[Ryan_InsideBB]

Originally Posted by Redmond

As much as Grodner rigs things it can never be 100% full proof. There is always someone that could mess things up for them and things beyond their control.

In other news I really don't think this season will be All Stars 2. Although I wouldn't rule out ex-housemates been involved in some shape or form.

I think the fact there are the most houseguests EVER means there has to be some sort of twist relating to ex-houseguests or previous relationships between the cast. They would never do a normal season with lots of brand new people.

[Kyle123]

My Allstar cast would be:

Dan - Only recent winner that was both gamesmart and good to watch, and frankly Allstars wouldn't be the same without him!
Dick - I don't want three-peaters, and I don't like Dick much, but I could make an exception considering the way Dick had to leave last year, plus he is a genuine Allstar.
Dominic - Struggled for a 7th male, but he had a lot of potential and was very popular. I'd give him a second try at the game.
Eric - Hopefully this time without the constraints of AP
Kevin - Really strong player, and fun to watch. He'd be a good dark horse again.
Matt - Not a personal favourite, but he does bring a sense of unpredictability and would be by far the only member of the "Brigade" worth bringing back
Russell - There's bound to be one "villain" in the cast, so may as well pick one that was actually good at the game too. Be fun to see what would happen with Russell & Dick!

Britney - One of the most fun-to-watch housemates in years, and I'd like to see how she played the game after what happened last time
Jen - How could they not have her back!
Keesha - One of my personal favourites. She's a likable girl, got involved in so much drama, and managed to play some big moves too!
Libra - Wouldn't happen really, but Libra was a potentially fantastic player who went a bit early. She controlled so much early in BB10 though, so deserves another shot.
Lydia - A random choice, but she brought so much freaking drama and would be guaranteed to bring it again. Not a great player, but a strong personality choice.
Natalie - Natalie of BB9 that is! She was a total carcrash, but was by far the most interesting player in the second half of BB9, so I'd give her a go!
Shelly - Deserves it after a gripping game last Summer. Prob wouldn't return, but she deserves a shot at redemption. Also by far the best of the older players.

I'd also consider: Renny, Sheila, Kathy (jk ), Michele if she hadn't gone all crazy post BB11, Ragan, and of course my poor Laura ()

[mindset]

Originally Posted by Kyle123

I still think she'd have done something to try to help them out though. Diamond power of change a juror perhaps?

It's not really much of stretch to wipe out 1 Jury vote, given that they have previously used a "Nullify An Eviction Vote" as a Veto reward.

Originally Posted by Ryan_InsideBB

If we are going with All Stars 2, my ideal lineup would be:

Eric BB8 - Deserves another shot on his own but how cool would it be to make him be AP again!

Highly intelligent, good strategy, good social skills. What's not to like? Not as AP again though ty.

Jessica BB8 - I had a soft spot for how she played the game

Not enough of a gamer to be a worthy All Star. A tailgater.

Jen BB8 - Great entertainment but seems normal outside the house

Well she sure wasn't normal inside the House LOL. She can return though, so I can hate her all over again.....

Daniele BB8/13 - One of my fav players of all time

Loved her ferocity in BB8, hated her foolishness in BB13. Will never be the superstar/living legend that is Evel Dick.

Sharon BB9 - Another soft spot houseguest

Interesting "sleeper" type game player. Robbed by Grodner, worth another shot.

Amanda BB9 - A trainwreck who needs to go back in but prob wouldn't cus of her child

Too easily destroyed by Chelsia. No chance.

Dan BB10 - Former winner has to go in

My 2nd best rated player ever.

Keesha BB10 - Loved her in BB10

Too busy inflicting her awful laugh on wealthy boyfriends (allegedly) to return, thankfully.

Kevin BB11 - One of the few saviours of BB11 and a nice guy

Intelligent, empathetic and good strategist. More please.

Annie BB12 - Was screwed by the saboteur twist and had real potential

Vastly over-rated by many, especially herself.

Britney BB12 - Really entertaining and played the game well

Very funny, bitchy and intelligent. Too fearful to be a winner though. Not smart enough to see through Lane.

Ragan BB12 - A smart player who provides lots of comedy/arguments

Much like, but not as entertaining as Britney, not smart enough to see through Matt.

Kalia BB13 - My favourite newbie last season needs to come back

Another player who was a legend in her own mind. Serious absence of subtlety.

Shelly BB13 - Made one of the biggest moves in the game so deserves to come back

Much to admire; a real player, just lacked patience.

Porsche BB13 - Really good at competitions once she woke up half way through the season

A very cold fish indeed. Glad she lost.



