The act I'm saving is Shayne as he does actually have some talent and despite flopping in later years is still one of the best male winners the show has produced imo.
118. 2 To Go
Between the four remaining choices this was the best one I felt to justify. He was blind, she was average, and Simon Cowell basically told her she wasn't good enough thus meaning she was in tears and had to be comforted by the wonderful Kate Thornton. Having Louis Walsh as a mentor meant they were guaranteed a spot in the live shows giving performances such as this. Truthfully it was clear the guy (yes I can't remember their names) had a pretty decent voice but their performances were incredibly bland and no one was shocked when they exited in week three. Sorry to do this to you Kevin - at least there are still others like Voices With Soul left for you to support.
Now over to David to recreate the final five showdown in s3
So it comes down to Ben Mills and Eton Road... Would be lying if I said I had any form of loyalty to either, so it's going to come down to I feel is the more bearable of the two.
As a result of this...
117 - Ben Mills
It should be no surprise to anybody when I say Ben is not my cup of tea. His voice, his attitude, his whole character and most importantly... his hair. He was all kinds of gross and unfortunately I had no time for him. I was so happy when he came 3rd because he really didn't deserve to make it that far at all and I basically wanted him evicted every single week. It's not really shocking that he's been a total flop since the show and thank goodness for that because I'm not sure my ears would be able to handle if his music went on to be popular. I literally would rather lock myself in a room and listen to PSY for 12 hours. (Also he's one of Lucas' favourites and therefore I feel obliged to cut him, sorrynotsorry.)
- - -
This does mean that the cheesiness of Eton Road are safe from elimination this round and next.
Save - Nicholas Dorsett.
Nicholas was one of my favourite contestants in the early seasons of X-Factor. He was really good looking - see pic! http://static9.imagecollect.com/preview/560/b3fd62b78c096ac, and would have made such a fab soul/urban singer, but Louis completely threw him under the bus to focus on Shayne Ward in Season 2. He was actually very talented albeit sadly forgotten by most and I think he definitely deserves another chance in this comp!
Eliminate - 116. Daniel Evans
Daniel is best remembered for two things on X-Factor, his dead wife which was awful but it was brought up constantly on the show, and became one of the most exploited contestant sob stories ever on the show. He was also memorably compared by Louis to Ricky Gervais (David Brent) which was a pretty fair comparison. Nice guy but no x-factor bye Daniel.
Save - Nicholas Dorsett. Nicholas was one of my favourite contestants in the early seasons of X-Factor. He was really good looking - see pic! http://static9.imagecollect.com/preview/560/b3fd62b78c096ac, and would have made such a fab soul/urban singer, but Louis completely threw him under the bus to focus on Shayne Ward in Season 2. He deserves another chance in this comp!
Eliminate - Daniel Evans
Daniel is best remembered for two things on X-Factor, his dead wife which was awful but it was brought up constantly on the show, and became one of the most exploited contestant sob stories by the show. He was also memorably compared by Louis to Ricky Gervais which was a pretty fair comparison. Nice guy but no x-factor bye Daniel.
Remember to put the number of the act you've eliminated Marsha
115 - Craig Colton
Craig has been dead bottom of my annual "All time rankings list" (the one conducted by yohinchild) since the day he graced our screens. I'm not actually sure why I loathed him so much? Then I remembered how he stole James Michael's rightful position in the last 12. I remember Gary Bore-low fawning all over him with his Middle-of-the-road garbage and his utterly shocked "This is outrageous" face when Craig finally got eliminated. I think what bugged me the most was Craig's "constipation"-emotive face that he used to pull during his performances that kind of looked like a seriel killer who fantasizes about necrophilia aka http://img.metro.co.uk/i/pix/2011/10/14/article-1318599484687-0E4D030700000578-483460_466x310.jpg
SAVE -
I'm saving Jamie Archer. He really didn't do well under Simons mentorship (Simon literally knows nothing about rock) and he was constantly called a pub singer by that prick Louis. However, Jamie's performance of "Hurt" is still one of my favourite ever performances today. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZUOKI-FStI
Thus began the archetype of older male contestant with the inability to make commercial music due to appealing to only one demographic. This was also one of the first times we saw someone being dramatically brought back into the judges' room after Louis correctly identified the problem that would plague season 1: the reality that Steve was completely uninspiring musically speaking.
