For those who are saying Melanie will do well etc! Where exactly does she fit into the music industry. Where is her audience that will buy her album,. single and go to her concerts! I for one have no idea.
You won't be proven wrong. She'll get about 1.2% of the vote in the first love show and be bottom - eliminated by public vote. I like her as a person, but she's the ultimate 'first-out' candidate.
I'm ripping up my betting slip now, I was pretty confident she'd be in with an above average chance of winning. But, your insightfulness has convinced me she actually has no talent and is indeed an also ran. :rolleyes:
I'm ripping up my betting slip now, I was pretty confident she'd be in with an above average chance of winning. But, your insightfulness has convinced me she actually has no talent and is indeed an also ran. :rolleyes:
and certain to be first booted out of the lives!! :eek:
I'm ripping up my betting slip now, I was pretty confident she'd be in with an above average chance of winning. But, your insightfulness has convinced me she actually has no talent and is indeed an also ran. :rolleyes:
Please, don't get me wrong! I thikn Melanie is very talented, and is not an also-ran by any stretch of the imagination. I think she's a good singer and kudos to her for trying and trying again. I'm just saying that she will be first out because she won't connect with the very fickle X Factor TV audience!
Please, don't get me wrong! I thikn Melanie is very talented, and is not an also-ran by any stretch of the imagination. I think she's a good singer and kudos to her for trying and trying again. I'm just saying that she will be first out because she won't connect with the very fickle X Factor TV audience!
I actually understand what you are saying here but I don't think she'll be weak enough to go on the very 1st week - there will be others that will probably go before her (if she makes it to the live shows which I'm pretty certain she will). Audiences are very fickle but these finalists do have a fanbase and tbh Melanie does have a very good number of fans compared to others this year
I actually understand what you are saying here but I don't think she'll be weak enough to go on the very 1st week - there will be others that will probably go before her (if she makes it to the live shows which I'm pretty certain she will). Audiences are very fickle but these finalists do have a fanbase and tbh Melanie does have a very good number of fans compared to others this year
exactly!! that's why first to be eliminated is ermm highly improbable
Please, don't get me wrong! I thikn Melanie is very talented, and is not an also-ran by any stretch of the imagination. I think she's a good singer and kudos to her for trying and trying again. I'm just saying that she will be first out because she won't connect with the very fickle X Factor TV audience!
Hypothetically: I think if you posted this after the first live show, because her performance was not good I think I would understand your reasoning. Presuming she makes the lives, your assessment does not take into account boot camp, judges houses or show one performances. You may be entirely right, but you may be entirely wrong too, time will tell.
Hypothetically: I think if you posted this after the first live show, because her performance was not good I think I would understand your reasoning. Presuming she makes the lives, your assessment does not take into account boot camp, judges houses or show one performances. You may be entirely right, but you may be entirely wrong too, time will tell.
Her whole fanbase must be on DS. Wont make any difference to her going home though.
We don't even know if she is through yet, but she will have lots of Irish fans who can vote through the TV3 website. The girl group is at most risk of going first.
Looks like my prediction is all the more likely after bootcamp. The producers have misjudged this one - pimped her, but realised now the other girls are far superior in talent, personality and interest.
Live show number one: Melanie is up first and gets the "it was fine" treatment.
Comments
have you asked this of other acts?
I'm ripping up my betting slip now, I was pretty confident she'd be in with an above average chance of winning. But, your insightfulness has convinced me she actually has no talent and is indeed an also ran. :rolleyes:
and certain to be first booted out of the lives!! :eek:
long live le phantom crystal ball!!
Please, don't get me wrong! I thikn Melanie is very talented, and is not an also-ran by any stretch of the imagination. I think she's a good singer and kudos to her for trying and trying again. I'm just saying that she will be first out because she won't connect with the very fickle X Factor TV audience!
I actually understand what you are saying here but I don't think she'll be weak enough to go on the very 1st week - there will be others that will probably go before her (if she makes it to the live shows which I'm pretty certain she will). Audiences are very fickle but these finalists do have a fanbase and tbh Melanie does have a very good number of fans compared to others this year
exactly!! that's why first to be eliminated is ermm highly improbable
Hypothetically: I think if you posted this after the first live show, because her performance was not good I think I would understand your reasoning. Presuming she makes the lives, your assessment does not take into account boot camp, judges houses or show one performances. You may be entirely right, but you may be entirely wrong too, time will tell.
We don't even know if she is through yet, but she will have lots of Irish fans who can vote through the TV3 website. The girl group is at most risk of going first.
Evidently woke up on the wrong side of Andrea Begley's bed this morning.
My pleasure :cool:
Live show number one: Melanie is up first and gets the "it was fine" treatment.