One Direction - One Way or Another

[Deleted User] · 05/02/13 - 16:41

From the 30 second preview I have heard of it I think it sounds pretty good. http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=vrFywfE-Fw4

FanFromHolland · 05/02/13 - 16:46

I think it's horrible... Couldn;t they at least autotune them so they would sound like singers?

robo2 · 05/02/13 - 18:02

wow, that is utter shite

[Deleted User] · 05/02/13 - 18:39

The whole song has been leaked https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gn_3eatoe1A

Diceroll_81 · 05/02/13 - 18:53

Just read some of the comments underneath the full version video - I forgot how funny those one direction fans can be bless em.

Hav_mor91 · 05/02/13 - 19:02

The original is a classic and no matter how much they butcher it we will at least be safe in the knowledge their version will be quickly forgotten.

HMO · 05/02/13 - 19:10

It's a charity single so it should do well.

ashtray88 · 05/02/13 - 19:15

I hate to be one of those "the original is soo much better" people but it really is.

1992 · 05/02/13 - 19:19

"Meh"

cnbcwatcher · 05/02/13 - 19:53

Dreadful cover. Just as crap as any of One Dimension's other stuff.

[Deleted User] · 05/02/13 - 21:32

Its exactly as I expected it to sound, it will no doubt get to number 1 for the charity. I secretly like way too many 1D songs than is appropriate for my age!

[Deleted User] · 05/02/13 - 22:25

I find it funny that people are saying it's a shit cover version... You can hardly blame 1D for covering a song that was already dire and crap from the start with

Cloudbuster · 05/02/13 - 22:27

saintsebastien1 wrote: »

I find it funny that people are saying it's a shit cover version... You can hardly blame 1D for covering a song that was already dire and crap from the start with

Right there my friend. I have been a Blondie fan since the 70''s and this is one poor tune

boddism · 05/02/13 - 22:38

Irritatingly this is likely to keep Tyler James "Worry About You" another big release that week off the top spot, despite it being a much better song.

Its hard to diss the Comic Relief single as its for charidddddeeeee after all, but seriously there have been MUCH better Comic Relief songs.

twingle · 05/02/13 - 22:38

I am not keen on the mash up and would have been happy with just the song but I don't think this song is the final version. Sounds a bit too *dirty* in parts. Not sure that is the right word I want but can't think of another. What I do mean is I am hoping there is a final version and it sounds much cleaner

[Deleted User] · 07/02/13 - 10:15

I don't think it's too bad, obviously Blondie's is much better.

At least it's for charity.

--
thinkofmusic.com

Mr_Eye · 07/02/13 - 10:33

A painful cover of a bad song.

Mattehhhftw · 07/02/13 - 13:10

Really nothing special AT all. The original in this case is actually MUCH better.

[Deleted User] · 07/02/13 - 16:17

I think it's not too bad, it's for charity so it deserves to do well.

[Deleted User] · 07/02/13 - 16:53

Personally, I usually really like One Directions music but I'm not a fan of this. Usually their music is unashamedly cheesy and that's the reason I love it but this is just.. meh.

boddism · 07/02/13 - 20:56

It sounds like a kareoke session at a lads night out. The backing music sounds cheaply thrown together too.

There have been some great Comic Relief songs so there is no excuse.

Scratchy7929 · 07/02/13 - 23:09

Hassaan13 wrote: »

It's a charity single so it should do well.

Is that the $yco tax reduction charity

HMO · 16/02/13 - 10:35

Well, there's quite a lack of group singing which is my only issue.

A better quality version: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=scLZWKZ6bYg

[Deleted User] · 16/02/13 - 11:14

Dear me these guys can't sing if their life depended on it. Original FTW

[Deleted User] · 16/02/13 - 11:22

Scratchy7929 wrote: »

Is that the $yco tax reduction charity

Exactly, Syco is just churning publicity agin, it's so disgusting. Syco and 1 D would sell their grandma just for some publicity.

[Deleted User] · 16/02/13 - 11:56

Seems to me as if it was rushed and just picked any tune. Funny whatever they do you know it is them straight away. As my mother says "all there songs sound the bloody same". Haha.
:mad:Talk about murder a classic.

Hey there!

Quick Links

One Direction - One Way or Another

Comments