This series has been one BLATANT job interview for Cole for US X Factor!
foxy23
Posts: 4,392 Forum Member
✭✭✭
Does anyone feel this?
Even when Simon 'critics' Cheryl's decisions, it all seems for effect, and therefore rather hollow....
He is trying desperately to get her on the US judging panel, and this has just been one, drawn out exercise, performed in front of our eyes!
Really is manipulation of the highest order!
Danni, I believe is the most truthful judge with integrity, who fully emersed herself in her acts -- and her efforts have been greatly rebutted by the 'double-act' of Cole and Cowell..
Don't vote in the final people, they have already decided their winner!
I really like Rebbecca, but because of Cheryl, I don't want her to be victorious, purely to bring her mentor down a peg or two!
X Factor has officially jumped the shark!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cher will probably sell records, but she needs to move to America, where they will lap up that 'gangsta-gurning' style she has adopted!
Sorry, just had to get that off my chest!!!!!
Matt to win - Danni and Matt both deserve it!
Even when Simon 'critics' Cheryl's decisions, it all seems for effect, and therefore rather hollow....
He is trying desperately to get her on the US judging panel, and this has just been one, drawn out exercise, performed in front of our eyes!
Really is manipulation of the highest order!
Danni, I believe is the most truthful judge with integrity, who fully emersed herself in her acts -- and her efforts have been greatly rebutted by the 'double-act' of Cole and Cowell..
Don't vote in the final people, they have already decided their winner!
I really like Rebbecca, but because of Cheryl, I don't want her to be victorious, purely to bring her mentor down a peg or two!
X Factor has officially jumped the shark!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cher will probably sell records, but she needs to move to America, where they will lap up that 'gangsta-gurning' style she has adopted!
Sorry, just had to get that off my chest!!!!!
Matt to win - Danni and Matt both deserve it!
0
Comments
I want Matt to win purely to wipe the smirk off of the gruesome twosomes faces
Plus I hope Dannii then resigns live on air.
It's totally unfair and it's clear Cheryl's going to get her hatrick to boost her credentials for US XF. Disgrace!
Come on Dannii and Matt! Mess it up for 'em
If it is, then it's backfired spectacularly.
This is another example of DS coming up with a grand conspiracy that simply wouldn't be worth it. Plus, it's almost certainly not going to work. Matt & One Direction have been 1st/2nd favourites for weeks and weeks and weeks. Unless Rebecca really pulls something special out of the bag, she's not going to win.
I do like Rebecca, but I am willing to sacrifice her to bring her mentor down a peg or two....Rebecca will be fine anyway, she'll make it regardless of whether she wins or not!
ALSO does anybody else find it really cringey when Cheryl talks about/dances to/acts like an idiot when Cher is on or performing?
Who are the "people" that her ? If mean the minute amount of people who post on a daily basis then it's insignificant.
The whole show was just a showcase the american network and Simon Cowell has made it as controversial as possible.
It has very little to do with what other judges want but more to do with the fact that it's lauching in USA next year.
totally agree with you on some counts except one.I think the american has good sense when it comes down to music so no they won't lap it up.
People said that about Stacey Soloman last year.
Don't know if you guys get to watch a show that's been playing over here in the U.S. for two seasons now. It's only on for a few weeks in December: The Sing Off.
http://www.nbc.com/sing-off/
It's an a cappella singing competition featuring groups. The first show of "this season" was last night. Pretty good stuff. The three judges are Ben Folds, Shawn Stockman, and Nicole Scherzinger. Now, of the three, Ben Folds is a dream judge. So knowledgeable, amusing, articulate, and not mean-spirited. He would've been a great choice for American Idol but alas, Randy wouldn't leave. Shawn's not bad either, but he's just not up to Ben's standards, I think. As for Nicole, she just seemed to be there to be pretty. Didn't add much. In fact, I was reading an American TV message board where they are discussing last night's Sing Off show and this is what several posters said (none of whom are me, by the way) about Nicole:
Since Nicole is constantly mentioned over here as such a good judge, who will be so great on the US X-Factor and someone Americans will like because of her "singing career" here and winning run on DWTS, I just wanted to point out that she is not the be all and end all. Americans have already seen through her and won't see her as a credible "mentor," as they barely see her as a credible judge.
Now to be fair, I did come across a positive comment, so might as well include that:
So, in my opinion, neither Cheryl nor Nicole have any business mentoring or judging anyone on a performance/singing competition. You're just replacing one pretty, vacuous person for another. Just the nationalities are different.
And very interesting post as well about Nicole, who I happen to like way more than Mrs Cole.
GG
And throw water over Scowell afterwards would make it even better.
It'd be even more better if Fox Executives were there to witness it all.
Well if thats what Americans have to say about Nicole as a judge they are going to crucify Cheryl Cole.
When Nicole filled in on X Factor she was a breath of fresh air compared to Cole. Cheryl is such a pointless addition to the panel, Nicole seemed like an excellent judge in comparison.
Whether Cheryl has been given the X Factor US slot remains to be seen. The press seem to think she has but then they think they know everything and are often wrong so who knows. Hope Cheryl is ready to fall from a huge height if she does get it. Seems to me she won't go down well.
Well, please, if you have the opportunity, take a look at this person's youtube page. He has all of last night's (the first night's) performances from the show loaded up, with the critiques, on the right side of the page.
http://www.youtube.com/user/mrduckbear11
They are superb. Truly. Great singing. And, listen to Ben Folds wonderful commentary.
I'd recommend the groups, Groove for Thought, Committed, Street Corner Symphony, Jerry Lawson & Talk of the Town, and Eleventh Hour (which is basically the real life "Glee").
But really.They are all so good.
Ummm, if she wants that job and thats what she would be doing in that job, then not sure what else she would do other than be observed doing the same job?