pet and won't be kicking or biting it, as my friend's two year old often does with my boxer. Fortunately he's a gentle giant and puts up with it all. In fact I would really reccommend a boxer dog, providing you have time to exercise him and stop him from getting bored. Boxers adore children. Mine sits on his bum everytime I try to walk him past a child in the street because he expects them to come up and fuss him. I grew up amongst boxer dogs and they really are great family dogs.

    Agree, boxers are great family dogs - as long as the family are as bouncy and energetic as the dog!
  • TheBigMTheBigM Posts: 13,125
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    I agree about waiting until your child is older (say 5 or 6) then get one. Dogs can be expensive too (vet bills, vaccinations, food, treats, poo bags etc etc) so hopefully finances are fine. Think very carefully about your time too, having dog is in some ways like having a toddler for life and they need looking after daily.

    I have a swedish vallhund, beautiful dog, very intelligent, generally very peaceable but can be naughty if he wants to be. They're quite rare but he's an ideal size, small enough to pick up, large enough to be interesting.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,218
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Rubbish to the above few posts. Introduce your children to pets as soon as you can. My daughter's been around dogs and cats since she was a baby. She still remembers my mum's old curly coated retriever who was just wonderful with her when she was a toddler. Our collie on the other hand wasn't fussed on the little person.

    We've had a Jack Russell since she was three and they adore eachother.
  • muddipawsmuddipaws Posts: 3,300
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I had a dog when I was a lad but stayed with my parents (spaniel) but my girlfriend and I have just bought our first home & were thinking of getting a dog.

    I'm self employed & occasionally work away from home but only once a month, if that & my girlfriend is working part time so there'll always be someone there to take it walks etc.

    We have a garden but it's not the largest & a 2 year old daughter.

    I had two dogs when my kids were tiny and had two Yorkies they were good family dogs, having said that I now have a Staffie and is just fabulous with kids but do think with toddlers possibly too big. As family dogs though they are great
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 4,864
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Rubbish to the above few posts. Introduce your children to pets as soon as you can. My daughter's been around dogs and cats since she was a baby. She still remembers my mum's old curly coated retriever who was just wonderful with her when she was a toddler. Our collie on the other hand wasn't fussed on the little person.

    We've had a Jack Russell since she was three and they adore eachother.

    I had my first dog when I was two... A black lab, adored him, he adored me, and lived to the ripe old age of 17. I was devastated when he died. The reason I don't advocate small children and pets is because kids don't understand they're not toys or dolls. And some parents don't seem bothered about enforcing this either. Especially with dogs, if you have full time jobs and children, I firmly believe you do not have time for a dog.
  • cats_fivecats_five Posts: 1,182
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    TWS wrote: »
    before settling on a breed you need to look at two things, one how much exercise you plan on giving it, then two the kind of size dog you want - then go from there really

    Also look at how much it will cost to keep - I'm thinking especially of how much it costs at the vet, and how much it will cost to insure if you want to do that. Even a cat-sized dog seems to cost a lot more at the vets than a cat.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 4,864
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    cats_five wrote: »
    Also look at how much it will cost to keep - I'm thinking especially of how much it costs at the vet, and how much it will cost to insure if you want to do that. Even a cat-sized dog seems to cost a lot more at the vets than a cat.

    This ^^

    My cats are insured, and for nearly five years, I never had any problems. Then in the space of three weeks, one of them got hit (just a glancing blow but still) by a car, and the other got bitten by another cat on the tail. Bang goes £300... I got the money back less the excess, but I still had to find the £300 upfront...
  • susie-4964susie-4964 Posts: 23,143
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Rubbish to the above few posts. Introduce your children to pets as soon as you can. My daughter's been around dogs and cats since she was a baby. She still remembers my mum's old curly coated retriever who was just wonderful with her when she was a toddler. Our collie on the other hand wasn't fussed on the little person.

    We've had a Jack Russell since she was three and they adore eachother.

