Chris Chibnall - 5
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 13 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6
Matthew Graham - 7 Hurt
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 18
Helen Raynor - 9
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 4 HURT
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 13
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 19 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 9
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
I think this thread is very cruel. It's different judging a writer rather than a companion or a Doctor. With a character, you're not criticizing an individual's work or performance. You can dislike a companion without thinking that the actor did a bad job, or that the companion was badly written etc...
Of course, continue with it if you want to, if you enjoy it then enjoy it. But I do wonder if the posters on here would want work from their own occupation rated in such a way.
I think this thread is very cruel. It's different judging a writer rather than a companion or a Doctor. With a character, you're not criticizing an individual's work or performance. You can dislike a companion without thinking that the actor did a bad job, or that the companion was badly written etc...
Of course, continue with it if you want to, if you enjoy it then enjoy it. But I do wonder if the posters on here would want work from their own occupation rated in such a way.
What mysterious profession do you work in where your work isn't appraised? If writers are putting themselves out there and getting payed inordinate sums of money to write one of the pre-eminent dramas on british television - surely a bit of scrutiny goes hand-in-hand with that?
Anyway - as far as I can see writers like chris chibnall and mark gatiss need a reality check so they can buck up their ideas and try harder. Precipitous drops in quality from season premieres to episodes like "cold war" or "dinosaurs on a spaceship" are half the reason why the show has been underperforming ratings-wise in recent years.
Chris Chibnall - 4
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 13
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 20 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 8 Hurt
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 4
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 14 heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5 hurt
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 4
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14 HEAL
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae -6 HURT
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 4
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 15 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6 Hurt
Tom MacRae -6
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 4
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14 Hurt
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 7 Heal
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 4
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 15 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6 Hurt
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 4
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14 HURT
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 21 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 3 HURT
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6 HEAL
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12 heal
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5 hurt
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15 HEAL
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 5 HURT
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 13 HURT
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6 HEAL
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 13
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 22 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 7 HURT
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 5 Hurt
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 22
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5 Hurt
Steven Moffat - 22
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 1
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15 Russell T. Davies - 14 (HURT)
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5 Steven Moffat - 23 (HEAL)
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 1
Chris Chibnall - 4 HEAL
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4 HURT
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
I fixed Whithouse, as he magically went from 11 to 1
Chris Chibnall - 3 HURT
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5 HEAL
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Had to edit mine as I posted mine at the same time as the post above and we picked the same writers.
Chris Chibnall - 3
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15 heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4 hurt
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Chris Chibnall - 2 hurt
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 12 heal
Chris Chibnall - 1 hurt
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 24 heal
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 12
Chris Chibnall - 1 hurt
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15 Russell T. Davies - 14 (HURT)
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5 Steven Moffat - 25 (HEAL)
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 12
Comments
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 13 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6
Matthew Graham - 7 Hurt
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 18
Helen Raynor - 9
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 13
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 19 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 9
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Of course, continue with it if you want to, if you enjoy it then enjoy it. But I do wonder if the posters on here would want work from their own occupation rated in such a way.
What mysterious profession do you work in where your work isn't appraised? If writers are putting themselves out there and getting payed inordinate sums of money to write one of the pre-eminent dramas on british television - surely a bit of scrutiny goes hand-in-hand with that?
Anyway - as far as I can see writers like chris chibnall and mark gatiss need a reality check so they can buck up their ideas and try harder. Precipitous drops in quality from season premieres to episodes like "cold war" or "dinosaurs on a spaceship" are half the reason why the show has been underperforming ratings-wise in recent years.
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 13
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 20 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 8 Hurt
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 13
Russell T. Davies - 14 heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5 hurt
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae - 7
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14 HEAL
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 7
Tom MacRae -6 HURT
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 15 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6 Hurt
Tom MacRae -6
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14 Hurt
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 7 Heal
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 15 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6 Hurt
Steven Moffat - 20
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14 HURT
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 21 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 11
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 6 HEAL
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 12 heal
Neil Cross - 14
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5 hurt
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15 HEAL
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 5 HURT
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 13 HURT
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6 HEAL
Steven Moffat - 21
Helen Raynor - 8
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 13
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 6
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 22 HEAL
Helen Raynor - 7 HURT
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 5 Hurt
Tom MacRae - 6
Steven Moffat - 22
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15 Heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5 Hurt
Steven Moffat - 22
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 1
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14 (HURT)
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23 (HEAL)
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 1
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4 HURT
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
I fixed Whithouse, as he magically went from 11 to 1
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 5 HEAL
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Had to edit mine as I posted mine at the same time as the post above and we picked the same writers.
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15 heal
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4 hurt
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 11
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 23
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 12 heal
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 15
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 24 heal
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 12
Nearly there chibnall
Paul Cornell - 12
Neil Cross - 15
Russell T. Davies - 14 (HURT)
Neil Gaiman - 12
Mark Gatiss - 4
Matthew Graham - 5
Tom MacRae - 5
Steven Moffat - 25 (HEAL)
Helen Raynor - 7
Gareth Roberts - 9
Stephen Thompson - 9
Toby Whithouse - 12