Options

Banished on BBC 2

1246725

Comments

  • Options
    Prince MonaluluPrince Monalulu Posts: 35,900
    Forum Member
    lundavra wrote: »
    But imagine the fuss if the programme portrayed the Aborigines as cannibals or the BBC did a drama about Gallipoli that showed the Australian troops in a very poor light. but just excused both as being fiction.

    Imagine whatever scenario makes you happy that there's some anti English thing going on, rather than a drama trying to sway the viewers emotionally and put bums on seats.

    Best leave that there, I think.
  • Options
    Jenny_SawyerJenny_Sawyer Posts: 12,858
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    lindenlea wrote: »
    That was Joseph Millson playing Major Ross, one of the real-life characters. He's done quite a lot of TV - I've seen him in the ShakespeaRe-told Macbeth, with James MacAvoy, and The Sarah-Jane Adventures, and several guest roles. He's also Carter in Casino Royale.




    Sam Wollaston in the Guardian wasn't impressed - very facetious review here:
    Banished review: 18th century Australia or I'm a Convict Get Me Out of Here

    I prefer this review by Grace Dent in the Independent (covers the first two episodes):
    Jimmy McGovern's Banished sheds light on sex slavery, leaves us feeling decidedly woebegone

    I'd never seen him before, I agree he's good-looking, horrible character but dishy actor.
  • Options
    Aurora13Aurora13 Posts: 30,246
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I'd never seen him before, I agree he's good-looking, horrible character but dishy actor.

    He goes after the Joanna Vanderham character I think. There was a brief shot this week of him eyeing her up
  • Options
    roddydogsroddydogs Posts: 10,308
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    With so much Shagg..g going on, Pregnancy & STDs seem surprisingly absent.
    I predict the spider will feature later on, but Tarantula bites are not often fatal.............
  • Options
    bornfreebornfree Posts: 16,360
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Just finished watching it on BBCi. I will tune in again. Enjoyed it even if it historically not correct. Read the Guardian review by Sam Wollaston and that made me tune in.
  • Options
    Doghouse RileyDoghouse Riley Posts: 32,491
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    roddydogs wrote: »
    With so much Shagg..g going on, Pregnancy & STDs seem surprisingly absent.
    I predict the spider will feature later on, but Tarantula bites are not often fatal.............

    You mean it wasn't a "Hhhhighly deadly black tarantula?"

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kyn4KJzbL3c
  • Options
    gemma-the-huskygemma-the-husky Posts: 18,116
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    it was gripping.

    I wondered how much of this was based on true tales, or whether it was all "imagined".

    Faramir was a good choice for the sympathetic "boss"
  • Options
    gemma-the-huskygemma-the-husky Posts: 18,116
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    roddydogs wrote: »
    With so much Shagg..g going on, Pregnancy & STDs seem surprisingly absent.
    I predict the spider will feature later on, but Tarantula bites are not often fatal.............

    I expected it to end up in the blacksmith's bed.

    otherwise

    a) they have only been there 10 days. it will take a while for a pregnancy to become apparent
    b) maybe there weren't any std's in OZ.
  • Options
    gemma-the-huskygemma-the-husky Posts: 18,116
    Forum Member
    ✭✭
    Was I the only one who didn't recognise Faramir?

    I recognized him from somewhere, but I had to look him up to see who it was. He's put on a bit of timber, I think. It's called doing a Kilmer.
  • Options
    Moll FlandersMoll Flanders Posts: 1,392
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Joseph Millson, was fairly recently in Holby City as Luc.

    Thankyou for that, it was really bugging me! I now remember Luc well, living in his caravan and dating that nurse who pulled funny faces (not deliberately),
  • Options
    shirlt9shirlt9 Posts: 5,085
    Forum Member
    Have only watched the first ten minutes. .recorded it and keep trying but poorly 7 year old around and not really suitable! !!!..first ten minutes has made me want to carry on..will have to sneak down in the middle of the night
  • Options
    DJW13DJW13 Posts: 4,278
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    I expected it to end up in the blacksmith's bed.

    otherwise

    a) they have only been there 10 days. it will take a while for a pregnancy to become apparent
    b) maybe there weren't any std's in OZ.

