Options
Evictions that would've gone differently if Channel 5 was Vote To Evict...
Fiercefanatic
Posts: 3,580 Forum Member
✭✭✭
If Channel 5 had never done vote to save... which evictions would've gone differently to how they actually turned out?
Here's a few I think would've gone differently if it was vote to evict:
Normal BB:
Aaron v Aden v Anton v Jay v Faye (Anton would've gone instead of Aden) - BB12
Conor v Lydia v Victoria (Lydia would've gone instead of Victoria) - BB13
Conor v Shievonne (Conor would've gone instead of Shievonne) - BB13
Luke A v Lauren (Luke A would've gone instead of Lauren) - BB13
Ashleigh v Becky v Deana v Luke A (Ashleigh would've gone instead of Becky) - BB13
Celeb BB:
Darryn v Pamela (Darryn would've gone instead of Pamela) - CBB8
Natasha v Nicola (Nicola would've gone instead of Natasha) - CBB9
Frankie v Paula v Speidi (Speidi would've gone instead of Paula) - CBB11
Here's a few I think would've gone differently if it was vote to evict:
Normal BB:
Aaron v Aden v Anton v Jay v Faye (Anton would've gone instead of Aden) - BB12
Conor v Lydia v Victoria (Lydia would've gone instead of Victoria) - BB13
Conor v Shievonne (Conor would've gone instead of Shievonne) - BB13
Luke A v Lauren (Luke A would've gone instead of Lauren) - BB13
Ashleigh v Becky v Deana v Luke A (Ashleigh would've gone instead of Becky) - BB13
Celeb BB:
Darryn v Pamela (Darryn would've gone instead of Pamela) - CBB8
Natasha v Nicola (Nicola would've gone instead of Natasha) - CBB9
Frankie v Paula v Speidi (Speidi would've gone instead of Paula) - CBB11
0
Comments
It was a double so Ashleigh and Deana would of gone!
I think Becky would still have gone, only by a bigger percentage.
i watched the eviction of sezer last night thats one vote that wouldnt have gone differently had it been vote to save then
I think Luke A would of gone. I wanted Lauren to stay, but not because i wanted her to win. I only vote to save people if i want them to win. If it was vote to evict, i disliked Luke A enough to evict him!
Victoria was being portrayed as a bitchy, pompous drama queen- and so would still have got the vote to eliminate.
Are you sure your votes would have been enough to swing it though? I really think Luke was far enough ahead not to have to worry about them. And presumably if there are people - I doubt whether there are many - who would throw themselves into voting if it was a vote to evict but not a vote to save, even when two housemates are head to head - it would work equally for every housemate, so yours would be cancelled out by an equally 'only to evict' voter.
I can't actually understand your point of view, I must understand. I mean I understand VERY well that someone who dislikes Luke would like to imagine that it was only lucky fortune that saved him, and not greater popularity (the second of which it clearly was), but if you disliked him enough to vote to evict him, why didn't you dislike him enough to cast a vote that would have evicted him?
More people disliked Luke A than Lauren at the time. If it was vote to evict, more people would of picked up the phone to get Luke out, rather than to keep Lauren in!
It was very close though they said! And if it was that close in a vote to save, i'm almost 100% sure Lauren would of stayed in a vote to evict!
Vote to evict allows people to get rid of the people they dislike. The people who didn't like either of them enough to save them, but disliked one of them more would of voted in a vote to evict i think.
The reason i didn't save Lauren, is because i didn't particularly like her either. So why would i pick up a phone to save someone who i didn't like, just to get someone else out i didn't like? I wasnt bothered about who went, if it was a vote to evict i would of evicted Luke A. And if i had liked Lauren enough to save her, i would of saved her.
It doesn't actually make your argument more convincing if you keep saying it over and over again. Luke beat Lauren by 8%. So it was not a walkover but not a tiny margin either - loads of evictions have been much closer. I'm sure you have your own reason for wanting Luke out but wanting Lauren out as well so you would vote Luke out but not Lauren in, but it just sounds peculiar to me. And there is no reason to believe that views like this would favour Luke more than Lauren even if other people share them. I think deep down you just can't admit to yourself that Luke was more popular than Lauren: a TINY poll on here had him at 34 votes for least favourite compared with her 26 votes, but compared with the number of voters that is microscopic.
In the end the voting figures are the only thing that mattered. Luke got more votes than Lauren, and would have stayed whether it had been a vote to save or a vote to evict.
I would say it had more to do with sympathy rather than popularity. People seemed to feel sorry for him. That is why he won.
Luke 53% Lauren 46%
Show me the evidence for that! I liked him and that is why I voted for him. No sympathy at all.
I think if you are going to describe what makes people vote, you will have to stick to your own reasons, or link to other peoples' own accounts of their reasons. It would be rude and silly in the extreme to pretend to know other peoples' reasons without this evidence.
Saw different points and answered them.
I don't see why you're getting so offended by this? And making such an argument out of it?
The people who don't like either, but prefer one to the other wont pick up the phone to save either, but would pick up the phone to evict. At that time, Luke A was more disliked than Lauren. Nobody is saying she 100% would of gone. But if it was THAT close with a vote to save, it wouldn't of took much votes to change that with the low number of votes cast these days. My opinion is Luke A would of gone with a 65%+ share of the vote to evict.
Read the appreciation thread for a start. It should be renamed the Luke A sympathy thread.
You only speak for yourself. I get it. If it had been vote to evict, Luke would have had your votes. Unless you would have voted 8000 times, Lauren would still have gone.
Really, why are you doing this? What kind of person lives in the appreciation thread of a housemate they obsessively, compulsively dislike? Dont' you have a shed to tidy or something?
This is a classic example from one of his most loyal supporters. This is you trying to create the picture of poor victimised Luke A.
Never have I said I don't like him. I said he was a boring housemate. :rolleyes:
How is it based on nothing? At the time, Luke A was clearly more disliked than Lauren. Just as people like how Deana was more disliked than anyone in the final. She still came 3rd, but if the winner was the person with the least votes to evict, Sara would of won! Deana first out, then Luke A, then Luke S etc! It's not based on nothing, its based on the facts! You're getting so defensive because Luke A was your favourite. Deana was my favourite but i still said that she would of gone in a vote to evict. My god, get over it, your favourite would most likely of gone in a vote to evict.
Vote to Save gives of the impression that you want to SAVE someone from eviction. So who would you vote if you dislike both the people up for eviction? You still wouldn't want to save someone from eviction no if you didn't like either.
Vote to evict gives of the impression you want to get someone out. Lauren and Luke A, didn't like either particularly, preferred Lauren. But i didn't feel strongly enough to SAVE her from an eviction. If it was vote to evict, it makes it so much easier, don't like either, want Luke A out, feel strong enough to EVICT him. Simple. You can keep saying i'm wrong and its based on nothing, but it's not. Which on why on so many polls etc that people want the vote to evict back. If it was the same, nobody would have a problem with it.
In that case I'm really glad for vote to save. lol The thought of Deana getting evicted and Scott staying in for the final I find quite depressing.
I think that week was probably Becky's worst week of all, she couldn't stop going on about the BMI comment. She seemed to be getting on alot of the viewers nerves.
Admittedly though I can barely remember what Ashleigh did that week so I don't know if she did anything to motivate viewers to get rid of her. Though being her usual self would obviously have attracted alot of votes anyway.
Adam vs Ashleigh vs Caroline vs Conor vs Deana vs Luke A vs Luke S vs Sara
If it had been vote to evict I'm almost certain Conor would have gone instead of Caroline
if that was true more people would have saved lauren votewise