Paije Richardson - entertaining
Aiden Grimshaw - usually I like him, but well below par
Mary Byrne - better than last week, but really a star?
Katie Waissel - poor overall as usual, sometimes she sounded OK but lacks consistency
Matt Cardle - very good, his voice is getting stronger
Cher Lloyd - the singing was reasonable, but the non-singing part is embarrasing
Wagner - the whole performance is appalling. I assume the votes for him are from RATM supporters.
One Direction - fun, but how much of what you hear is their voices?
Rebecca Ferguson - started quietly, but the controlled power she has was "amazing".
Only two performers have the X-Factor for me - Matt and Rebecca. The rest are from week to week just there to make up the numbers.
Comments
Aiden Grimshaw - usually I like him, but well below par
Mary Byrne - better than last week, but really a star?
Katie Waissel - poor overall as usual, sometimes she sounded OK but lacks consistency
Matt Cardle - very good, his voice is getting stronger
Cher Lloyd - the singing was reasonable, but the non-singing part is embarrasing
Wagner - the whole performance is appalling. I assume the votes for him are from RATM supporters.
One Direction - fun, but how much of what you hear is their voices?
Rebecca Ferguson - started quietly, but the controlled power she has was "amazing".
Only two performers have the X-Factor for me - Matt and Rebecca. The rest are from week to week just there to make up the numbers.
> The rest
Rebecca
Cher
Got my vote.
In a league of his own;)
4th division,:D