oh my god that vocal was FAR from faultless. She shrieked on and was technically SHARP on a lot of the big notes. Her head voice was out of control, it didn't settle in one tuneful register but doubtfully wobbled. Parts of the performance were nice though, but the song was too big for her. I personally think that is one of the very few songs that should NOT be touched by anyone.
I thought Sam was great, i am a little bit annoyed that people are saying that it wasn't as good as Leonas version because thats not what Sam was trying to acheive.
She was just trying to make it her own, and not try and compete with Leonas version thats all! In terms of what i have seen tonight she was the best again, but like i say every single week, you dont vote for talent you vote for whos most attractive so all this work shes putting in is probably going to be in vein as some jumped up young kid will end up winning but anyhow that aside faultless again!
i thought it was very good to be fair. what a huge song to take on and i think she brought a lot of emotion to her performance. "bleeding love" will always be leona's signature song, but actually, its probably the x factor's signature song too and she had the biggest task tonight in my opinion.
i can understand why its not to every bodies taste and there will always arm chair vocal experts on hand to deliver scathing reviews, but actually it was a big song to undertake and she did very well.:)
foxyuk
Posts: 153
Comments
Steals the show? No, that was Luke.
Compare her on stage to a Streisand, Carey or Dion and it's not favourable
Big dress, big hair, big belter of a song. Week in, week out. :yawn:
She was just trying to make it her own, and not try and compete with Leonas version thats all! In terms of what i have seen tonight she was the best again, but like i say every single week, you dont vote for talent you vote for whos most attractive so all this work shes putting in is probably going to be in vein as some jumped up young kid will end up winning but anyhow that aside faultless again!
I thought Luke was great this week too.
Nicholas to an extent too
Yes, I looked away as she was singing and thought "would I buy this?" and the answer was "not in a million years."
Don't get her at all
i can understand why its not to every bodies taste and there will always arm chair vocal experts on hand to deliver scathing reviews, but actually it was a big song to undertake and she did very well.:)