Options
Unpopular Opinions on Doctor Who
freddieaxl
Posts: 1,183 Forum Member
✭✭✭
A lot of polls say that David Tennant and Tom Baker are the best Doctors and Rose, Sarah Jane and Donna are best companions and Caves of Androzani and Blink are some of the best episodes, but do you agree? What are your unpopular opinions?
Mine -
I didn't really like Matt Smith as the Doctor. He was a good actor, but it wasn't the kind of style I like for a Doctor. And I didn't like Rory or Amy either, they just felt really weak to me. Again, good actors, but not my cup of tea.
Sylvester McCoy is one of my favourite Doctors, and The Happiness Patrol is one of my favourite ever Doctor Who stories. I think it's brilliant. My four favourite Doctors are Tom Baker, David Tennant, Peter Davison and Sylvester McCoy. I also love Time Flight and Four to Doomsday, which aren't that popular, and I think Fear Her and The Idiot's Lantern are great.
I thought Martha was one of the best companions ever, she was great, which is sort of unpopular to some. Tegan, Ace, Romana II, Martha, Rose and Donna are my favourites which isn't really unpopular, but I think Martha is way underrated.
So what are yours?
My Doctor Rankings
1. David Tennant
2. Peter Davison
3. Tom Baker
4. Sylvester McCoy
5. Patrick Troughton
6. Jon Pertwee
7. Christopher Eccleston
8. Matt Smith
9. Colin Baker
10. William Hartnell
11. Paul McGann (never seen the TV Movie)
Top 5 Companions
1. Donna
2. Ace
3. Martha
4. Tegan
5. Romana II
Mine -
I didn't really like Matt Smith as the Doctor. He was a good actor, but it wasn't the kind of style I like for a Doctor. And I didn't like Rory or Amy either, they just felt really weak to me. Again, good actors, but not my cup of tea.
Sylvester McCoy is one of my favourite Doctors, and The Happiness Patrol is one of my favourite ever Doctor Who stories. I think it's brilliant. My four favourite Doctors are Tom Baker, David Tennant, Peter Davison and Sylvester McCoy. I also love Time Flight and Four to Doomsday, which aren't that popular, and I think Fear Her and The Idiot's Lantern are great.
I thought Martha was one of the best companions ever, she was great, which is sort of unpopular to some. Tegan, Ace, Romana II, Martha, Rose and Donna are my favourites which isn't really unpopular, but I think Martha is way underrated.
So what are yours?
My Doctor Rankings
1. David Tennant
2. Peter Davison
3. Tom Baker
4. Sylvester McCoy
5. Patrick Troughton
6. Jon Pertwee
7. Christopher Eccleston
8. Matt Smith
9. Colin Baker
10. William Hartnell
11. Paul McGann (never seen the TV Movie)
Top 5 Companions
1. Donna
2. Ace
3. Martha
4. Tegan
5. Romana II
0
Comments
The SJA was a very poor show that not once excelled beyond its CBBC status. The BBC has produced through the decades some truly classic children's dramas that will endure. SJA isn't one of them. Terrible acting. Cheap. File next to that Wizards and Aliens thing.
The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances is a great story. But not even remotely scary.
John Simm is by far the best Master. An actor with skill and range and heart as opposed to the previous incumbents who belonged in a Punch and Judy Show.
Love and Monsters is one of the best episodes of all time.
Kandyman is scarier than the Daleks.
The alleged 'comedy' bits between Donna and the Doctor were woeful and seemed forced. Donna as a character always did better with the more serious and dramatic moments which were far greater than all the 'Watch it spaceman' cockney nonsense.