    It's not "rubbish", it's an opinion, as is your post. People really need to get to grips with the fact that others may have different views on things, and not get so rude about it, it's very annoying.
  • primerprimer Posts: 6,370
    Forum Member
    get a beagle.

    it'll be non stop adventures :D
  • frisky pythonfrisky python Posts: 9,737
    Forum Member
    I'd just like to fly the flag for Golden retrievers and have highlighted the words I have for a reason. Male Golden retrievers are everything you have said, large, bositerous, slow to mature ect.. However female Golden retrievers are (in my experience) a different kettle of fish. My bitch isn't large at at all, more collie size. She is the laziest, calmest dog in the world, always had a mature head on her. If I remember rightly by the time she was a year she was doing pretty much every trick under the sun and taking part in showing/obiedence classes. My mum is a childminder and she is fantastic with the kids, I can't even begin to count the amount of children my mum has had that started out with a terrible fear of dogs, my dog totally cured them and most now have family dogs of there own. I can let children as young as 4 or 5 walk her on a lead, they plag with her and shes so careful. She will play all rough and tumble with me but soon as you hand say her tug toy to a child, she pulls it with the slightest force giving the child the upper hand to tug it back. I've been known to walk outside and half the kids are watching as one asks her to roll over or beg ect and the daft mutt is rolling repeatidly over and over trying to please the child who is asking her to do it.

    Its not just her I know/have known atleast 5 or 6 other golden retriever bitches that are exactly the same. Obviously all dogs are different but i've never come across a bad behaved female golden retriever. Wheras I know 3 males (of my friends.. different friends) plus meeting some out on walks, who are all everything JulieD mentioned above.



    Im intringued as to what sex your golden retriever was? :)
    I've got a 19mth old female Golden, who is currently in behaviour training! She is fantastic with my kids (who are aged 5 and 7) and with people in general, but does not seem to like some dogs. She was fine initially when we were doing training a year ago, loved playing with other dogs, but then over the summer months she started to get really growly when other dogs got near her. I went to a trainer who specialised in Golden's but it didn't help much, so we are now with a duo who focus on behaviour - we just started today.

    OP, GRs are lovely dogs, my two adore our dog, but if I could do it again I'd get a smaller breed who didn't need as much exercise. My kids don't want to walk as far as our dog needs - so I walk her when they are at school rather than the family walks I'd envisioned.
  • marietsmariets Posts: 1,262
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I'd suggest a staffy. Seriously. Don't believe everything you read, they are ideal family pets.

    Staffies are fab with kids althought we've never had one as my H doesn't like them. My mum, my brother and my niece have all had them and they are extremely good-natured and friendly with all people, but they do hate all other animals as a rule.
  • Steve™Steve™ Posts: 7,286
    Forum Member
    A well trained dog.
  • haphashhaphash Posts: 21,448
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Here's a picture of our boy Alfie too, for good measure... http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii240/big_hard_lad/d682a40d.jpg (He actually started out as solid black and every time we got him cut he got lighter and lighter, and now he looks like this!!)

    Your dog is gorgeous :)
  • marietsmariets Posts: 1,262
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Is Alfie a shit-zu or a lhasa apso?
  • Fizzee RascalFizzee Rascal Posts: 1,032
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    mariets wrote: »
    Staffies are fab with kids althought we've never had one as my H doesn't like them. My mum, my brother and my niece have all had them and they are extremely good-natured and friendly with all people, but they do hate all other animals as a rule.

    Mine don't. In fact they are all in love with the neighbourhood cats - most of whom don't even bother to run away any more.
  • oscardelahoyaoscardelahoya Posts: 4,902
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I have a lab x springer, he's pretty much like a little labrador, is soft as anything, and so long as he's had his exercise for the day is happy to cabbage out and sleep all day, or if you want to he will also play all day.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 1,218
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Mine don't. In fact they are all in love with the neighbourhood cats - most of whom don't even bother to run away any more.

    I once knew of a very big and beefy staffy who had the most amazing temperament. I wouldn't have hesitated in having him around small kids. The funniest thing was that he was totally submissive to his companion, a elderly decrepit Jack Russell.
Sign In or Register to comment.