Cowell says Jules will keep the title.

[Deleted User] · 02/06/15 - 17:48

This is unbelievable, so you can cheat the public, by not telling them a stand-in dog is used, win 1/4 million pounds from votes by the public, and Cowell is happy for her to keep the title. What a message that sends...

Now what's is Jonathan Antoine number, maybe he can stay back stage and sing, and I will mime at next year's BGT..

tawny · 02/06/15 - 17:52

At last somebody with some sense - well done Simon

xTonix · 02/06/15 - 17:54

tawny wrote: »

At last somebody with some sense - well done Simon

Agreed.

skp20040 · 02/06/15 - 17:56

myscimitar wrote: »

This is unbelievable, so you can cheat the public, by not telling them a stand-in dog is used, win 1/4 million pounds from votes by the public, and Cowell is happy for her to keep the title. What a message that sends...

Now what's is Jonathan Antoine number, maybe he can stay back stage and sing, and I will mime at next year's BGT..

Did it need a new thread to tell us that ? you could have added it in your other one on your utter outrage at the event , following your other one where you found it cruel for the dog to walk on a rope anyway. It does seem you had a thing about the dog act from the start

dellzincht · 02/06/15 - 18:03

skp20040 wrote: »

Did it need a new thread to tell us that ? you could have added it in your other one on your utter outrage at the event , following your other one where you found it cruel for the dog to walk on a rope anyway. It does seem you had a thing about the dog act from the start

Seem?? I think it's blatantly obvious.

[Deleted User] · 02/06/15 - 18:09

Source please.

lewismacf · 02/06/15 - 18:34

Are they keeping the title or not

[Deleted User] · 02/06/15 - 19:27

So it reported he sack the producers over this fraud, but he still keep the person who conned the public!

Lyceum · 02/06/15 - 19:33

tawny wrote: »

At last somebody with some sense - well done Simon

Thank god Simon has a brain in his head!

lewismacf · 02/06/15 - 19:46

I love dogs they are amazing

njp · 02/06/15 - 19:55

Does anyone know if anyone who actually voted for the dog act claims to have been cheated, or is the faux-outrage entirely orchestrated by a small gaggle of people unhappy with the result, and whipped into a fulminating frenzy by useless tabloid hacks, for whom any nonsense on twitter makes for an easy story, requiring no actual journalism?

dellzincht · 02/06/15 - 20:13

njp wrote: »

Does anyone know if anyone who actually voted for the dog act claims to have been cheated, or is the faux-outrage entirely orchestrated by a small gaggle of people unhappy with the result, and whipped into a fulminating frenzy by useless tabloid hacks, for whom any nonsense on twitter makes for an easy story, requiring no actual journalism?

It's the latter.

Heathyheath_ · 02/06/15 - 20:48

njp wrote: »

Does anyone know if anyone who actually voted for the dog act claims to have been cheated, or is the faux-outrage entirely orchestrated by a small gaggle of people unhappy with the result, and whipped into a fulminating frenzy by useless tabloid hacks, for whom any nonsense on twitter makes for an easy story, requiring no actual journalism?

I voted for Jules and Matisse. I don't even want her to lose her winner's title but I do find what happened unethical and misleading, whether it's a big deal or not.

[Deleted User] · 02/06/15 - 20:50

Heathyheath_ wrote: »

I voted for Jules and Matisse. I don't even want her to lose her winner's title but I do find what happened unethical and misleading, whether it's a big deal or not.

And that is why she should be stripped of the win, it was misleading and that being kind to say just that.

CBFreak · 02/06/15 - 20:50

And the faux outrage threads keep coming. It's a tv show for crying out loud. If you want to get so overheated about something why not about the Debacle of FIFA?

spikewoman · 02/06/15 - 21:04

Oh come on Simon is just milking a bit of end of series drama for the column inches.

Every act had to be heavily rehearsed and the directors would be trimming everything to the split second and telling everyone what to do, where to stand, how long they'd got etc including Ant and Dec. Cut to this, cut to that, interview fox X seconds and so on and so forth. The crew running the show knew EXACTLY what was going on, what we'd see and so forth and if they thought it controversy worthy would have reported it to La Cowell who would probably have rubbed his hands with glee and said "run with that and make it look worse"

Nothing went on that the directors didn't know would happen and they condoned the lot. I bet you they had a bit of "dirt" on every act so whoever won they could have an end of season ruckus about it.

Frankly Amanda and Alesha's barely concealed puppies were more controversial than Jules' performing ones.

CollieWobbles · 02/06/15 - 21:11

Thank goodness Simon has sense!

Not that it should even be questioned, because she won fair and square.

She trained the dogs

The dogs are all her own dogs

Her own dog walked the rope

Matisse did 90% of the tricks and he can do the tightrope trick too he's just not very comfortable doing so so she used a dog that is for a few seconds

She hasn't done anything wrong.

Dalekbuster523 · 02/06/15 - 21:19

Simon Cowell: the voice of wisdom

Sarah Anne · 02/06/15 - 21:35

myscimitar wrote: »

So it reported he sack the producers over this fraud, but he still keep the person who conned the public!

Obviously the producers were in on it and advised her! She hardly smuggled a dog up her top!

Dalekbuster523 · 02/06/15 - 21:36

Sarah Anne wrote: »

Obviously the producers were in on it and advised her! She hardly smuggled a dog up her top!

This. You can't hide a dog that size.

jerefprdterra · 02/06/15 - 21:40

The man has no shame. Simply disgusting.

Sarah Anne · 02/06/15 - 21:43

People are foolish to believe there will be an investigation and that Jules would be disqualified. Jules could probably sue for being advised to do this act and defamation of character. Has nobody complaining noticed that all week whenever an act went wrong or Simin didn't like it he said "WE have let you down tonight!! Says it all!
People who work on the show should know better and be more experienced with the public!

Hank1234 · 02/06/15 - 21:43

What are they supposed to do?? ,.. The shows over now and people voted

dellzincht · 02/06/15 - 21:44

jerefprdterra wrote: »

The man has no shame. Simply disgusting.

Go on, say something about Revelation Avenue being robbed, you know you want to.

gregrichards · 02/06/15 - 21:45

myscimitar wrote: »

This is unbelievable, so you can cheat the public, by not telling them a stand-in dog is used, win 1/4 million pounds from votes by the public, and Cowell is happy for her to keep the title. What a message that sends...

Now what's is Jonathan Antoine number, maybe he can stay back stage and sing, and I will mime at next year's BGT..

He is feckless this is shameful and an utter disgrace. Cheats should never prosper.

Dalekbuster523 · 02/06/15 - 21:45

jerefprdterra wrote: »

The man has no shame. Simply disgusting.

Blimey. He's not justifying murder.

It's a TV talent show, for God's sake.

Hey there!

Quick Links

Cowell says Jules will keep the title.

Comments