Turn Left is not a terrible episode as such but it is one of the most overrated in the shows history and is RTD showing his worst excesses as opposed to the strengths of Midnight. A fairly tiresome retread of the 'What if?' scenario which is well played out in sci-fi it features a terrible and distracting performance from Piper, an annoyingly melodramatic turn from Tate and some of the worst supporting performances the show has ever had. Witness the token superstitious peasant maid of indistinct ethnic origin who crosses herself, makes crazy eyes and would seem insultingly out of place in a Roger Corman 70s B-movie. Not to mention the feeble attempt to give this clear filler story some gravitas by throwing in the ludicrous and almost offensive notion that within a few short months Britain will have descended so far into the abyss that we begin on a route to becoming another Nazi Germany. Utter Tosh. Yes the scene with Wilf and the salute is nicely acted and poignant...until you engage your brain. How this episode makes it into the top 150 let alone top 20 is baffling. And I didn't even mention the beetle backpack once! Says it all.
River Song and the Doctor are not really married.
'Spoilers' is a really annoying catchphrase.
Merry Christmas and God Bless us everyone
I didn't mean this as a negative thread, I meant it to be what you like that other people don't. Like I said, I love Time Flight and Four to Doomsday but other people dont. Unpopular positive opinions too
Firstly i must say I'm really disappointed that saladfingers is keeping his opinions so close to his chest
Martha - she was sooooooooooooo boring. Wake me up please. Her only good episode was when the doc was human, man I'm terrible at episode names, family of blood?
I love evil characters, i like the spice early Colin Baker bright to the role.
I do like Donna, there were bad parts to her role, but she was way more convincing at showing depth of character "being around you I don't know what's right or wrong", I like the way she wasn't a timid spineless "yes" character, if the doctor did something wrong she told him so quite clearly. Her cockney character was funny at times, "you want to mate with me?", "no I just want a mate".
But picking the best doctor or best companion, eh, it's just not that simple. I love Led Zep, Jimi Hendrix and Black Sabbath. I also love Gary Numan and early non-pop Human League. I also love Duran Duran and UB40 and Nick Drake. They're all different but not better than each other. It's a mood thing, and I think the Doctors are like that.
The only absolutes are that certain characters are loathsome. I hated the guy who appeared for two episodes (Rose picked up after Dalek). Donna' s mom irritated me as did the slitheen. Captain Jack irritates me (but redeemed himself temporarily) in the Bad Wolf episode when he actually died, and I think the Face of Boe was great. Sil irritated me.
Ok rant over.
Saladfingers...you diss *anything* about Donna, we're going to have to take things outside. >:( ;-)
As regards this forum, the only thing that springs to mind is...I quite like 'The Doctor, the Widow and The Wardrobe'.
I think Warriors of the Deep is a good episode as well as The Power of Kroll, and Timelash is so bad it's actually quite enjoyable.
I also found Vengeance on Varos, which is often hailed as one of Colin Baker's best stories, incredibly dull.
I agree with this. Apart from the very odd exception, I couldn't watch the Sarah-Jane Adventures without cringing at the poor acting and childishness of it all. It was like watching Tracy Beaker most of the time.
Another think I can never do is rank all the Doctors in order of my favourite. There are some Doctors I like more than other, but I don't think I could ever rank them all in a list.
- There is no Classic Series and New Who. There is only Doctor Who. It's certain fans who seem to be creating a divide amongst the show, not the show itself.
- Donna is a brilliant companion but a bit overrrated in parts. I still think she was exactly what the Tenth Doctor needed though in a friend.
- Colin Baker and Sylvester McCoy's eras are nowhere near as bad as some people make out and McGann's movie is better than a lot of stories.
- Ian Levine is the worst ambassador for this show and considering how little he is of actual influence, it says a lot. The hero worshipping he gets from some fans because he saved a few episodes is utterly mind boggling.
- The 50th anniversary was in no way or shape ruined at all. It was a massive success, just only the serious Moffat haters who refuse to accept that.
- I do think at some point, the revived series probably should kill off at least one companion - preferably by the Master, just to remind viewers that he actually is dangerous at times.
- The 45 minute episode/occassional two parter/hour long special is a better format than the one from the Classic Series. Sorry, but it is.
- The Sarah Jane Adventures was a better spin-off than Torchwood and I did mostly like both of them.
- The companion should always have a prominent role and not just be there for exposition sake.
I also really enjoyed "Love and Monsters". Though, I do admit I have never seen a story go downhill as fast as that once the monster was revealed. Still, second best in a series that was went from awful to bland.