Sadly the second chance storyline was the ignition for Steve to sail to victory, but not before he his iconic annihilation at the hands and teeth of Sharon Osbourne as witnessed here. Obviously Sharon went way OTT and Britain was NOT having that so this probably did everything necessary to ensure a Steve win so thanks Sharon, although she was correct that he was as average as possible and would give inspiration to many future male acts looking to copy his journey, although so far none have managed it thank the lord.
I don't have strong feelings about the rest so I'm saving Verity lol.
Now someone save Diva Fever and Hannah Barrett already, we need a bit of cheese and soul to go through
Of the four left I would definitely like Hannah, she was annoying but she did have a fab voice, and then one of Diva Fever/Lucy. I could take or leave Robert!
I choose to save Hannah Barrett because she is BAE.
113 - Robert Allen
And therefore I choose to eliminate Robert Allen because honestly, he's one of the most forgettable X Factor contestants to date. I had to google him in order to remember him and youtubing his performances showed me how amateurish he actually is. Unsure how he made the finals, but I know for a fact that he's O U T of this X Factor rankdown.
112. Lucy Spraggan.
Oh dear, if you wanted this creature saved then you shouldn't have left her to me. Her "songwriting" (aka, every song in the exact same chord with some laughably unintellectual lyrics) is embarrassing. Her voice is worse than a woman going through labour and frankly, I'd rather listen to a walrus sing for the rest of my days rather than this person, though they'd probably sound the same. Yes, you can play the guitar, congratulations - go queue up with the other millions of people who can do the same.
The first 'joke' act of the series, and one of my least favourites ever. Sure, he had 'personality' - but it didn't stop his atrocious vocals casting a black cloud over series 2. The whole 'he's fun' act got boring after week three and 'It's Chico Time' was an abomination as a song. I cringed every time he was on screen and it says a lot that I'd choose to eliminate Wagner over him. Chico set the precedent for mediocre acts making it way further than they should and as a result I'm happy to get rid of him early.
Saving Ruth Lorenzo - one of my favourites from season 5 - she was slightly over hyped on DS, but still adore her Purple Rain
Save - This was tricky as I do like Jedward for the fun factor and they did try their best! But I will save Misha B I thought she was very talented but the producers threw her under the bus with the whole bullygate episode - for sheer talent I will save Misha B, here is one her performances from the live shows which I liked: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idaoG74UKzg
114. 4Tune - I have chosen to eliminate the bland, the boring, the completely forgettable 4Tune, I vaguely rememebered they were an older look boyband that were in Season 2, and I was right. They didn't look great - http://img.rasset.ie/000062b3-630.jpg, and they didnt sing great, and were a very very forgettable boring band of Westlife wanna-bes, their time is up in this competition too - bye guys!
113 - John Adeleye
I vaguely remember him, I think he was thrown under a bus as he had like no air time? And then got eliminated in the b2 with Treyc. To be honest, he seemed like a nice chap but was completely forgetable, i remember he wore a sparkley silver suit the week he got eliminated and there was a dirty dancing choreography in the background and the judges just focused on that (deramping the act), wherever John is today, i hope he's content as he was a nice man but was completely dull and forgetable.
SAVE - I am going to save LORD WAGNER. This man lit up my Saturday night with his sexy body and infectious accent. I still await for his heart to complete my wagner shrine.
Why not cull 4Sure in the same 24 hours as 4Tune given that they are both week 2 footnotes in their respective series with very similar style/name/inability to connect with the voters. The only reason I was reluctant to do so is that I don't have to say on them as YouTube was unhelpful and even more annoyingly some guys in the US version also decided to call themselves 4Sure, unwisely, as they too failed to make an impact.
Anyway, back to the TRUE 4Sure; I feel like every decision made in series 3 was a carefully implemented machination on the part of Simon to ensure Leona victory and so it is not surprisingly that technically proficient acts like these guys were early casualties, but still the most interesting thing about their audition video (which is all I could find) is the first second which is a monstrosity, but actually nothing to do with them.
