Doctor Who Best Regeneration Elimination Thread
![[Deleted User]](https://w0.vanillicon.com/v2/0c321084217d8711373682c0fc1d3cf1.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 872 Forum Member
✭✭
ok, ok i know i am just jumping on the band wagon but i love these threads and want one of my own so here we go again! what was the best regeneration storys? Round 1 -3 and +3, you know the rules by now. Please state what you have done and feel free to comment on the reasons behind your vote. I am not expecting too many replies as this requires classic fans!
The Tenth Planet/Power of the Daleks (WH-PT) 10
The War Games/Spearhead from Space (PT-JP) 10
Planet of the Spiders/Robot (JP-TB) 10
Logopolis/Castrovalva (TB-PD) 10
The Caves of Androzani/The Twin Dilemma (PD-CB) 10
Time and the Rani (CB-SM) 10
Television Movie (SC-PM) 10
?
Parting of the Ways/Children in Need Special/The Christmas Invasion (CE-DT) 10
Also does anyone have any ideas about the PM-CE Regeneration?
The Tenth Planet/Power of the Daleks (WH-PT) 10
The War Games/Spearhead from Space (PT-JP) 10
Planet of the Spiders/Robot (JP-TB) 10
Logopolis/Castrovalva (TB-PD) 10
The Caves of Androzani/The Twin Dilemma (PD-CB) 10
Time and the Rani (CB-SM) 10
Television Movie (SC-PM) 10
?
Parting of the Ways/Children in Need Special/The Christmas Invasion (CE-DT) 10
Also does anyone have any ideas about the PM-CE Regeneration?
0
Comments
1-2 Hartnell to Troughton 11
2-3 Troughton to Pertwee 9
3-4 Pertwee to Baker 10
4-5 Baker to Davison 8
5-6 And back again 11
6-7 McCoy in a wig to McCoy 10
7-8 McCoy to McGann 10
?
9-10 Eccleston to Tennant 11
Right then: one point each to William Hartnell's departure - the final fall of the frail old man, and the entertaining astonishment of the new Doctor as he discovers his new face; David Tennant's arrival and the thrill of a regeneration again after ten years); and of course to Peter Davison's best death-acting being overshadowed by the magnificent Nicola Bryant.
But one point away from the psychedelic yelling-spinning of Troughton, and the strangely wafty nonsense with the Lurker at the end of the great Tom Baker.
There, see if we can't get this thread bumped
EDIT: I've tried rejigging your list to make it a bit more digestible...posters can check the first one if they need a reminder of episode names. Is that better?