Options
Who do you think killed Lucy Beale and who do you think sent the 'Rot In Hell' note?
lucasade16
Posts: 397 Forum Member
✭
My personal 'EIGHT' suspects for killing Lucy are:
Whitney Dean - I think Whitney is being suprisingly heartless and emotionless over it all and it is sending alarm bells to me.
Johnny Carter - Being bestfriends with Whitney and his Brother being Lee, maybe he thought enough was enough with the blonde, would of given him a great enterance into the show. But he also seems quite heartless about it all.
Ben Mitchell - He killed before, he is returning. Something just tells me he has something to do with it. To get back at Ian?
Nick Cotton - Well I personally don't think he is dead in any way at all, but I do think that Charlie is still in contact with him, after Charlies and Ians heated clash over Nick's 'supposed to be death' could it have been Evil Nicks revenge in killing Lucy for Ians constant diss of Nick?
Billy Mitchell - Always the runt of the litter of the Mitchell clan, but Lucy shunted Billy of being apart of LB lettings before any major business was put together, could he try and prove himself a Mitchell, not seen much of a emotional wimpy Billy in the last few months?
Jane Beale - Something about her not wanting to attend the funeral really rung alarm bells at me, why didn't she want to turn up? I do personally feel like Jane loved Lucy but can't say I've seen Jane acting like her normal self? she has acted shifty since day 1 after she 'found out' Lucy had been murdered?
Abi Branning - She has acted really weird, not been in the Soap much, she said last night she knew about Max and Lucy and she has been quite angry and heartless over it all? I also think she could of wrote the note of 'Rot in hell' too!?
Les Coker - A really dark shifty character who I can't get my head around but he is definitely one to watch!?
My suspects of who wrote the note!
Aleks - I think he is my MAJOR suspect. He never seemed to like her, could of knocked him back unknown to anyone? And maybe feels sorry for Jake so he is taking it out on her?
Masood - I think he was always jealous of the way Lucy and the kids came before him with Jane and could be quite bitter towards her?
Opinions on my opinions or anymore?
Whitney Dean - I think Whitney is being suprisingly heartless and emotionless over it all and it is sending alarm bells to me.
Johnny Carter - Being bestfriends with Whitney and his Brother being Lee, maybe he thought enough was enough with the blonde, would of given him a great enterance into the show. But he also seems quite heartless about it all.
Ben Mitchell - He killed before, he is returning. Something just tells me he has something to do with it. To get back at Ian?
Nick Cotton - Well I personally don't think he is dead in any way at all, but I do think that Charlie is still in contact with him, after Charlies and Ians heated clash over Nick's 'supposed to be death' could it have been Evil Nicks revenge in killing Lucy for Ians constant diss of Nick?
Billy Mitchell - Always the runt of the litter of the Mitchell clan, but Lucy shunted Billy of being apart of LB lettings before any major business was put together, could he try and prove himself a Mitchell, not seen much of a emotional wimpy Billy in the last few months?
Jane Beale - Something about her not wanting to attend the funeral really rung alarm bells at me, why didn't she want to turn up? I do personally feel like Jane loved Lucy but can't say I've seen Jane acting like her normal self? she has acted shifty since day 1 after she 'found out' Lucy had been murdered?
Abi Branning - She has acted really weird, not been in the Soap much, she said last night she knew about Max and Lucy and she has been quite angry and heartless over it all? I also think she could of wrote the note of 'Rot in hell' too!?
Les Coker - A really dark shifty character who I can't get my head around but he is definitely one to watch!?
My suspects of who wrote the note!
Aleks - I think he is my MAJOR suspect. He never seemed to like her, could of knocked him back unknown to anyone? And maybe feels sorry for Jake so he is taking it out on her?
Masood - I think he was always jealous of the way Lucy and the kids came before him with Jane and could be quite bitter towards her?
Opinions on my opinions or anymore?
0
Comments
As far as Masood is concerned, Jane wouldn't have slept with Ian if Lucy hadn't died. Maybe he blames Lucy for it, so has decided she can rot in hell.
Brilliant theory!
We saw how Mas went out of control when Carol dumped him for David so we know he has a nasty streak!
The Kilker - Abi
David Wicks, he's my prime suspect. I've got a feeling
The Killer: No one notable [big kudos to TPTB at EastEnders if it's a major character AKA not Aleks, Les Coker, though...]
The people saying it's Abi make me LOL.
I think Whitney for the obvious reasons- she always hated Lucy, and all the stress of Carole then her fallout with Jonny and Lucy could have led to the attack. However I don't think she meant it on purpose to kill her and maybe she was drunk when she did it.
I agree with your reasons for Billy.
I think DTC is fooling everyone with Charlie. The majority are convinced he's a nice guy but I've got a gut feeling he's up to something sinister.
I think Whitney was the one who wrote the note.
As for the person who wrote the "rot in hell" note the fact that Tamwar seems to realise he recognises the handwriting over time makes me wonder if it was Aleks. If it wasn't for the fact he recognises it I'd be 100% convinced and certain it's Whitney but now I'm not so sure really. Aleks definitely has something to hide.
Jake isn’t responsible. Yes it was him she met having received the email/text on her phone. Although it wasn’t meant for her she was curious, as I think she thought that it was the person who took the photo of her and max and they were going to expose it to Lauren. When she got there he was totally off his face and she brought him home as he has said. She got him inside, maybe they had a bit of a barney as she tried to find the evidence of the picture he took and the cut to her head, that she got in the car lot, started bleeding again and she tried to clean it, knocking out her earring – hence the blood and the earring in the flat.
Jake will be cleared as Nick is alive and was trying to track down Charlie by finding his mum (who I reckon lives on the common) – he was there that night and witnessed what actually happened and will ultimately be the one who solves the case with the police – I think that’s where his story comes into it. I also think the family picture hanging in the restaurant will prove to be a clue, I think someone will spot that Lucy had an injury to her head then before her death!!
I reckon Nick assaulted Charlie’s mum and Charlie found out so using his police skills tracked Nick down and paid another drug dealer to bump him off. However, that went wrong and Nick ended up killing the dealer, so Charlie struck a deal with him that he would cover it up and pretend that it was in fact Nick that died in exchange for him leaving Charlie’s mum alone. Charlie enlisted the help of Coker and in with the coffin was the drug dealer and the murder weapon which is why they didn’t want Dot to open it.
As for who / what did kill Lucy I’m still undecided – but as for the Rot in Hell card – I think that’s Aleks – as I think Tam will recognise his writing from working with him – and I think its from him because he secretly loves Jake and has been left wondering if Jake was also seeing Lucy.
I do however think a further shocker later this year will be that her phone (which is missing remember) will be found in the Beale’s house! - leading us to believe it must have been one of them, when in actual fact its been planted there by someone when they came to pay their respects.
I don’t think Sharon’s upcoming attack will be linked in any way – although we may be led to believe at first that it’s a possibility
She saw him at or near the common, realised he wasn't dead and so he killed her to stop the truth from coming out.
The rot in hell card, I think was Whitney or Abi.
The killer: a Mitchell, Masood or, I'm beginning to think, maybe Tosh.
Whit (Sent the Note)
Ben (Attacks Sharon)
Not Masood as Tamwar would have recognised it at the funeral, defo Aleks
I think Whitney wrote the note. I think Tam doesn't recognize her handwriting just now, but in a few episodes there'll be a reason for her to write something and he'll see it then.
Yeah - good one.
Murder: Jane
Nite: Whitney
Whitney wrote the note and Aleks will be the one who supplied the drugs.
As for the note, it's definitely Whitney who wrote it. He reactions during the service, the burial and the wake gave her away.