Is Cheryl waiting for confirmation on other judges!!? for XF USA!! DO U THINK!!?

iluvdannii · 23/12/10 - 18:59

Do u think she's been offered it but is waiting to see who the other female judge is!!!!!!? cause i can't see her wanting to do it if someone else as attractive as her and someone who would be competition for her!!!! e.g nicole, katy who are also more talented!!!!?

Also how they can sit her on the same judging panel as Mariah Carey (or someone of her level of fame/success) is beyond me!

neelia · 23/12/10 - 19:25

She would be hard to be trumphed as The Pretty One

KieranDS · 23/12/10 - 20:52

Do you think she actually worries about that?

[Deleted User] · 23/12/10 - 20:55

I would be shocked if the people behind Fox News decide to let a nobody be a judge over an American celebrity.

THEXFACTORKING · 23/12/10 - 23:42

If she is picked as a judge, solidifying that Americans are stupid, than I will dress up as Donald Duck and run around the city streets screaming out ' what a quack"

batman. · 23/12/10 - 23:44

I doubt she'll care who else is there as long as she is.

jediknight2k1 · 23/12/10 - 23:46

Anightlikethis wrote: »

I would be shocked if the people behind Fox News decide to let a nobody be a judge over an American celebrity.

Simon Cowell as a nobody before American Idol.

When the launch XF-USA there will obviosuly be a huge PR push with the judges being given the usual talk show slots(Letterman etc).

There's also that little thing called "The American Dream".

THEXFACTORKING · 23/12/10 - 23:48

or the American Sweetheart * grabs a bucket and vomits*

batman. · 23/12/10 - 23:49

THEXFACTORKING wrote: »

or the American Sweetheart * grabs a bucket and vomits*

Would you not have to be American to have that title? :L

[Deleted User] · 23/12/10 - 23:50

jediknight2k1 wrote: »

Simon Cowell as a nobody before American Idol.

When the launch XF-USA there will obviosuly be a huge PR push with the judges being given the usual talk show slots(Letterman etc).

There's also that little thing called "The American Dream".

Surely, if she *does* go, they're not actually going to let her... Talk...??!! Wouldn't her job be the 'sit and look pretty' one??

mrellis33 · 23/12/10 - 23:52

i doubt shes even been offered the gig. Seriously, shes a small fish compared to some of the names being thrown around (i've now heard Will Smith, George Michael, Noel Gallagher, Cher (old one), Mariah Carey, Jamie Foxx)

PADDY75 · 24/12/10 - 19:17

mrellis33 wrote: »

i doubt shes even been offered the gig. Seriously, shes a small fish compared to some of the names being thrown around (i've now heard Will Smith, George Michael, Noel Gallagher, Cher (old one), Mariah Carey, Jamie Foxx)

If Cowell wants her there then she'll be there. It makes no difference what you or I think.

BReal2 · 24/12/10 - 19:46

I heard both she and Nicole Scherzinger are doing it. That can only work in Nicole's favor imo as she is more famous here than Cheryl, has a better voice imo and is more beautiful imo.

iluvdannii · 24/12/10 - 19:51

BReal2 wrote: »

I heard both she and Nicole Scherzinger are doing it. That can only work in Nicole's favor imo as she is more famous here than Cheryl, has a better voice imo and is more beautiful imo.

NOT ONLY THAT BUT NO OFFENCE TO CHESSA BUT NICOLE HAS WAY MORE PERSONALITY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SuperAPJ · 25/12/10 - 01:50

THEXFACTORKING wrote: »

If she is picked as a judge, solidifying that Americans are stupid, than I will dress up as Donald Duck and run around the city streets screaming out ' what a quack"

Ooh, now I want Cheryl to get the job!

[Deleted User] · 25/12/10 - 02:07

BReal2 wrote: »

I heard both she and Nicole Scherzinger are doing it. That can only work in Nicole's favor imo as she is more famous here than Cheryl, has a better voice imo and is more beautiful imo.

