It's a difficult one to choose, as even the word as even the word judge covers different areas, like their role as a critic, a mentor and an entertainer. So I'll just do my favourites:
1. Sharon Osbourne (totally nuts)
2. Louis Walsh (see above)
3. Nicole Scherzinger
4. Simon Cowell
5. Tulisa
6. Mel B
7. Cheryl Cole
8. Kelly Rowland
9. Dannii Minogue
10. Gary Barlow (mooooan)
Surprised myself with that . . . I guess I do like the slightly mad ones, even if they're terrible mentors. Could never be doing with Gary and Dannii, who never seemed to get that it was a show and not all about who had the best technical voice (something Dannii definitely should be aware of - and I say that as someone who actually owns her music)
1. Nicole
2. Danni
3. Tulisa
4. Sharon.
5. Cheryl
6. Gary
7. Simon
8. Mel B
9. Louis
10. Kelly
In doing this it helps to really assess the judges, and my observations have been obviously based on past performance, but heavily based on this years diabolical performance. I actually looked forward to Simon and Cheryl return, but certainly was rather doubtful about Mel B from her performance in auditions etc. Louis is just Louis and has really stayed firstly as he is Simon's man, but more importantly because it seems to be difficult to get viable men judges WHY
What is needed is to find one/two suitably qualified male judges (not in Simon Cowell's pocket). and link them to Nicole, Tulisa, but my next two would come from Danni and/or Sharon, but it would take some persuading for either to come back. I think the major element would be no interference from Simon i.e not telling them who to vote for !!!!!!!!
I am aware that the results were supposed to come in weeks ago, so I apologise for the very late reply! I'm now going to announce your favourite judges in reverse order.....
Comments
1. Sharon Osbourne (totally nuts)
2. Louis Walsh (see above)
3. Nicole Scherzinger
4. Simon Cowell
5. Tulisa
6. Mel B
7. Cheryl Cole
8. Kelly Rowland
9. Dannii Minogue
10. Gary Barlow (mooooan)
Surprised myself with that . . . I guess I do like the slightly mad ones, even if they're terrible mentors. Could never be doing with Gary and Dannii, who never seemed to get that it was a show and not all about who had the best technical voice (something Dannii definitely should be aware of - and I say that as someone who actually owns her music)
1.Simon Cowell
2.Nicole Scherzinger
3.Danni Minogue
(hmm, ok)
4.Sharon Osbourne
(completely forgotten about her)
5.Kelly Rowland
(awful)
6.Tulisa
7.Cheryl Cole
8.Mel B
9.Louis Walsh
10. Gary Barlow
1 Simon
2 Kelly
3 Nicole
4 Danni
5 Cheryl
6 Gary
7 Mel
8 Tulisa
9 Sharon
10 Louis
Danni
Tulisa
Kelly
Gary
Sharon
Mel B
Simon
Louis
Cheryl
2 gary
3 simon
4mel
5 Danni
6. sharon
7 Tulisa
8 Cheryl
9 Louis
10 Kelly
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
The Rest.
Sharon.
2. Danni
3. Tulisa
4. Sharon.
5. Cheryl
6. Gary
7. Simon
8. Mel B
9. Louis
10. Kelly
In doing this it helps to really assess the judges, and my observations have been obviously based on past performance, but heavily based on this years diabolical performance. I actually looked forward to Simon and Cheryl return, but certainly was rather doubtful about Mel B from her performance in auditions etc. Louis is just Louis and has really stayed firstly as he is Simon's man, but more importantly because it seems to be difficult to get viable men judges WHY
What is needed is to find one/two suitably qualified male judges (not in Simon Cowell's pocket). and link them to Nicole, Tulisa, but my next two would come from Danni and/or Sharon, but it would take some persuading for either to come back. I think the major element would be no interference from Simon i.e not telling them who to vote for !!!!!!!!
Kelly
Nicole
2 - Sharon Osbourne
3 - Dannii Minogue
4 - Louis Walsh
5 - Simon Cowell
6 - Gary Barlow
7 - Tulisa
8 - Kelly Rowland
9 - Mel B
10 - Cheryl
2. Dannii
3. Simon
4. Nicole
5. Mel B
6. Kelly
7. Sharon
8. Louis
9. Gary
10. Cheryl
Dannii Minogue
Mel B
Simon Cowell
Nicole Scherzinger
Sharon Osbourne
Gary Barlow
Kelly Rowland
Tulisa
Cheryl F V
Louis Walsh
2. Nicole
3. Cheryl
4. Dannii
5. Tulisa
6. Sharon
7. Mel
8. Gary
9. Louis
10. Kelly
2.Simon
3. Dannii
4. Louis
5. Mel B
6. Kelly Rowland
7. Gary
8. Nicole
9. Tulisa
10. Sharon
My top 4 are my favourite panel.
2 - Dannii
3 - Louis
4 - Sharon
5 - Mel B
6 - Simon
7 - Gary
8 - Kelly
9 - Nicole
10 - Cheryl
1. Dannii
2. Gary
3. Nicole
4. Mel
5. Simon
6. Kelly
7. Tulisa
8. Sharon
9. Louis
10. Cheryl
[So S4 panel was my fave, but that season was awful /: ]
Louis Walsh
Dannii Minogue
Simon Cowell
Sharon Osbourne
Tulisa
Nicole Scherzinger
Kelly Rowland
Mel B
Gary Barlow
Cheryl Cole