Like a previous poster said I don't really like turn left that much. Just an average episode if you ask me. Maybe even under par actually. Also didn't quite fancy midnight as much as the hype it gets. It's a decent episode, yeah, but I wouldn't put it 'up there'.
I also absolutely love the wedding of river song, and lots of people seen to hate that.
I thought the gangers/rebel flesh episodes were also excellent, and lots of people hate too (I find that one strange because, to me, that is total classic who at it's best in its style).
Also totally hated the power of three. Started off really good, but the last third just went so down hill, it came out the other side of the planet. Seems to get a bit of praise that one. I think if the last third was'accidentally' wiped from my brain I would have lived it. Insert instead, a scene where they go down the pub because the cubes just disappeared and they couldn't explain it. And then they go odd in the Tardis just like in the last minute. THEN, add that animated thingy that was Brian meeting Rory and Amy's adopted son, but for real. Now that could well have been a 10/10 episode. Instead it was about 2/10
-Jack is my least favorite companion and I think he ruined every episode he appeared in. I also don't like Amy.
-Rings of Akhaten, Planet of the Dead and Shakespeare Code are fantastic episodes IMO. I also liked Smith and Jones, 42, Gridlock, Beast Below, The Course of the Black Spot, Partners in Crime and Lodger.
-Fear Her, The Doctor, The Window and the Wardrobe and Long Game are average episodes IMO.
-I liked all episodes in 7B (except Cold War).
-I think all RTD finals are terrible and I also don't like The Girl Who Waited and Christmas Carol.
-I think Doctor Who isn't bizarre/fairytalish/weird enough. I'd like to see some Alice-style episode.
-Neil Cross is my favorite writer (along with Steven Moffat).
-I don't want a new companion for season 8, Clara is great and enough.
-Daleks are overused but sonic screwdriver isn't.
-Donna is good, but overrated companion.
- I ranked him 9th, but I still think Colin Baker is underrated. I think all the Doctors are top-tier and that's just the order that I like them in.
- I LOVED Kinda from the Davison era.
- I prefer episodes either standalone or two-parter with no huge story arc to climactic story-arc series finales. I'd rather see Gridlock than The Pandorica Opens. But I did love Turn Left, pretty much every second of it. One of my favourites.
- I wish Weeping Angels only appeared in Blink. I thought they were amazing and scary there, and sort of wish they'd left it because it's a perfect ep imo.
- I've never really found 'The Master' that interesting, but I love "The End of Time"
Rose: good actress, stupid character; she was always putting her personal needs ahead of the universe, like in 'Father's day'
Amy: good character, bad actress
Most boring episode of all time: Love and monsters
Best new aliens of the modern era: Judoons and the Oods
Best doctors: Tom Baker and Matt Smith. David Tennant as a lot of sympathy because the fans know he's a genuine fan from childhood and he got the bests stories, but his acting was irregular. One minute he plays the Doctor as an alien (like Matt Smith), the next like a very intelligent human being. A very intelligent human is not a Timelord.
Best special guests: only the voices and small parts but, Mitchell and Webb in 'Dinosaurs on a spaceship'
But now it's not secret
Yeah, but how do you really feel?
Ianto Jones wasn't that great a character.
Partners in Crime is a dreadful episode and the "comedy" between the Doctor and Donna is horribly forced and unfunny.
Christopher Eccelston doesn't deserve to be skinned alive by the fans.
"A Christmas Carol," is the best Who xmas special by a country mile.
The Ninth Doctor ahould've been alongside the Tenth and Eleventh in The Day of the Doctor.
Series 6 and 7 should not have been split in half.
Ben Daniels should've been cast instead of Peter Capaldi.
Eccleston was brilliant as the Doctor and has subsequently conducted himself professionally and with good judgment.
McCoy's first year has several magical moments if you look closely.
Rose was the best of Tennant's companions.
The sets, lighting and effects make Kinda an even better story by creating a slightly nauseating claustrophobia.
I don't think that's an unpopular opinion! ;-)