Cher was flat throughout her performance last night
GibsonSG
Posts: 23,681
Forum Member
✭✭✭
She didn't hit a single note bang on and neither did Mary. What has happened to the judges? Normaly they would have pointed this out, but not this year. It has all become a bit flaccid and 'worthy'.
0
Comments
The second half of the show was in a different league for me (except Wagner of course!)
I think that the judges are trying to talk up so acts to keep them in for a fre more weeks
It certainly was a show of two halves! I was despairing until Aiden and Paige came on. To be honest it was like watching a second rate talent contest in a holiday camp. Better singers sitting at home watching that car crash last night.
Erm, if Cher didn't hit one single note bang on then I am pretty sure the song would have been unrecognisable ....I do absolutely agree that she was very flat in places, sharp in others and it was a pretty mediocre performance overall though. Mary was pretty awful tonight too.
Er! no she was close to a quarter out most of the way through, not singing completley different notes. So the song would be recognisable.
No. Just no.
The first line in particular was well out of tune.
She's been poor all the way through but last night was her worst by a country mile. Don't even attempt an Alicia Keys song unless your voice is spot on and hers really was nowhere near.
Worst of the night imo (not including Wagner who does have some car crash value)
WOT!!!!!! You are entitled to your opinion but oh dear if you thought she was the best female.
wow really? the others must of been bad then
for me it does not matter a jot I would rather have a performance I can relate to than a dull high hitter.
no way, even if were just a case of actually hitting the correct notes she would fail on this count alone.
Add in the performance level and the likeability facor and she is easly the worst female there
Well I don't completly disagree but this is a singing competition and frankly the performance just covers up a lack of musical talent. Last week proved that. So if you are watching X Factor just to be entertained and with no thought of the 'musical' aspect then vote for Wagner.
I bet you were a Jedward fan last year
Don't bother searching - she was carp!
Is that like being shti?
you my friend always do!!
I didn't enjoy her performance at all, and it was very out of tune to me.
I agree. I dont like Cher but to pick an Alicia Keys song is just suicide. She was poor last night, I wonder why they put her on first?
All I can say is "lol"
I hope Cher is booted out tonight. I can't listen to that song anymore with out thinking of last night's performance.