Doubt it - they'd both be filling the same role on the panel (pretty, young, vacant female). They'll want one person to fill that role, and then either a maternal older woman or a quirky young one. (of course, if they could get a quirky maternal older woman - Paula Abdul-esque - that would be perfect.)

jediknight2k1 · 25/12/10 - 11:44

Darren-5-10 wrote: »

Surely, if she *does* go, they're not actually going to let her... Talk...??!! Wouldn't her job be the 'sit and look pretty' one??

Why not let her talk as American's aren't all elitist snobs who base their opinion on accents.

rickster1995 · 25/12/10 - 12:46

the first year cheryl was amazing had the personality and the fiest but now she is just miserable

zx50 · 25/12/10 - 13:30

jediknight2k1 wrote: »

Simon Cowell as a nobody before American Idol.

When the launch XF-USA there will obviosuly be a huge PR push with the judges being given the usual talk show slots(Letterman etc).

There's also that little thing called "The American Dream".

Also, I'd hardly describe Girls Aloud as being "nobodies". I'd imagine that they've got a lot of fans here in the U.K and quite a few in America.

jediknight2k1 · 25/12/10 - 14:24

zx50 wrote: »

Also, I'd hardly describe Girls Aloud as being "nobodies". I'd imagine that they've got a lot of fans here in the U.K and quite a few in America.

They do as the likes of YouTube have opened up the world to British groups all over the globe

.

At the end of the day Cowell will take who he wants and that's all there is to it

[Deleted User] · 25/12/10 - 15:07

jediknight2k1 wrote: »

Simon Cowell as a nobody before American Idol.

When the launch XF-USA there will obviosuly be a huge PR push with the judges being given the usual talk show slots(Letterman etc).

There's also that little thing called "The American Dream".

You know why they call it the "American Dream" because you have to be asleep to believe it. - George Carlin.

Always loved that quote

InMyArms · 25/12/10 - 18:20

If she didn't want to join a panel with another attractive woman on it she wouldn't have joined Dannii in the UK.

Floh · 25/12/10 - 18:48

Simon Cowell knows which side his bread's buttered on. When he believes it would make his US XFactor successful, he'll take her. I can't fathom the reason why he would believe her on the judging panel would be a success in the US, but then again I can't fathom the reason Simon Cowell makes so much money.

MTUK1 · 26/12/10 - 04:15

zx50 wrote: »

Also, I'd hardly describe Girls Aloud as being "nobodies". I'd imagine that they've got a lot of fans here in the U.K and quite a few in America.

LOL! They never released a single in the US. People like Perez wrote about them, but that's it. They would not have a huge fanbase there.

[Deleted User] · 26/12/10 - 05:43

It's not about how famous she is in the US imo. It's about chemistry with Simon. I think that is what made idol work. Simon and Paula had good chemistry. When she left Simon didn't get along with Kara and the judging panel felt awkward. I think Cheryl would be perfect because she is feisty and doesn't get intimidated by Simon. Just like Paula. I like Nicole but don't think she has what it takes to stand up to Simon. She is more like Dannii. They are talented but too sweet.

Also, the problem with big celebrities is that they want to please the people by always being nice. So they might not give any criticism like Ellen Degeneres for example. She was like a cheerleader that didn't add anything to idol. Someone like Mariah might be like that imo which makes the judging panel a little too boring.

I do think Katy might be able to stand up to Simon so she could also be a good choice.

[Deleted User] · 26/12/10 - 05:47

rickster1995 wrote: »

the first year cheryl was amazing had the personality and the fiest but now she is just miserable

I agree with this. Cheryl from the first year needs to come back. She was more constructive and gave more detailed critics. She was more feisty too. This year she looked drained and ready to quit the show. Probably the divorce and malaria got to her so I can also understand.

Hey there!

Quick Links

Is Cheryl waiting for confirmation on other judges!!? for XF USA!! DO U THINK!!?

Comments