Most definitely, and especially the highlight line! This is exactly what I want to see too. I couldn't get on with Amy or Clara but I did love Rose and Donna. The latter two were personable and accessible and I liked the working class element. I found Clara and Amy a bit too dominant and unfazed by it all. The companion acts as the eyes of the viewer but Clara especially was written so nonchalant about the whole thing. I enjoyed the shock, amazement, fear, excitement ect...portrayed by Rose and Donna, but Clara and Amy became the 'boss' of the Doctor and I hated that. Plus their attitudes/the way they were written annoyed me in general. Admittedly Amy was toned down nearer her exit and I much preferred her then. I hope Moffat gets it right this time.
Clara and Amy both showed shock and amazement at the start, but it would be ridiculous if after several years of travelling with him (and remember that the characters have been with the Doctor for a lot longer than their TV time) they were the same.
I've enjoyed all the Companions, Clara is my favourite though as I find her more relatable to ME, i.e. her outlook on life is most similar to mine. I'm not saying she's better, as it's entirely down to opinions and totally subjective.
I'm sure the next one will be completely different, and the opposite to Clara. After an incredibly intense Doctor/Companion partnership, I'm sure the next one will be much looser, and the next Companion more Rose/Donna ish
I think Rose's early adventures brilliantly capture the wonder of travelling with the Doctor for an ordinary human.
I loved that the overwhelming experience of meeting all the alien races in "The End of the World" sent her rushing to an empty room, simply to get her breath back.
And then that gorgeous scene at the beginning of "The Unquiet Dead" when she steps slowly from the TARDIS onto a layer of snow that fell more than a century before she was even born.
It was the same with Martha and Donna. The sheer wonder and excitement, and the feeling they all felt it was a privilege to be have been given the opportunity to travel.
For me, with both Amy and Clara (and I accept some may feel this is unfair) there was more of a sense of entitlement. And I didn't feel the sense of wonder quite so much.
Perhaps its felt it would get a bit boring if every companion went through an extended "ooh wow" phase at the beginning. But it does make them seem more real and grounded, and I think for a companion that's essential.
For me, with both Amy and Clara (and I accept some may feel this is unfair) there was more of a sense of entitlement. And I didn't feel the sense of wonder quite so much.
Perhaps its felt it would get a bit boring if every companion went through an extended "ooh wow" phase at the beginning. But it does make them seem more real and grounded, and I think for a companion that's essential.
On the other hand, Amy's reaction was grounded in a different way - she started out cynical and disbelieving, both of the Doctor's offer and why he should choose her. And she was probably right to be, in the end. I think it's okay for 'being overwhelmed' to not be in a companion's vocabulary, it would be boring if everyone reacted the same way.
Clara and Amy both showed shock and amazement at the start, but it would be ridiculous if after several years of travelling with him (and remember that the characters have been with the Doctor for a lot longer than their TV time) they were the same.
Fair enough, that is a good point. Perhaps it is what others have raised and it was their sense of entitlement, particularly Clara.
I think Rose's early adventures brilliantly capture the wonder of travelling with the Doctor for an ordinary human.
I loved that the overwhelming experience of meeting all the alien races in "The End of the World" sent her rushing to an empty room, simply to get her breath back.
And then that gorgeous scene at the beginning of "The Unquiet Dead" when she steps slowly from the TARDIS onto a layer of snow that fell more than a century before she was even born.
It was the same with Martha and Donna. The sheer wonder and excitement, and the feeling they all felt it was a privilege to be have been given the opportunity to travel.
For me, with both Amy and Clara (and I accept some may feel this is unfair) there was more of a sense of entitlement. And I didn't feel the sense of wonder quite so much.
Perhaps its felt it would get a bit boring if every companion went through an extended "ooh wow" phase at the beginning. But it does make them seem more real and grounded, and I think for a companion that's essential.
A young Gallifreyan that the Doctor takes under his wing to stop him/her being brought up in the stuffy traditions of Time Lord society and to try to bring a bit of positivity back to Gallifrey, in the hopes that they may be re-accepted by the universe.
Y'know I quite like the sound of that idea!! Like an apprentice of sorts....
I thought victorian Clara was going to be a rather fabulous companion... and they killed her off immediately for yet another one from London in the early 21st Century.
Well worth considering a companion from a different time and place.
Fair enough, that is a good point. Perhaps it is what others have raised and it was their sense of entitlement, particularly Clara.
Clara has stayed for much longer than any of the RTD companions. Imagine Rose or Donna after several years with the Doctor. The Rose we saw by the end of S2 had already changed, Mickey had changed even more!
Clara has stayed for much longer than any of the RTD companions. Imagine Rose or Donna after several years with the Doctor. The Rose we saw by the end of S2 had already changed, Mickey had changed even more!
I don't know what it was but I just found Clara and her attitude throughout irritating, not just towards the end.
Ideally I would vote for Helena Bonham Carter as the next companion. Would never happen but it would be AMAzing.:D
Clara has stayed for much longer than any of the RTD companions. Imagine Rose or Donna after several years with the Doctor. The Rose we saw by the end of S2 had already changed, Mickey had changed even more!
Clara should've left at the end of Series 8 to be honest.
Clara should've left at the end of Series 8 to be honest.
I'm very glad she stayed!
Either way, RTD to me changed Companions too regularly, so (with Chris leaving) we ended up with 4 different Doctor/Companion combinations for his 4 series, and then the Doctor alone for his Specials. There's plenty you can do with the same pairing once you've had a series to work out the chemistry.
