The News Quiz Radio 4

24

Comments

  • Sid LawSid Law Posts: 4,702
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    It isn't funny

    It's anti government from beginning to end

    It's on the BBC

    All down to your personal perceptions. It is a well known fact that most of those with right of centre political views are in the main a bunch of miserable buggers that think that everything wrong in the world is the fault of the lefties.

    Me and my o/h find it very funny. The fact that it is anti (UK) government is fine with us, and the fact that it is on radio 4 on the BBC is a delicious irony.

    We don't enjoy it purely for these reasons - in fact one of the funniest things we have ever heard on it was a comment made by Jeremy Hardy (I think) - describing the Scots (which we both are) as haggis munching subsidy junkies.

    No one is ever going to enjoy every different type of comedy. I am at a loss to understand why Lee Mack is so successful, so I avoid watching anything he is in.

    Maybe you should avoid listening to the news quiz?
  • Rich Tea.Rich Tea. Posts: 22,048
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    The thing that ruins the News Quiz for me is Jeremy Hardy. I just don't find the guy funny.

    Fine as a guest panelist but not every week.
    Agree with you. On the panel far too much and the guests need a bit of a shake up with some fresh input and perspectives.

    I'm pleased I can podcast the show, and just wish I could do the same with Just A Minute. The comics that do Just A Minute never seem to cross over much to do News Quiz for some reason.
  • gomezzgomezz Posts: 44,615
    Forum Member
    I don't bother with the podcast but wait for the Monday evening extended version on R4X.
  • davelovesleedsdavelovesleeds Posts: 22,619
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sid Law wrote: »

    No one is ever going to enjoy every different type of comedy. I am at a loss to understand why Lee Mack is so successful, so I avoid watching anything he is in.

    Maybe you should avoid listening to the news quiz?

    So true, a lot of Radio 4 comedy is Marmite. My wife thinks Count Arthur Strong is hysterical but it leaves me cold, where I loved Claire In The Community,which she hates. She doesn't enjoy The News Quiz either but I enjoy it,
  • Isambard BrunelIsambard Brunel Posts: 6,598
    Forum Member
    Rich Tea. wrote: »
    the guests need a bit of a shake up with some fresh input and perspectives.

    It seems the BBC know there's a problem and things are changing. There were a couple of new voices in the last series who weren't so right-on left-wing, though the well-settled audience at times seemed uncomfortable raising a giggle at some of their genuinely funny quips. Of course, they still hurt their sides laughing whenever Jeremy Dry said "The Tories are rubbish!" or "Oh, the Tories, eh?" or "I'm not voting for Cameron" etc.

    And now Toksvig's out, "to embark on a new and exciting stage of her career". Yeah, her and Nick Clegg both.

    Any guesses for the new host? Will they just move one of the regular panellists like Susan Calman or get some fresh blood to revamp the show. I wonder if Frank Skinner could be in the frame?
  • Lone DrinkerLone Drinker Posts: 1,699
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    It seems the BBC know there's a problem and things are changing. There were a couple of new voices in the last series who weren't so right-on left-wing, though the well-settled audience at times seemed uncomfortable raising a giggle at some of their genuinely funny quips. Of course, they still hurt their sides laughing whenever Jeremy Dry said "The Tories are rubbish!" or "Oh, the Tories, eh?" or "I'm not voting for Cameron" etc.

    And now Toksvig's out, "to embark on a new and exciting stage of her career". Yeah, her and Nick Clegg both.

    Any guesses for the new host? Will they just move one of the regular panellists like Susan Calman or get some fresh blood to revamp the show. I wonder if Frank Skinner could be in the frame?

    Hardy ?
  • lundavralundavra Posts: 31,790
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I think they will find it difficult to recover, too many people will just have given up on the programme like I have.
  • the forgemasterthe forgemaster Posts: 82
    Forum Member

    Any guesses for the new host? Will they just move one of the regular panellists like Susan Calman or get some fresh blood to revamp the show. I wonder if Frank Skinner could be in the frame?

    If Susan Calman gets the gig, I'll stop listening. Her voice is like a cheese grater down my privates.

    And she has a more annoying laugh than Toksvig.
  • Marmite BabyMarmite Baby Posts: 3,598
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I'd love Andy Zaltzman (from the excellent Bugle podcasts with John Oliver) to be the new host but think Calman will take over.
  • JT2060JT2060 Posts: 5,370
    Forum Member
    I'd love Andy Zaltzman (from the excellent Bugle podcasts with John Oliver) to be the new host but think Calman will take over.

    Zaltzman would be perfect. Just the right amount of cynicism and ennui,
  • davelovesleedsdavelovesleeds Posts: 22,619
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    If Susan Calman gets the gig, I'll stop listening. Her voice is like a cheese grater down my privates.

    And she has a more annoying laugh than Toksvig.

    Not as bad as Sarah Millican.

    Her voice is so bad I cannot watch or listen to anything she does.
  • dave2702dave2702 Posts: 2,394
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    JT2060 wrote: »
    Zaltzman would be perfect. Just the right amount of cynicism and ennui,

    As long as he lays off the puns, I like the Bugle podcasts but when he goes on one of his Pun-runs it's time to hit ffwd
  • Isambard BrunelIsambard Brunel Posts: 6,598
    Forum Member
    Which panellists do you think will feature on Sandi Toksvig's final show?

