Yes, it was Gomes' fault. Though Nani dived and/or handballed, the ref played advantage instead of giving a freekick as Gomes had the ball in his hands. The ball was in play when Gomes dropped it.
it looked a pen, the nani threw himself to the floor and handled it, gomes picked it up and thw whistle never blew. i agree with the ref playing on keeping a flow to the game.
only one man at fault is gomes (although the ref could of given a pen and then a fk).
Absolute farce from the referees - a clear dive and handball from Nani who reaches out for the ball. If the incident involved any other team on the planet than Manchester United the goal would not have stood.
Absolute farce from the referees - a clear dive and handball from Nani who reaches out for the ball. If the incident involved any other team on the planet than Manchester United the goal would not have stood.
No one denies it could have a free kick, but the ref played an advantage, as he would for any other team on the planet.
Absolute farce from the referees - a clear dive and handball from Nani who reaches out for the ball. If the incident involved any other team on the planet than Manchester United the goal would not have stood.
What about the first goal, that y'know, up till then was winning United the game? :rolleyes: Smokescreen.........
Absolute farce from the referees - a clear dive and handball from Nani who reaches out for the ball. If the incident involved any other team on the planet than Manchester United the goal would not have stood.
there was a dive but before that he was pulled back.
the ref said play on gomes had the ball in his hands, the ball was never dead so how could it not of stood?
Absolute farce from the referees - a clear dive and handball from Nani who reaches out for the ball. If the incident involved any other team on the planet than Manchester United the goal would not have stood.
Should've been a penalty in the first place, before the dive. Or in the words of Chris Waddle - 'pelanty'
I can see why spurs fans were upset but they should direct their fury at the goalkeeper.
If he thought it was a free kick why did he throw the ball down in the wrong place and then kick it further away from where the free kick would have been awarded?
The ref thought, its a free kick but the ball is in the GKs hands so play on. Maybe that was a mistake by the ref but regardless the Spurs keeper had the ball and made a complete arse of things!
I can see why spurs fans were upset but they should direct their fury at the goalkeeper.
If he thought it was a free kick why did he throw the ball down in the wrong place and then kick it further away from where the free kick would have been awarded?
The ref thought, its a free kick but the ball is in the GKs hands so play on. Maybe that was a mistake by the ref but regardless the Spurs keeper had the ball and made a complete arse of things!
i agree, refs make enough silly mistakes without getting the blame for things like this.
With 10 minutes to go including stoppage time Spurs definitely were in with a chance of equalising
And equally, United could have scored another. Spurs fans are arguing like it was 0-0 at the time. The reality is niether side really looked like scoring from sixty minutes on and Spur's most creative player had gone off.
Absolute farce from the referees - a clear dive and handball from Nani who reaches out for the ball. If the incident involved any other team on the planet than Manchester United the goal would not have stood.
Are you serious? Nani embellished but Kaboul was clearly grabbing his jersey because he was beaten on the pass. Should've been a penalty given in the first place.
Comments
Did you even take the 30 seconds required to look up whether or not that was a goal?
beat me to it
only one man at fault is gomes (although the ref could of given a pen and then a fk).
Impartiality well out of the window there.
i agree, it turned into fanzone for a minute with waddle backing him up.
they didnt even mention that gomes decided to try and steal 10 yards if a fk had been given.
No one denies it could have a free kick, but the ref played an advantage, as he would for any other team on the planet.
What about the first goal, that y'know, up till then was winning United the game? :rolleyes: Smokescreen.........
there was a dive but before that he was pulled back.
the ref said play on gomes had the ball in his hands, the ball was never dead so how could it not of stood?
Should've been a penalty in the first place, before the dive. Or in the words of Chris Waddle - 'pelanty'
Here Here.
The cameras didn't show at any point the referee signal an advantage
With 10 minutes to go including stoppage time Spurs definitely were in with a chance of equalising
The ref only signalled play on once Gomes had rolled it onto the ground
Would have been the softest penalty I've seen this season
If he thought it was a free kick why did he throw the ball down in the wrong place and then kick it further away from where the free kick would have been awarded?
The ref thought, its a free kick but the ball is in the GKs hands so play on. Maybe that was a mistake by the ref but regardless the Spurs keeper had the ball and made a complete arse of things!
Incidentally I am NOT a Man U fan, but AM a referee.
do they show the ref stopping play?
i didnt see the ref at the timeof the incident but that was when nani asked
i have seen softer, he pulled him back and thats a pen.
i agree, refs make enough silly mistakes without getting the blame for things like this.
90% a goal keeping error only 10 % the ref's fault,
And equally, United could have scored another. Spurs fans are arguing like it was 0-0 at the time. The reality is niether side really looked like scoring from sixty minutes on and Spur's most creative player had gone off.
Like I said, smoke.
it all comes down to what was said in the discussion between the ref and linesman.
if the linesman saw the handball and the ref has overruled him then clattenderg should get a couple of weeks off.
if neither of them saw the handball then its a goal and both should get a couple of weeks off.
Are you serious? Nani embellished but Kaboul was clearly grabbing his jersey because he was beaten on the pass. Should've been a penalty given in the first place.
If the Linesman said it was a free kick and Clattenberg said he'd given the advantage to Gomes who had the ball in his hand then it's Gomes' fault.
Anyway if it was a free kick shouldn't it have been where the handball took place?