Having said all this, I hope and pray no one returns! Hahaha

[Journal]

Annie is the only player since Season 8 that I would whole-heartedly back for another series. I have a longggggg list of those who I'd love to see play again such as Sheila (BB9), Jen (BB8), Matt (BB12) and Kalia (BB13), but the most tragic early loss of BBUSA has to be Annie. Her character and value to the show was head and shoulders above the rest of the house right from the beginning long before she was revealed as the Saboteur. I'd sooner exchange half the BB12 cast for one more week of Annie. Had she not been recruited as the Saboteur I believe she would have been a Big Brother All-Star in every sense of the word. I can't give her too much credit because she had no one to blame but herself for being evicted so early, but the potential she had as a player was huge. I remember thinking she was the Saboteur because I thought looking at everyone in the house, production probably felt she would best pull it off, but I was just gutted when they made the reveal, we will very likely never see Annie again, why did they have to make the Saboteur someone who held such presence on their own?! Kathy would have made a much better puppet for the production's 'sabotage' efforts.

That said, Rachel obviously MADE BB12 worth watching during her time there and had Annie stayed over her I doubt those first few weeks would have been as entertaining, if you can call it that!

My ideal BB14 would be half the cast as returning houseguests (and in a sense would be the 'All-Star' season everyone had anticipated would happen at this stage), the other half as new players but not a group so obviously engineered to allow for veteran dominance. No pre-existing groups like High School cliques or Dynamic Duos, they say the most houseguests ever so lets say 18 players, 9 of each, two of those fantastic double eviction weeks, and a twist that can utilise the big crowd of players and change the game for at least the four-week period that their gimmicks usually last for.

Eventually I'd like to see three nominees just for the start of a season, but not with the 'most houseguests ever'. I sort of wish everyone played for the veto, but I'm sure theres enough reasons why they never carried that on beyond the obvious - wanting the drama of the veto actually seeing more usage.

[Yobaba**]

I was Jen and only Jen. Everybody else can go to hell.

[ferfer]

Holy cow. I read this title and almost started jumping up and down! I would love to see another All Stars, but this was cruel posting it as if it was fact.

[Y2Jin99]

Originally Posted by Kyle123

My Allstar cast would be:

Dan - Only recent winner that was both gamesmart and good to watch, and frankly Allstars wouldn't be the same without him!
Dick - I don't want three-peaters, and I don't like Dick much, but I could make an exception considering the way Dick had to leave last year, plus he is a genuine Allstar.
Dominic - Struggled for a 7th male, but he had a lot of potential and was very popular. I'd give him a second try at the game.
Eric - Hopefully this time without the constraints of AP
Kevin - Really strong player, and fun to watch. He'd be a good dark horse again.
Matt - Not a personal favourite, but he does bring a sense of unpredictability and would be by far the only member of the "Brigade" worth bringing back
Russell - There's bound to be one "villain" in the cast, so may as well pick one that was actually good at the game too. Be fun to see what would happen with Russell & Dick!

Britney - One of the most fun-to-watch housemates in years, and I'd like to see how she played the game after what happened last time
Jen - How could they not have her back!
Keesha - One of my personal favourites. She's a likable girl, got involved in so much drama, and managed to play some big moves too!
Libra - Wouldn't happen really, but Libra was a potentially fantastic player who went a bit early. She controlled so much early in BB10 though, so deserves another shot.
Lydia - A random choice, but she brought so much freaking drama and would be guaranteed to bring it again. Not a great player, but a strong personality choice.
Natalie - Natalie of BB9 that is! She was a total carcrash, but was by far the most interesting player in the second half of BB9, so I'd give her a go!
Shelly - Deserves it after a gripping game last Summer. Prob wouldn't return, but she deserves a shot at redemption. Also by far the best of the older players.

I'd also consider: Renny, Sheila, Kathy (jk ), Michele if she hadn't gone all crazy post BB11, Ragan, and of course my poor Laura ()

Would love to see Dick and Lydia in the house. He absolutely despises her and I would love to see him go crazy on her.

[Y2Jin99]

Their is no reason to believe this season is all stars. They will just have another twist gimmick. Not sure what it its. Maybe all stars next year so America can get a break from Rachel. Cuz you know she is gonna be in All stars.

Dick said he won't do it with Danielle again so Dani has to be out and Dick has to be in.

Who knows. I hear the twist is announced on 7/2

[Tyyleer]

The title of this thread is misleading as nothing has been confirmed yet

I would love another all stars season.. But not yet. I'm hoping for a whole new cast for this season. I would love to see Danielle and Rachel return (again) but i think we need a break from them and from old hms for at least 1 summer.