    How long would they have been on the boat to get there though?
  • Options
    Phil OwensPhil Owens Posts: 6,989
    Forum Member
    Managed to watch it last night.. Brilliant, didn't expect anything less from Jimmy McGovern.
    Can't wait for the next instalment..
  • Options
    Welsh-ladWelsh-lad Posts: 51,925
    Forum Member
    Crikey, Faramir has aged.
  • Options
    sealionsealion Posts: 240
    Forum Member
    Can someone help me with what the woman said to the priest to stop him pulling the lever. I just can't make it out.
  • Options
    gomezzgomezz Posts: 44,625
    Forum Member
    Something about it being seen as like the crucification ie the vicitim would become a martyr. Yes, I know. I thought it a bit iffy a hook to rely on the god-botherer *not* pulling the lever.

    It is in the mode of The Three Musketeers, Atlantis and Merlin as being a hokum adventure series rather than serious drama and I will continue to watch it in that frame of mind.
  • Options
    Mairi_CameronMairi_Cameron Posts: 350
    Forum Member
    sealion wrote: »
    Can someone help me with what the woman said to the priest to stop him pulling the lever. I just can't make it out.

    It was something like 'this is a crucifixion', not being religious myself I didn't understand why that would make him stop, hopefully someone else can explain!
  • Options
    tq21tq21 Posts: 1,693
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    It was something like 'this is a crucifixion', not being religious myself I didn't understand why that would make him stop, hopefully someone else can explain!

    Eh because he was a Christian & Christians believe their 'saviour' was crucified for his beliefs, so being responsible for a crucifixion of another would be the worst thing they could do to someone else.
  • Options
    [Deleted User][Deleted User] Posts: 0
    Forum Member
    DJW13 wrote: »
    How long would they have been on the boat to get there though?

    It took 8 months to get there.
  • Options
    koantemplationkoantemplation Posts: 101,293
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭✭
    tq21 wrote: »
    Eh because he was a Christian & Christians believe their 'saviour' was crucified for his beliefs, so being responsible for a crucifixion of another would be the worst thing they could do to someone else.

    Yes because that whole 'Thou shalt not kill' thing doesn't even come into it.
  • Options
    Mairi_CameronMairi_Cameron Posts: 350
    Forum Member
    I thought gomezz was nearer the mark with the idea of making him a martyr but I can't be sure, can't fathom the thought process that led the preacher to think hanging a man was better than remarrying him. It's not something that will spoil my viewing though, religion was a much bigger part of life in those days and I can watch with a sense of relief that things have changed.
  • Options
    Kat 68Kat 68 Posts: 426
    Forum Member
    DJW13 wrote: »
    How long would they have been on the boat to get there though?

    I've read a few books on this topic and find the various accounts riveting. It took months on the boat to reach their final destination with many not surviving the journey. The convicts were usually shackled to one another with women kept separate from the men.
  • Options
    seayork2002seayork2002 Posts: 234
    Forum Member
    When the priest walked off from the gallows and ended up at the Sydney headlands from where the hanging was taking place it would have taken a lot longer than a walk through the trees
  • Options
    bratwurztbratwurzt Posts: 2,707
    Forum Member
    ✭✭✭
    Absolute crap.
    All it was about was a couple wanting to marry and one going to get hanged then wasn't. Why was the man in charge and that woman so concerned about a couple of convicts? Why did the man in charge seem to care more about the welfare of some scummy convicts than his soldiers?
    Why did one of the lead characters speak in the same dialogue as someone off Eastenders?

    I hope this isn't the best they can come up with.
  • Options
    Kat 68Kat 68 Posts: 426
    Forum Member
    bratwurzt wrote: »
    Absolute crap.
    All it was about was a couple wanting to marry and one going to get hanged then wasn't. Why was the man in charge and that woman so concerned about a couple of convicts? Why did the man in charge seem to care more about the welfare of some scummy convicts than his soldiers?
    Why did one of the lead characters speak in the same dialogue as someone off Eastenders?

    I hope this isn't the best they can come up with.

    Maybe because that character is from the East End of London?!!!!
Sign In or Register to comment.