    I'd have thought the most appropriate farewell panel would be Jeremy Hardy, Mark Steel, Andy Hamilton and Susan Calman, but Calman and Hardy were on this week's penultimate show.

    I still think Frank Skinner would be an interesting choice for a new shaken-up News Quiz.
  • curmycurmy Posts: 4,725
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    As long as it's not another Leftie !

    I loved the programme when Barry Took was the host, with Richard Ingram & Alan Coren on the panel ( Yes I'm that old ) :D Sandy Toksvig sounded like a chicken when she laughed ! I hear she's off to form her own Femenists Equality Party or something !
  • davelovesleedsdavelovesleeds Posts: 22,619
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Tonight's panel on Sandi's final show will be Andy Hamilton, Phill Jupitus and Francis Wheen along with Jermeny Hardy.

    I don't mind Sandi, I enjoy her sense of humour so it'll be interesting to see who is the new host.
  • JELLIES0JELLIES0 Posts: 6,709
    Forum Member
    Passengers wrote: »
    If the News Quiz was a person it would live in Islington, wear sandals and read The Guardian. It would send its children to private school whilst insisting everyone else's kids go the local comprehensive.

    I think your description accurately describes almost the entire BBC.
  • JELLIES0JELLIES0 Posts: 6,709
    Forum Member
    Sid Law wrote: »
    All down to your personal perceptions. It is a well known fact that most of those with right of centre political views are in the main a bunch of miserable buggers that think that everything wrong in the world is the fault of the lefties.

    Me and my o/h find it very funny. The fact that it is anti (UK) government is fine with us, and the fact that it is on radio 4 on the BBC is a delicious irony.

    We don't enjoy it purely for these reasons - in fact one of the funniest things we have ever heard on it was a comment made by Jeremy Hardy (I think) - describing the Scots (which we both are) as haggis munching subsidy junkies.

    No one is ever going to enjoy every different type of comedy. I am at a loss to understand why Lee Mack is so successful, so I avoid watching anything he is in.

    Maybe you should avoid listening to the news quiz?

    The problem of course is that the Beeb always favours the left, there is no broadcaster of comparable size and with comparable finances as an alternative to this socialist monolith and to add insult to injury the cheeky blighters charge us £145.50 a year for their services whether we want them or not.

    It's a bit like the old GDR in fact.
  • curmycurmy Posts: 4,725
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    JELLIES0 wrote: »
    The problem of course is that the Beeb always favours the left, there is no broadcaster of comparable size and with comparable finances as an alternative to this socialist monolith and to add insult to injury the cheeky blighters charge us £145.50 a year for their services whether we want them or not.

    It's a bit like the old GDR in fact.

    I gather Ofcom might be taking over from the BBC Trust, so we might finally get a bit of balance !
  • curmycurmy Posts: 4,725
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Originally Posted by Sid Law

    All down to your personal perceptions. It is a well known fact that most of those with right of centre political views are in the main a bunch of miserable buggers that think that everything wrong in the world is the fault of the lefties.

    Well they're right :D Also the Right are probably busy making money for the country , while the Left sit about pontificating :)
  • lundavralundavra Posts: 31,790
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Sid Law wrote: »
    All down to your personal perceptions. It is a well known fact that most of those with right of centre political views are in the main a bunch of miserable buggers that think that everything wrong in the world is the fault of the lefties.

    Though most of those with left of centre political views are in the main a bunch of miserable buggers who think that everything wrong in the world is the fault of the RIght.

    Perhaps just a comment on anyone with strong political opinions.
  • oldtvnewsguyoldtvnewsguy Posts: 31
    Forum Member
    Tonight's panel on Sandi's final show will be Andy Hamilton, Phill Jupitus and Francis Wheen along with Jermeny Hardy.

    I don't mind Sandi, I enjoy her sense of humour so it'll be interesting to see who is the new host.

    I listened to the last one...so glad she has gone. I prefered the late Barry Took.
  • Welsh-ladWelsh-lad Posts: 51,925
    Forum Member
    Sad to see Sandi go as she is genuinely funny, witty and quick off the mark.
    Can't believe it's been nine years since she took over from Simon Hoggart :o

    I'm quite centre left politically and the show works for me in that regard though it has recently gotten very monotonous in its denigration of the same politicians week in week out.
    Jeremy Hardy is funny and while I do like his weekly monologues, they have got unremmitting of late.
    I can well imagine if one is even a smidgeon right wing, this programme gets right on your nerves.
  • gomezzgomezz Posts: 44,615
    Forum Member
    Hardy can be funny but oh, so predictable and boring at times too.
  • oldtvnewsguyoldtvnewsguy Posts: 31
    Forum Member
    For several years this has not been a news quiz but a platform for left wing alternative comedy artists to vent their spleen.

    Sandy is the worst and so obvious in her politics and her delivery in pre scripted so called jokes.

    There is scope for a News Quiz but I want to hear curve balls being thrown at journalists
    and newspaper editors.

    The current crowd know the questions a week in advance.
  • curmycurmy Posts: 4,725
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Nobody but the Beeb would employ Jeremy Hardy or Mark Steel !
Sign In or Register to comment.