Options
Digital Spy: It's Not The Same Old Song [Show 1]
afallingstar
Posts: 328 Forum Member
✭
Hello Digital Spy and welcome to It's Not The Same Old Song, the show where opinions really count!
Let's bring our acts out:
I've Got Class and the BOYS
John Wilding
Paije Richardson
Matt Cardle
Craig Colton
_NiallDEE_ and the GIRLS
Misha B
Sophie Habibis
Rachel Adedeji
Rebecca Ferguson
pothuthic and the OVERS
Ben Mills
Kitty Brucknell
Sami Brookes
Johnny Robinson
StigOfTheKrump and the GROUPS
The Keys
Husstle
2 Shoes
JLS
Let's bring our acts out:
I've Got Class and the BOYS
John Wilding
Paije Richardson
Matt Cardle
Craig Colton
_NiallDEE_ and the GIRLS
Misha B
Sophie Habibis
Rachel Adedeji
Rebecca Ferguson
pothuthic and the OVERS
Ben Mills
Kitty Brucknell
Sami Brookes
Johnny Robinson
StigOfTheKrump and the GROUPS
The Keys
Husstle
2 Shoes
JLS
0
Comments
Singing Robert Palmer's Addicted to Love, it's Sophie Habibis!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcATvu5f9vE
haz_cat: 4
SacredDiablo: 1
Spanner82: 7
Total: 18/40
So much for agreeing with scores!
We must go to SacredDiablo after his 1:
What rubbish is this? i just didnt get it at all. No way does this suit her voice and neither does it bring out the best of her amazing vocal tone. For me, it was worst than karaoke.
Next tonight is StigOfTheKrump's first group! Singing James Morrison and Jessie J's Up, it's The Keys!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LWgQ-wiPls4&ob=av2e
haz_cat: 5
SacredDiablo: 4
Spanner82: 5
Total: 22/40
Let's go to haz_cat!
That was OK. It wasn't incredible but it wasn't bad.
Following them is I've Got Class's first boy, Paige Richardson, singing The Righteous Brothers' Unchained Melody!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-idDbIfGvw
You've got my least descriptive comment there
Have to agree with SacredDiablo on that one, that was a pretty awful choice, I hope _NiallDEE_ can salvage it...
haz_cat: 7
SacredDiablo: 2
Spanner82: 4
Total: 21
Because of that low score, we must go to SacredDiablo.
To be honest, its pretty awful. I have to keep slapping myself real hard in order to be awake until the end of the performance.
Woah! Now up with the Michael Jackson song Ben is pothuthic's first over, Johnny Robinson!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msqfQpoFTYk
Woah indeed! That was in my top 3 performances...
haz_cat: 7
SacredDiablo: 6
Spanner82: 8
Total: 27/40
Let's go to Spanner82!
A very different choice from what I would have expected for you, Johnny but again it works!
Next tonight is Niall's second girl, with Adele's Don't You Remember, it's Rachel Adedeji!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RDRwqTNLGDs&ob=av3e
And I can definitely see the MJ song working for Johnny, the Overs are in good hands now.
yeah at least i have spanner on my side of the panel:D. Just to add on that i really gave very very very good scores to those that are really good.
ill just post one on my own
johnny Robinson
6/10 - Well, i thought that is was a pretty good performance. A great song choice so well done to your mentor as well. Just note that i got a little annoyed with your voice as the song progressed. However that is whats so unique about you so i dont think i can fault it but its just my personal opinion.
haz_cat: 6
SacredDiablo: 3
Spanner82: 5
Total: 20
Once again, we'll be going to SacredDiablo (BTW, Ryan sent no comments so we can't go to him) about his THREE!
Not the kind of songs she should sing, as a mentor you have the responsibility to showcase her talent. She is an all round entertainer and should head in the direction.
Next up is StigOfTheKrump's second group, performing Bruno Mars' Runaway Baby is JLS!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Ww-8jvxT5Q
haz_cat: 7
SacredDiablo: 7
Spanner82: 10
Total: 30/40
Wow, a 10 on night 1! We must go to Spanner82.
OK i'm officially blown away for act to song choices this is the best hands down
Woo! Next up is I've Got Class' second boy, Matt Cardle, singing Ben Folds' Still Fighting It!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZJyATtouGM
:eek: Have to agree that that was one of the best.
haz_cat: 6
SacredDiablo: 6
Spanner82: 5
Total: 24
Let's go to haz_cat for their opinion.
Matt, that was a strong performance generally, but I thought it was a bit weak in parts. X Factor winners can do better.
Next up tonight is poth's second over, Sami Brookes, singing Pinocchio's When You Wish Upon A Star!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4cHsPCAZlP4
Most of mine are longer, they picked my shortest comment
well, at least we gave the same score for two consecutive performances
haz_cat: 7
SacredDiablo: 5
Spanner82: 6
Total: 27
I think SacredDiablo should have a say on this one.
I kinda like the arrangement even though it got a little sleepy. You gave your best effort and overall it is quite well done
Next, singing Macy Gray's hit I Try, is Niall's third girl Rebecca Ferguson!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViyC5X2DRS4
haz_cat: 6
SacredDiablo: 6
Spanner82: 9
Total: 30
Well, Spanner has a very productive comment, so let's go to him:
WOW!
Okay! Next is StigOfTheKrump's third group, singing Gwen Stefani's What You Waiting For it is Husstle!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdcObAQ5OOM
Just kidding, it's really fun to see that the direction you're taking Sami in is so fundamentally different from the one I'd have taken her in if I was still on the show.
And WOW JLS, props to Stig for the best song choice so far!
haz_cat: 6
SacredDiablo: 6
Spanner82: 5
Total: 25
Let's see what SacredDiablo has to say.
Great song choice for them. Well done to their mentor. The leads and harmonies were good, great delivery.
Next to perform is I've Got Class' third boy, with Rihanna's California King Bed, it's John Wilding!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nhBorPm6JjQ&ob=av3e
make it three and four
Think my comment for this one wasn't too bad