Ask yourself "Just who is my Doctor"?
![[Deleted User]](https://w1.vanillicon.com/v2/1b3425e3666d76f23e94121e11f8637c.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 209 Forum Member
✭
As it says on the tin.. for me its the final time I will even consider the above........ I hope 
Anyway, last night I watched the Impossible planet. At the time this episode kicked ass in terms of depth and fear and creativity. Tennants acting was very good, BUT.....
Everytime I look at tennant next to Smith, I cant help but think Smith is the better actor of the two.
Examples are the emotional scenes, Tennant put so much into the Holding back tears look and dragged out much of the emotion. Smith on the other hand seems so much more accomplished at brushing aside the emotion and tuning up in a situation that needs it ala TPO when being dragged inside.......
So for me in summary Ive come to terms with Smith FInally, He is now MY DOCTOR!!! :cool:
Anyway, last night I watched the Impossible planet. At the time this episode kicked ass in terms of depth and fear and creativity. Tennants acting was very good, BUT.....
Everytime I look at tennant next to Smith, I cant help but think Smith is the better actor of the two.
Examples are the emotional scenes, Tennant put so much into the Holding back tears look and dragged out much of the emotion. Smith on the other hand seems so much more accomplished at brushing aside the emotion and tuning up in a situation that needs it ala TPO when being dragged inside.......
So for me in summary Ive come to terms with Smith FInally, He is now MY DOCTOR!!!
:cool: 0
Comments
Precisely!!! Immensely talented Actor. He's the same age as me... Im so jealous! Im an It project manager, he is THE DOCTOR!!!! :eek:
Tom Baker was the Doctor I grew up on (delayed runs on Gibraltar TV in the early 80s) and I think to me he will always be the Doctor. Jon Pertwee was also a good doc I think.
I however dislike greatly Colin Baker and Troughton's doctors.
Tom Baker is still my favourite Doctor, however.
Smith is a phenomenal actor, but hasn't been there long enough yet. For me, he's behind the Fourth, Tenth and Third, but by the time he's done, he'll probably be higher.
It's gotta be Ten for me.
I watched at 2005 onwards but my Doctor Who obsession began in Series 3. Matt Smith is a fine Doctor in his own right but David Tennant is possibly the greatest Doctor that will ever be,. In my opinion of course.
Aside from that, my favourite Doctors are Baker#1, McCoy and that there new Smith boy - but I lay much of the credit for that on the scriptwriters of their times as much as the performances.
Love 'em all really. Except 10. Smug Mockney Git, sobbing and weeping all over the place.
I prefer Matt as he's the most quirky/alien type Doctor. Chris and David were good too - but very human.
My favourite of the 'oldies' though - Pat Troughton!
or
David Tennant.:)
That reminds me, going to watch Human Nature and The Family of Blood later
I'm also one of the few Doctor Who fans who finds Tom Baker hugely overrated and annoying. His first two seasons were very good indeed, but when he had weaker producers his self-indulgence became unbearable for me. Or maybe I was growing out of Who at that time when I was in my teens. That said, time hasn't altered my view and of the two Bakers, I much prefer Colin. There, I've said it.
Currently, Matt Smith is playing The Doctor superbly well, and is a joy to watch.
Which was my personal favourite incarnation? David Tennant.
i like eccleston as much as i like pertwee
I felt sorry for McCoy - the BBC budget didn't help!:rolleyes: