I don't really like that episode all that much, certainly isn't close to being the best for me. The dire attempt to rehash "everybody lives" at the end kills the episode stone dead.
They didn't live though, they were just thoughts in a computers memory.
Well according to the news last night, a computer effectively transmitted a DNA code into a cell, and the cell reproduced - could this be a way to bring River back after her death - but of course that opens the door for Adric too....
What a coincidence OP, I watched it round about the same time last night
And I cried too. River's words about the Doctor always knowing that she would come to this end had so much more emotion to them now that we've seen her in her past/the Doctor's future.
They didn't live though, they were just thoughts in a computers memory.
But they were shown to "live"....its just there bodies that don't exist, but their minds are pretty much alive forever, hence why the Doctor felt proud in saving River, Moff himself sees them as "alive".
For me its definitely the weakest of Moff's stories ever. Its too predictable, it feels like a greatest hits album when its only the fourth story from Moff, and the ending really does spoil it....if they had ended on the "everbody dies" note...it would have been a nice mirroring story to the Doctor dances.
The best thing going for it is the performances from everyone, and some of the witty dialogue....it alllows me to stay sitting and watch it on repeat viewings.
Really? I fell asleep during that episode but after rewatching it I'd say it was good but not bestest
Oh I have written essays on DS about why i think its the best!:D I won't repeat myself here as I haven't time....but I love everything about it....its the only story that has the same fear factor feeling that I had the first time round. And well everything about is top notch for me. Overall its a story that started out as marmite for fandom, but has been growing for many....only recently made the number one spot in the survivors game....that is one hell of an achievment for what was a splitting fandom type story!:)
Oh I have written essays on DS about why i think its the best!:D I won't repeat myself here as I haven't time....but I love everything about it....its the only story that has the same fear factor feeling that I had the first time round. And well everything about is top notch for me. Overall its a story that started out as marmite for fandom, but has been growing for many....only recently made the number one spot in the survivors game....that is one hell of an achievment for what was a splitting fandom type story!:)
It bears repeated viewing, which you can't say about all episodes and therefore may well be remembered for years to come. Personally I expect respect for Amy's Choice to grow and grow as time moves on, certainly the best of Matt's season so far. :cool:
It bears repeated viewing, which you can't say about all episodes and therefore may well be remembered for years to come. Personally I expect respect for Amy's Choice to grow and grow as time moves on, certainly the best of Matt's season so far. :cool:
I agree, Loved Amy's Choice, and although it didn't have a big split opinion as Midnight, it will certainly be a grower just like it.
:cool::)Though he is a great hero and does the job, its good like superman or batman , he doesnt always do well well like us humans , ok rory could be annoying to amy , she did love him but unlike rose , she was more humane and is more free thinking but cares more
What a coincidence OP, I watched it round about the same time last night
And I cried too. River's words about the Doctor always knowing that she would come to this end had so much more emotion to them now that we've seen her in her past/the Doctor's future.
It bears repeated viewing, which you can't say about all episodes and therefore may well be remembered for years to come. Personally I expect respect for Amy's Choice to grow and grow as time moves on, certainly the best of Matt's season so far. :cool:
After two or three viewings, this is really growing on me, and could be one of the better episodes of the new series.
It's a brilliant episode, the revelation about the screwdriver and Tennant's amazing performance, all culminating with the moment of him clicking his fingers and the Tardis door opening, it really thrills you in a way most episodes don't.
Moffat hasn't reached that high yet in this series. The finale is probably the place we should look for this level of awesomeness.
Comments
and now trying to escape by creating a crack in time, perhaps?
Well according to the news last night, a computer effectively transmitted a DNA code into a cell, and the cell reproduced - could this be a way to bring River back after her death - but of course that opens the door for Adric too....
And I cried too. River's words about the Doctor always knowing that she would come to this end had so much more emotion to them now that we've seen her in her past/the Doctor's future.
But they were shown to "live"....its just there bodies that don't exist, but their minds are pretty much alive forever, hence why the Doctor felt proud in saving River, Moff himself sees them as "alive".
For me its definitely the weakest of Moff's stories ever. Its too predictable, it feels like a greatest hits album when its only the fourth story from Moff, and the ending really does spoil it....if they had ended on the "everbody dies" note...it would have been a nice mirroring story to the Doctor dances.
The best thing going for it is the performances from everyone, and some of the witty dialogue....it alllows me to stay sitting and watch it on repeat viewings.
Well if it is best for the OP, then it is the best for the OP!!:p
I agree that City of Death is fantastic though...
My "bestest" is Midnight!!!:D
Really? I fell asleep during that episode but after rewatching it I'd say it was good but not bestest
Oh I have written essays on DS about why i think its the best!:D I won't repeat myself here as I haven't time....but I love everything about it....its the only story that has the same fear factor feeling that I had the first time round. And well everything about is top notch for me. Overall its a story that started out as marmite for fandom, but has been growing for many....only recently made the number one spot in the survivors game....that is one hell of an achievment for what was a splitting fandom type story!:)
It bears repeated viewing, which you can't say about all episodes and therefore may well be remembered for years to come. Personally I expect respect for Amy's Choice to grow and grow as time moves on, certainly the best of Matt's season so far. :cool:
I agree, Loved Amy's Choice, and although it didn't have a big split opinion as Midnight, it will certainly be a grower just like it.
Rose did but was a tad self involved ax
Yes, I cried at River's scary face too.
I love this story and i am still on the thought that the Scaroth will be the big bad of this seriers, cracks in time, the repeated eye image.
Where else is the Mona Lisa then? Scarborough?:p:p
Moffat hasn't reached that high yet in this series. The finale is probably the place we should look for this level of awesomeness.
How clever will you look if you end up being right about this