Kinda hoping they'll break out the big guns and get a well known established actor in the role to get audiences really excited. I know it isn't likely but Gillian Anderson is my dream at the moment, I can see the two together in my head and it's magical but I fear people would get mardy about the show having an ageing cast.
Another famous would be Gemma Arterton because she seems genuinely lovely, and I think she's a decent actor.
Kinda hoping they'll break out the big guns and get a well known established actor in the role to get audiences really excited. I know it isn't likely but Gillian Anderson is my dream at the moment, I can see the two together in my head and it's magical but I fear people would get mardy about the show having an ageing cast.
Another famous would be Gemma Arterton because she seems genuinely lovely, and I think she's a decent actor.
I'd be happy if Rose Leslie did get it though.
I'd love it if they could get Gemma Arterton, but the chances of that happening are a big fat zero. Most likely it'll be another ex-soap actress, since the more established actresses would have to commit to 9 months filming in Cardiff, possibly more if they stay as long as Karen or Jenna.
Well Ashildr is still possible, although I doubt that would go down well here.
Rigsy is another possibility and I suppose would change the dynamic in the Tardis (as has been mentioned I believe) compared with the previous female companions. I haven't forgotten Rory but obviously Amy was the main companion at that time.
How about Reece Shersamith's character from Sleep No More given that episodes universal love?
Santa would certainly be a bold move. That is my preferred choice. :D
Faye Marsay...thats the one. Full of life and challenge. Great dynamic of her own too.
Thanks for the link. She would be so much more than a sidekick. She is a charismatic actress in her own right, and one to watch.
With her in place Moffat could do amazing things with scripts, really change the formula with two imposing figures. She's got real soul in her acting.
Comments
Clara and Amy both showed shock and amazement at the start, but it would be ridiculous if after several years of travelling with him (and remember that the characters have been with the Doctor for a lot longer than their TV time) they were the same.
I've enjoyed all the Companions, Clara is my favourite though as I find her more relatable to ME, i.e. her outlook on life is most similar to mine. I'm not saying she's better, as it's entirely down to opinions and totally subjective.
I'm sure the next one will be completely different, and the opposite to Clara. After an incredibly intense Doctor/Companion partnership, I'm sure the next one will be much looser, and the next Companion more Rose/Donna ish
I loved that the overwhelming experience of meeting all the alien races in "The End of the World" sent her rushing to an empty room, simply to get her breath back.
And then that gorgeous scene at the beginning of "The Unquiet Dead" when she steps slowly from the TARDIS onto a layer of snow that fell more than a century before she was even born.
It was the same with Martha and Donna. The sheer wonder and excitement, and the feeling they all felt it was a privilege to be have been given the opportunity to travel.
For me, with both Amy and Clara (and I accept some may feel this is unfair) there was more of a sense of entitlement. And I didn't feel the sense of wonder quite so much.
Perhaps its felt it would get a bit boring if every companion went through an extended "ooh wow" phase at the beginning. But it does make them seem more real and grounded, and I think for a companion that's essential.
On the other hand, Amy's reaction was grounded in a different way - she started out cynical and disbelieving, both of the Doctor's offer and why he should choose her. And she was probably right to be, in the end. I think it's okay for 'being overwhelmed' to not be in a companion's vocabulary, it would be boring if everyone reacted the same way.
Fair enough, that is a good point. Perhaps it is what others have raised and it was their sense of entitlement, particularly Clara.
Basically articulated my thoughts down to a tee.
Y'know I quite like the sound of that idea!! Like an apprentice of sorts....
Well worth considering a companion from a different time and place.
Clara has stayed for much longer than any of the RTD companions. Imagine Rose or Donna after several years with the Doctor. The Rose we saw by the end of S2 had already changed, Mickey had changed even more!
I don't know what it was but I just found Clara and her attitude throughout irritating, not just towards the end.
Ideally I would vote for Helena Bonham Carter as the next companion. Would never happen but it would be AMAzing.:D
Clara should've left at the end of Series 8 to be honest.
She'd make an excellent female Doctor (or future Missy for that matter).
I'm very glad she stayed!
Either way, RTD to me changed Companions too regularly, so (with Chris leaving) we ended up with 4 different Doctor/Companion combinations for his 4 series, and then the Doctor alone for his Specials. There's plenty you can do with the same pairing once you've had a series to work out the chemistry.
Well he knows nothing.
I'll get my coat
No, but, yeah, but, not, yeah, no, but, yeah, no, but...
Another famous would be Gemma Arterton because she seems genuinely lovely, and I think she's a decent actor.
I'd be happy if Rose Leslie did get it though.
I'd love it if they could get Gemma Arterton, but the chances of that happening are a big fat zero. Most likely it'll be another ex-soap actress, since the more established actresses would have to commit to 9 months filming in Cardiff, possibly more if they stay as long as Karen or Jenna.
Gwyneth Keyworth
Rosamund Hanson
Naomi Battrick
Oh, not her!
Glad she's not in it now.
Would want River Song to be a long-term companion, but as Alex has said recently, it's not going to happen any time soon.
Faye Marsay...thats the one. Full of life and challenge. Great dynamic of her own too.
Thanks for the link. She would be so much more than a sidekick. She is a charismatic actress in her own right, and one to watch.
With her in place Moffat could do amazing things with scripts, really change the formula with two imposing figures. She's got real soul in her acting.
Shona could be if they want to go with a working class companion and the character was well received in Last Christmas.
Or a new Rani