Why wasn't Karen Hardy invited onto the judging panel?
foxy23
Posts: 4,392 Forum Member
✭✭✭
She's fantastic and has so much experience and technical knowledge, in comparison to Alesha Dixon!
0
foxy23
Posts: 4,392 foxy23
Posts: 4,392
Comments
I would love to see Karen on the panel.
Karen is too (dance) intelligent and as a previous world champion her technical knowledge too profound and we would miss Alesha saying "your musicality is good and you give it lots of energy"
Not!
She might have better things to do.....
Indeed didn't she spend half of last series in China judging a proper dance competition.
She'd get my vote though. I love listening to her talk choreography and technique on ITT. She has a great deal of credibility and respect.
Because she knows what she is talking about. You can't have judges like that :rolleyes:
Still glad she is not on the panel. This is an entertainment show first and foremost. Too much proper knowledge of B&L dancing would spoil this image and she is still somewhat positive anyway so no real gain.
Besides, it would only be worthwhile if it was a serious dance show.
Well put
I would love to see either Karen, Lilia or Camila as a judge - all three women talented, knowlegable, each has judging experience, each has won SCD so they know how the celeb feels when competing in SCD - for me it would mean that the only female on the panel would be equal to her male colleagues
Thank you for your contribution. It's amazing that no-one has ever made that comment before on this forum.
Oh, and did you notice that Alesha's grammar is not the Queen's English either?
Face it, no matter who was on the judging panel, people would complain loudly and vociferously.
It's quite amusing seeing all this villification of Alesha, when I recall the equally numerous and angry responses to Arlene's presence on the show!
It's human nature - we love to complain (although I'm not sure why. I prefer to try to look on the bright side. Life's too short!
Of course we would - and do, about Craig, Len and Bruno.
Alesha's just a much bigger target because of her lack of actual dance knowledge and experience when set against the rest of the judges. Hiring Karen or someone like her would at least remove the most obvious reason for dislike levelled at Alesha. And I say this as someone who found Karen deeply irritating during her time on the show.
Given that Karen's comments during this season in Choreography Corner have been profoundly stupid, inane, pointless and / or just plain wrong, I'm not convinced she'd be any better.
Bashing her before she's even been hired...you'll be telling us she starts every sentence with the wrong grammatical construction next
Yeah. Signs of great discernment there, Karen.