Saving Jedward for being hawt.
Comments
118. 2 To Go
Between the four remaining choices this was the best one I felt to justify. He was blind, she was average, and Simon Cowell basically told her she wasn't good enough thus meaning she was in tears and had to be comforted by the wonderful Kate Thornton. Having Louis Walsh as a mentor meant they were guaranteed a spot in the live shows giving performances such as this. Truthfully it was clear the guy (yes I can't remember their names) had a pretty decent voice but their performances were incredibly bland and no one was shocked when they exited in week three. Sorry to do this to you Kevin - at least there are still others like Voices With Soul left for you to support.
Now over to David to recreate the final five showdown in s3
Who can post as soon as David chooses between Ben and Eton Road o: o: o:
As a result of this...
117 - Ben Mills
It should be no surprise to anybody when I say Ben is not my cup of tea. His voice, his attitude, his whole character and most importantly... his hair. He was all kinds of gross and unfortunately I had no time for him. I was so happy when he came 3rd because he really didn't deserve to make it that far at all and I basically wanted him evicted every single week. It's not really shocking that he's been a total flop since the show and thank goodness for that because I'm not sure my ears would be able to handle if his music went on to be popular. I literally would rather lock myself in a room and listen to PSY for 12 hours. (Also he's one of Lucas' favourites and therefore I feel obliged to cut him, sorrynotsorry.)
- - -
This does mean that the cheesiness of Eton Road are safe from elimination this round and next.
ETA Glad to see Eton Road were saved, I am a big Ben fan but I thought Eton Road were fab! Had to laugh at your Ben description though David!
Interested to see Rory's picks!!
Steve Brookstein
Verity Keays
Nicholas Dorsett
Robert Allen
Daniel Evans
Jamie Archer
Diva Fever
Craig Colton
Lucy Spraggan
Hannah Barrett
Nicholas was one of my favourite contestants in the early seasons of X-Factor. He was really good looking - see pic! http://static9.imagecollect.com/preview/560/b3fd62b78c096ac, and would have made such a fab soul/urban singer, but Louis completely threw him under the bus to focus on Shayne Ward in Season 2. He was actually very talented albeit sadly forgotten by most and I think he definitely deserves another chance in this comp!
Eliminate - 116. Daniel Evans
Daniel is best remembered for two things on X-Factor, his dead wife which was awful but it was brought up constantly on the show, and became one of the most exploited contestant sob stories ever on the show. He was also memorably compared by Louis to Ricky Gervais (David Brent) which was a pretty fair comparison. Nice guy but no x-factor bye Daniel.
Remember to put the number of the act you've eliminated Marsha
Thanks for the reminder Rory! Have edited now
Craig has been dead bottom of my annual "All time rankings list" (the one conducted by yohinchild) since the day he graced our screens. I'm not actually sure why I loathed him so much? Then I remembered how he stole James Michael's rightful position in the last 12. I remember Gary Bore-low fawning all over him with his Middle-of-the-road garbage and his utterly shocked "This is outrageous" face when Craig finally got eliminated. I think what bugged me the most was Craig's "constipation"-emotive face that he used to pull during his performances that kind of looked like a seriel killer who fantasizes about necrophilia aka http://img.metro.co.uk/i/pix/2011/10/14/article-1318599484687-0E4D030700000578-483460_466x310.jpg
SAVE -
I'm saving Jamie Archer. He really didn't do well under Simons mentorship (Simon literally knows nothing about rock) and he was constantly called a pub singer by that prick Louis. However, Jamie's performance of "Hurt" is still one of my favourite ever performances today. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZUOKI-FStI
114. Steve Brookstein
Thus began the archetype of older male contestant with the inability to make commercial music due to appealing to only one demographic. This was also one of the first times we saw someone being dramatically brought back into the judges' room after Louis correctly identified the problem that would plague season 1: the reality that Steve was completely uninspiring musically speaking.
Sadly the second chance storyline was the ignition for Steve to sail to victory, but not before he his iconic annihilation at the hands and teeth of Sharon Osbourne as witnessed here. Obviously Sharon went way OTT and Britain was NOT having that so this probably did everything necessary to ensure a Steve win so thanks Sharon, although she was correct that he was as average as possible and would give inspiration to many future male acts looking to copy his journey, although so far none have managed it thank the lord.
I don't have strong feelings about the rest so I'm saving Verity lol.
Now someone save Diva Fever and Hannah Barrett already, we need a bit of cheese and soul to go through
Of the four left I would definitely like Hannah, she was annoying but she did have a fab voice, and then one of Diva Fever/Lucy. I could take or leave Robert!
113 - Robert Allen
And therefore I choose to eliminate Robert Allen because honestly, he's one of the most forgettable X Factor contestants to date. I had to google him in order to remember him and youtubing his performances showed me how amateurish he actually is. Unsure how he made the finals, but I know for a fact that he's O U T of this X Factor rankdown.
A caj reminder you can't nominate any of those saved in the previous round, GL!
Oh dear, if you wanted this creature saved then you shouldn't have left her to me. Her "songwriting" (aka, every song in the exact same chord with some laughably unintellectual lyrics) is embarrassing. Her voice is worse than a woman going through labour and frankly, I'd rather listen to a walrus sing for the rest of my days rather than this person, though they'd probably sound the same. Yes, you can play the guitar, congratulations - go queue up with the other millions of people who can do the same.
Save: Diva Fever, of course.
1. Ruth Lorenzo
2. Wagner
3. Chico Slimani
4. 4Sure
5. 4Tune
6. John Adeleye
7. Nicolo Festa
8. MK1
9. Misha B
10. Jedward
The first 'joke' act of the series, and one of my least favourites ever. Sure, he had 'personality' - but it didn't stop his atrocious vocals casting a black cloud over series 2. The whole 'he's fun' act got boring after week three and 'It's Chico Time' was an abomination as a song. I cringed every time he was on screen and it says a lot that I'd choose to eliminate Wagner over him. Chico set the precedent for mediocre acts making it way further than they should and as a result I'm happy to get rid of him early.
Saving Ruth Lorenzo - one of my favourites from season 5 - she was slightly over hyped on DS, but still adore her Purple Rain
114. 4Tune - I have chosen to eliminate the bland, the boring, the completely forgettable 4Tune, I vaguely rememebered they were an older look boyband that were in Season 2, and I was right. They didn't look great - http://img.rasset.ie/000062b3-630.jpg, and they didnt sing great, and were a very very forgettable boring band of Westlife wanna-bes, their time is up in this competition too - bye guys!
I vaguely remember him, I think he was thrown under a bus as he had like no air time? And then got eliminated in the b2 with Treyc. To be honest, he seemed like a nice chap but was completely forgetable, i remember he wore a sparkley silver suit the week he got eliminated and there was a dirty dancing choreography in the background and the judges just focused on that (deramping the act), wherever John is today, i hope he's content as he was a nice man but was completely dull and forgetable.
SAVE - I am going to save LORD WAGNER. This man lit up my Saturday night with his sexy body and infectious accent. I still await for his heart to complete my wagner shrine.
111. Chci
110. 4Tune
109. John Adeleye
108. 4Sure
Why not cull 4Sure in the same 24 hours as 4Tune given that they are both week 2 footnotes in their respective series with very similar style/name/inability to connect with the voters. The only reason I was reluctant to do so is that I don't have to say on them as YouTube was unhelpful and even more annoyingly some guys in the US version also decided to call themselves 4Sure, unwisely, as they too failed to make an impact.
Anyway, back to the TRUE 4Sure; I feel like every decision made in series 3 was a carefully implemented machination on the part of Simon to ensure Leona victory and so it is not surprisingly that technically proficient acts like these guys were early casualties, but still the most interesting thing about their audition video (which is all I could find) is the first second which is a monstrosity, but actually nothing to do with them.
Saving Jedward for being hawt.
Leaving me to carry the dubious honour of Round 6. The spinner will then reset for Round 7 onwards!
Updated Wikia as of 4Sure